cs.CVNov 10, 2026

How Hyperbolic Are Hyperbolic Vision-Language Models?

Authors: Freek Byrman, Partha Das, Stijn Verdenius, Pascal Mettes

Organizations: University of Amsterdam · WAIR

Abstract

Hyperbolic vision-language models (VLMs) have emerged as a rapidly growing area of research, reporting strong zero-shot performance alongside an interpretable embedding space in which radius orders representations by generality. But how hyperbolic are hyperbolic VLMs in practice? We investigate this at the exponential map, the single operation through which curvature enters an otherwise Euclidean network. We show that across MERU, HyCoCLIP, ARGENT, and PHyCLIP, the exponential map is well approximated by the identity function, i.e., pairwise distances and angles in the pre-map Euclidean space barely change under projection, and removing the map at inference leaves evaluation scores unchanged. Motivated by this observation, we train Euclidean VLMs on CC3M from scratch under the same hierarchy losses. Over roughly the final 90% of the training steps, the training statistics are nearly indistinguishable from those of their hyperbolic counterparts, and the resulting models match the evaluation scores and recover the same radial distributions. Our findings establish Euclidean space as a sufficient substrate for hierarchical vision-language learning as it is currently practiced, and motivate new paradigms in which hyperbolic geometry can deliver on its theoretical promise. Code is available at https://github.com/fbyrman/hyperbolic-vlms.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables10 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Jul 6, 2026

Is the Geometry Doing the Work? An Operating-Point Audit of Hierarchy in Hyperbolic Vision-Language Models

Hyperbolic vision-language models are designed to encode abstraction geometrically: general concepts near the origin, specific ones farther out, and entailment cones representing directed order. We ask whether trained MERU, HyCoCLIP, and PHyCLIP models actually use these mechanisms. We audit seven released checkpoints and matched from-scratch interventions. All audited converged checkpoints remain near-Euclidean in the dimensionless radius u=cρu=\sqrt{c}ρ: the largest observed image-side value is 0.370.37 -- well below u≈0.84u\approx0.84, where local metric distortion reaches 10%10\%. Releasing the curvature floor changes curvature and norms but not this regime, with mixed, generally modest downstream shifts. Trained entailment cones are saturated or nearly saturated, so low violation rates can arise from trivially wide cones rather than learned order. Preregistered semantic traversal detects weak within-branch order but no operative full-hierarchy readout. Shuffle-controlled tests detect no pair-specific radial ordering in released checkpoints, and no positive result is consistent across all three matched ViT-B seeds. This non-detection is sensitivity-bounded: the diagnostic reaches 80%80\% power only at ≈13.5\approx13.5 pp of shuffle-controlled excess, while the largest released gap is ≈5\approx5 pp. We trace this to a low-curvature shortcut: lowering curvature widens entailment cones and suppresses violations without learning order. In the probed trajectories, gradient decomposition identifies entailment as the dominant curvature-lowering pressure during collapse. Yet curvature contracts even when entailment is removed, so the shortcut is not the sole cause. Under our diagnostics, the audited formulations do not demonstrate an operative radial or cone-based hierarchy. We distill the audit into a five-number geometry report for evaluating future hierarchy claims.
Mar 24, 2026

ARGENT: Adaptive Hierarchical Image-Text Representations

Large-scale Vision-Language Models (VLMs) such as CLIP learn powerful semantic representations but operate in Euclidean space, which fails to capture the inherent hierarchical structure of visual and linguistic concepts. Hyperbolic geometry, with its exponential volume growth, offers a principled alternative for embedding such hierarchies with low distortion. However, existing hyperbolic VLMs use entailment losses that are unstable: as parent embeddings contract toward the origin, their entailment cones widen toward a half-space, causing catastrophic cone collapse that destroys the intended hierarchy. Additionally, hierarchical evaluation of these models remains unreliable, being largely retrieval-based and correlation-based metrics and prone to taxonomy dependence and ambiguous negatives. To address these limitations, we propose an adaptive entailment loss paired with a norm regularizer that prevents cone collapse without heuristic aperture clipping. We further introduce an angle-based probabilistic entailment protocol (PEP) for evaluating hierarchical understanding, scored with AUC-ROC and Average Precision. This paper introduces a stronger hyperbolic VLM baseline ARGENT, Adaptive hieRarchical imaGe-tExt represeNTation. ARGENT improves the SOTA hyperbolic VLM by 0.7, 1.1, and 0.8 absolute points on image classification, text-to-image retrieval, and proposed hierarchical metrics, respectively.
Sep 21, 2026

Hierarchical Prompt Learning for Hyperbolic Vision-Language Models

Hyperbolic vision-language models (VLMs) represent image and text features in a geometry naturally suited to hierarchy, but their adaptation to downstream tasks has largely relied on fixed prompts. Existing prompt learning methods, meanwhile, treat class labels as a flat set and do not exploit available taxonomic structure. We address this gap with a hierarchical prompt learning plug-in for frozen hyperbolic VLMs. Given a fixed offline parent-class hierarchy, it augments a class prompt learner with a separate parent prompt learner, parent-level supervision, hyperbolic entailment regularization, and parent-feedback logit fusion. We instantiate the method with CoOp, CoCoOp and MaPLe, yielding HyPLO, CoHyPLO and MaHyPLO. Across the standard 11-dataset benchmark, all variants improve base-to-new generalization and cross-dataset transfer, and remain comparable to their prompt learning baselines under domain shift. Six hierarchical metrics and embedding analyses show that the method produces more taxonomically consistent predictions and induces a hierarchy-consistent organization of parent, class, and image embeddings in hyperbolic space. Its gains are largest when novel classes must be placed within a fixed taxonomy, and smallest for fine-grained confusions among sibling classes or shifts affecting only the image distribution.