Computational Explanations of Semantic Universals
Organizations: Department of Linguistics University of Washington · Department of Psychology and Cognitive Science University of Trento
Abstract
Despite their differences, the languages of the world share many deep features when it comes to how they express meaning. These semantic universals are likely to reflect shared aspects of human cognitive, communicative, and social structure. Recent advances in cross-linguistic semantics and computational linguistics allow us to develop explanations of the sources of such properties. This Element presents a body of work doing just that: we explicate a framework for providing computational explanations of semantic universals and then describe several such explanations using principles of ease of learning and efficient communication. Empirical domains include quantifiers, color terms, modals, and indefinites. After providing these explanations, we provide a discussion of future directions for advancing the explanatory power of computational methods in semantic typology.
Figures & tables
| Expression type | Meaning space | Property | Optimization principle | Section |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Determiners | Generalized quantifiers | Monotonicity | Ease of learning | 2.2 |
| Determiners | Generalized quantifiers | Quantity | Ease of learning | 2.4 |
| Color Terms | CIELab color space | Convexity | Ease of learning | 2.3 |
| Responsive predicates | Possible-world meanings | Veridical uniformity | Ease of learning | 2.5 |
| Determiners | Generalized quantifiers | Conservativity | Ease of learning (mixed) * | 2.6 |
| Determiners | Generalized quantifiers | Monotonicity | Efficient communication | 3.2 |
| Boolean | Set-Theoretic | Numeric |
|---|---|---|
| , , |
| Language | Indefinite pronoun | Flavors | Feature formula | |
| English | someone | specific known, specific unknown, non-specific | 1 | |
| anyone | negative polarity, free choice | 2 | ||
| no one | negative indefinite | 1 | ||
| Russian | kto-to | specific unknown, non-specific | 2 | |
| kto-nibud’ | non-specific | 2 | ||
| kto-libo | non-specific, negative polarity | 5 |
| Semantic flavor | Prior probability |
|---|---|
| specific known | 0.08 |
| specific unknown | 0.08 |
| non-specific | 0.26 |
| negative polarity | 0.33 |
| free choice | 0.1 |
| negative indefinite | 0.15 |
| St’át’imcets k’a | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| epistemic | deontic | ||
| weak | |||
| strong | |||
| epistemic | deontic | circumstantial | |
|---|---|---|---|
| weak | 0.139 | 0.042 | 0.143 |
| strong | 0.104 | 0.254 | 0.318 |
| Modal | Meaning representation | Shortest Formula in LOT | Complexity (# of atoms) |
|---|---|---|---|
| may | 3 | ||
| mought | 4 | ||
| notcirc | 1 |
Linguistic Typology
Linguistic typology compares languages to identify patterns in their sounds, grammar, meaning, and history.
See all 28 papers