cs.CRNov 11, 2026

Beyond Attack-Based Accuracy: Rethinking Adversarial Robustness Evaluation Through Structural Gradient Alignment

Authors: Hanrui Wang, Yu Luo, Shuo Wang, Xingbo Dong, Zhe Jin, Isao Echizen

Organizations: National Institute of Informatics, Tokyo, Japan · Anhui University, Hefei, China · Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China

Abstract

Visual adversarial robustness remains a fundamental security property as vision systems evolve from conventional classifiers to vision-language models (VLMs) and large vision-language models (LVLMs), with visual inputs remaining an attack surface across generations. Yet existing evaluation methods often depend on prescribed attacks, in-distribution data, extensive probing, or classifier-specific formulations, limiting external auditing of diverse models. We introduce Structural Gradient Alignment (SGA), a complementary robustness metric measuring the structural alignment between input content and objective-conditioned local model sensitivity. SGA uses a few randomly sampled, unlabeled public probes that need not follow the downstream task distribution and only one input-gradient computation per model--probe pair. Across 38 distinct DNNs, VLMs, and LVLMs, SGA produces rankings consistent with attack-based references. Without robustness references, uncalibrated SGA achieves 83.72%83.72\% average pairwise agreement across eight public-probe conditions, outperforming the strongest overall baseline in all eight by 9.389.38 percentage points on average. With known robustness orders of anchor models, calibrated SGA increases agreement to 85.36%85.36\%. These results demonstrate an attack-agnostic, computationally efficient robustness signal across conventional DNNs, VLMs, and autoregressive LVLMs, downstream tasks, threat norms, probe distributions, and evaluator-knowledge settings. Our implementation is available at https://github.com/azrealwang/SGA.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Mar 17, 2026

Adversarial attacks against Modern Vision-Language Models

We study adversarial robustness of open-source vision-language model (VLM) agents deployed in a self-contained e-commerce environment built to simulate realistic pre-deployment conditions. We evaluate two agents, LLaVA-v1.5-7B and Qwen2.5-VL-7B, under three gradient-based attacks: the Basic Iterative Method (BIM), Projected Gradient Descent (PGD), and a CLIP-based spectral attack. Against LLaVA, all three attacks achieve substantial attack success rates (52.6%, 53.8%, and 66.9% respectively), demonstrating that simple gradient-based methods pose a practical threat to open-source VLM agents. Qwen2.5-VL proves significantly more robust across all attacks (6.5%, 7.7%, and 15.5%), suggesting meaningful architectural differences in adversarial resilience between open-source VLM families. These findings have direct implications for the security evaluation of VLM agents prior to commercial deployment.
Mar 13, 2026

What Makes VLMs Robust? Towards Reconciling Robustness and Accuracy in Vision-Language Models

Achieving adversarial robustness in Vision-Language Models (VLMs) inevitably compromises accuracy on clean data, presenting a long-standing and challenging trade-off. In this work, we revisit this trade-off by investigating a fundamental question: What makes VLMs robust? Through a detailed analysis of adversarially fine-tuned models, we examine how robustness mechanisms function internally and how they interact with clean accuracy. Our analysis reveals that adversarial robustness is not uniformly distributed across network depth. Instead, unexpectedly, it is primarily localized within the shallow layers, driven by a low-frequency spectral bias and input-insensitive attention patterns. Meanwhile, updates to the deep layers tend to undermine both clean accuracy and robust generalization. Motivated by these insights, we propose Adversarial Robustness Adaptation (R-Adapt), a simple yet effective framework that freezes all pre-trained weights and introduces minimal, insight-driven adaptations only in the initial layers. This design achieves an exceptional balance between adversarial robustness and clean accuracy. R-Adapt further supports training-free, model-guided, and data-driven paradigms, offering flexible pathways to seamlessly equip standard models with robustness. Extensive evaluations on 18 datasets and diverse tasks demonstrate our state-of-the-art performance under various attacks. Notably, R-Adapt generalizes efficiently to large vision-language models (e.g., LLaVA and Qwen-VL) to enhance their robustness. Our project page is available at https://summu77.github.io/R-Adapt.
Feb 4, 2026

Stage-wise Attention-Guided Region Sequencing for Adversarial Attacks on Large Vision-Language Models

Targeted adversarial attacks on Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) test whether small image perturbations can steer model responses toward attacker-specified content. Under the standard L-infinity constraint, targeted attacks become a regional perturbation budget allocation problem: attack success depends not only on the perturbation objective, but also on which regions receive updates and in what order. Existing localized attacks improve over global perturbations but rely on stochastic spatial sampling, often updating weakly influential regions. We address this limitation through an attention-based analysis showing that cross-modal attention identifies adversarially sensitive regions and that perturbing high-attention hotspots induces predictable redistribution toward subsequent salient regions. These findings motivate attention-guided region sequencing, which begins from dominant hotspots and progressively moves the update support toward next-salient regions. Based on these principles, we propose Stage-wise Attention-Guided Attack (SAGA), a black-box region-sequencing framework that uses a fixed attention map from an open-source LVLM to guide perturbation updates without accessing target-model parameters, gradients, or attention maps. Across ten closed-source and open-source LVLMs, SAGA achieves state-of-the-art attack success rates and the best overall imperceptibility. The source code is available at https://github.com/jaehyun-kwak/SAGA.