A Sequential Monte Carlo Method for Data Assimilation in Subsurface Flow Systems with Hierarchical Uncertainty
Organizations: Department of Energy Science and Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
Abstract
Subsurface flow systems often involve hierarchical geological uncertainty, meaning both higher-level metaparameters and cell-by-cell properties are uncertain. This leads to challenges for data assimilation because both sets of parameters must be estimated. In this work we develop an adaptive-tempered sequential Monte Carlo (SMC) procedure for joint Bayesian estimation of these quantities. The method uses noncentered geological parameterizations, with geomodel realizations represented by metaparameters and Gaussian latent variables that are independent under the prior. Adaptive likelihood tempering, importance weighting, resampling, and blockwise Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) mutation are applied at each iteration. Flow surrogates are used for all function evaluations. The hierarchical SMC procedure is further extended to treat successive data assimilation. In this case, existing posterior particles are updated in a manner that accounts for correlations in surrogate model errors across observation batches. We consider two distinct 3D systems with hierarchical uncertainty. The first is a faulted carbon storage system containing three stacked aquifers and two extensive faults. Principal component analysis is used to represent target-aquifer heterogeneity, while geological metaparameters characterize uncertain aquifer and fault properties. The second is a channelized oil-water system containing three facies with uncertain properties. A latent diffusion model represents variability in channel geometry and facies realizations. For the four synthetic true models considered, SMC posterior metaparameter distributions and flow predictions agree closely with reference MCMC results. SMC, however, requires fewer function evaluations and provides speedups of 2.5--7.0 for single-stage data assimilation. Even greater speedups are achieved with multiple GPUs.
Figures & tables
| Metaparameter | Prior distribution |
| Target aquifer | |
| Mean of log-permeability, | |
| Standard deviation of log-permeability, | |
| Permeability anisotropy ratio, | |
| Coefficient in log-permeability–porosity expression, | |
| Metaparameter | Prior distribution |
| Geometric metaparameters | |
| Average channel width, | cells |
| Average channel orientation, | |
| Mud fraction, | |
| Petrophysical metaparameters | |
| Case 1A | Case 3 | |||
| Quantity | MCMC | SMC | MCMC | SMC |
| Elapsed time (h) | 19.8 | 6.6 | 20.3 | 7.8 |
| Function evaluations | ||||
| Approach | Description | Elapsed time (h) | Function evaluations |
|---|---|---|---|
| MCMC | Rerun from the start using all observations | 50.0 | |
| SMC | Rerun from the start using all observations | 17.4 | |
| Successive SMC | Update year-6 posterior using new observations | 4.9 | |
| Successive SMC | Total cost for Case 1A and the successive update | 11.5 |
| Case 2 | Case 4 | |||
| Quantity | MCMC | SMC | MCMC | SMC |
| Elapsed time (h) | 9.8 | 4.0 | 30.1 | 4.3 |
| Function evaluations | ||||
Appendix figures & tables16 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Network | Layer | Output size |
| Spatial encoder | Input | |
| Residual block, 32 filters | ||
| 2 residual blocks, 32 filters, | ||
| 2 residual blocks, 64 filters, | ||
| 2 residual blocks, 128 filters, | ||
| 2 residual blocks, 256 filters, |
Data Assimilation
Data assimilation combines observations with dynamical models to estimate hidden system states and their uncertainty over time.
See all 64 papers