cs.AINov 17, 2026

ForecastGym: A Live, Controlled, and Replayable Benchmark for Forecasting Agents

Authors: Yicheng Tao, Yuante Li, Zipei Fan

Organizations: Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA · Jilin University Changchun, China

Abstract

Agents built on large language models (LLMs) increasingly forecast real-world events by searching the Web and reasoning over what they find. How well such an agent forecasts depends on both the retrieved evidence and the model, making control over that evidence essential for evaluation. Live evaluations can mix retrieval with reasoning when each system searches on its own, while retrospective search can leak later information through date filters or today's ranking of historical pages. Comparing models, search sources, and memory strategies requires both fixed evidence and a record of how it evolved before resolution. We introduce ForecastGym, which records what four commercial web search APIs return for open prediction-market questions every two days and replays this frozen evidence offline once outcomes are known, comparing models, memory, and captured search sources under a fixed evidence-acquisition policy. Its first release covers 150 questions, 614 evidence states, one per question and collection time, and 131k search results. Rerunning the same queries after settlement returns results that all but state the outcome for up to 92% of the questions, despite the tested date filters. On the frozen evidence, all tested LLMs trail the market in forecasting accuracy. Our diagnostic analysis suggests that missed public information contributes more to the gap in high-gap states than misreading does. Switching the search API changes a model's Brier score by up to 0.043, more than the spread across models, while persistent notes score similarly to rereading all evidence at half the input tokens. The evidence a forecaster sees can matter as much as the model that reads it.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables10 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. Forecast-Dojo: Replayable Environments for Benchmarking and Training LLM Forecasting Agents

    Sep 24, 2026Liqin Ye, Haorui Wang, Fardin Ahmed +8LLM Agent EvaluationForecasting Benchmarks

  2. Benchmarking Forecasting Agents on Yesterday's Tomorrows

    Oct 29, 2026Yuxuan Wang, Yishu Wang, Jiaqi DengForecasting BenchmarksAI Agent Evaluation

  3. Hindcast: Replaying Prediction Markets to Evaluate LLM Forecasters

    Jul 15, 2026Xiao Ye, Jacob Dineen, Evan Zhu +3LLM EvaluationForecasting Benchmarks