Quenched large deviations for Monte Carlo integration with Coulomb gases

Kernel herding belongs to a family of deterministic quadratures that seek to minimize the maximum mean discrepancy (MMD), that is, the worst-case integration error over a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS). These MMD minimization procedures come with strong experimental support, but comparatively less theoretical footing. In particular, apart from recent progress in distribution compression, little has been proved in favor of an improvement of MMD minimization over classical Monte Carlo quadrature when the RKHS is infinite-dimensional. In this paper, we study a joint probability distribution over quadrature nodes, a tailored Gibbs distribution, whose support intuitively tends to concentrate around MMD minimizers as a temperature parameter is decreased. Our main contribution is to prove that drawing integration nodes from our distribution does outperform i.i.d Monte Carlo. While our bounds on the worst-case integration error feature the same rate as i.i.d. Monte Carlo, we do obtain a tighter concentration inequality as the temperature parameter decreases. This means smaller confidence intervals as the number of quadrature nodes increases. While arguably a first step, our results demonstrate that the mathematical toolbox developed around Gibbs measures can help understand to what extent kernel herding and its variants improve on computationally cheaper methods. There remains the issue of sampling from our Gibbs distribution. In our numerical experiments, we demonstrate that a simple MCMC chain already yields approximate samples that lead to improved confidence intervals around the target integrals, as supported by our theoretical results.

The standard Monte Carlo estimator $\widehat{I}_N^{\mathrm{MC}}$ of $\int fdω$ relies on independent samples from $ω$ and has variance of order $1/N$. Replacing the samples with a determinantal point process (DPP), a repulsive distribution, makes the estimator consistent, with variance rates that depend on how the DPP is adapted to $f$ and $ω$. We examine two existing DPP-based estimators: one by Bardenet & Hardy (2020) with a rate of $\mathcal{O}(N^{-(1+1/d)})$ for smooth $f$, but relying on a fixed DPP. The other, by Ermakov & Zolotukhin (1960), is unbiased with rate of order $1/N$, like Monte Carlo, but its DPP is tailored to $f$. We revisit these estimators, generalize them to continuous settings, and provide sampling algorithms.

Bayesian quadrature is a probabilistic, model-based approach to numerical integration, the estimation of intractable integrals, or expectations. Although Bayesian quadrature was popularised already in the 1980s, no systematic and comprehensive treatment has been published. The purpose of this survey is to fill this gap. We review the mathematical foundations of Bayesian quadrature from different points of view; present a systematic taxonomy for classifying different Bayesian quadrature methods along the three axes of modelling, inference, and sampling; collect general theoretical guarantees; and provide a controlled numerical study that explores and illustrates the effect of different choices along the axes of the taxonomy. We also provide a realistic assessment of practical challenges and limitations to application of Bayesian quadrature methods and include an up-to-date and nearly exhaustive bibliography that covers not only machine learning and statistics literature but all areas of mathematics and engineering in which Bayesian quadrature or equivalent methods have seen use.