cs.CVMar 5, 2026

HARP: HARmonizing in-vivo diffusion MRI using Phantom-only training

Authors: Hwihun Jeong, Qiang Liu, Kathryn E. Keenan, Elisabeth A. Wilde, Walter Schneider, Sudhir Pathak, Anthony Zuccolotto, Lauren J. O'Donnell, +2 more

Organizations: Department of Psychiatry, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America · College of Engineering, Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America · Physical Measurement Laboratory, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Boulder, Colorado, United States of America · Department of Neurology, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, Utah, United States of America · George E. Wahlen Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Salt Lake City, Utah, United States of America · University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania , United States of America · Psychology Software Tools, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania , United States of America · Department of Radiology, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America · Harvard-MIT Health Sciences and Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States of America

Abstract

Purpose: Combining multi-site diffusion MRI (dMRI) data is hindered by inter-scanner variability, which confounds subsequent analysis. Previous harmonization methods require large, matched or traveling human subjects from multiple sites, which are impractical to acquire in many situations. This study aims to develop a deep learning-based dMRI harmonization framework that eliminates the reliance on multi-site in-vivo traveling human data for training. Methods: HARP employs a voxel-wise 1D neural network trained on an easily transportable diffusion phantom. The model learns relationships between spherical harmonics coefficients of different sites without memorizing spatial structures. Results: HARP reduced inter-scanner variability levels significantly in various measures. Quantitatively, it decreased inter-scanner variability as measured by standard error in FA (12%), MD (10%), and GFA (30%) with scan-rescan standard error as the baseline, while preserving fiber orientations and tractography after harmonization. Conclusion: We believe that HARP represents an important first step toward dMRI harmonization using only phantom data, thereby obviating the need for complex, matched in vivo multi-site cohorts. This phantom-only strategy substantially enhances the feasibility and scalability of quantitative dMRI for large-scale clinical studies.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Feb 25, 2026

IHF-Harmony: Multi-Modality Magnetic Resonance Images Harmonization using Invertible Hierarchy Flow Model

Retrospective MRI harmonization is limited by poor scalability across modalities and reliance on traveling subject datasets. To address these challenges, we introduce IHF-Harmony, a unified invertible hierarchy flow framework for multi-modality harmonization using unpaired data. By decomposing the translation process into reversible feature transformations, IHF-Harmony guarantees bijective mapping and lossless reconstruction to prevent anatomical distortion. Specifically, an invertible hierarchy flow (IHF) performs hierarchical subtractive coupling to progressively remove artefact-related features, while an artefact-aware normalization (AAN) employs anatomy-fixed feature modulation to accurately transfer target characteristics. Combined with anatomy and artefact consistency loss objectives, IHF-Harmony achieves high-fidelity harmonization that retains source anatomy. Experiments across multiple MRI modalities demonstrate that IHF-Harmony outperforms existing methods in both anatomical fidelity and downstream task performance, facilitating robust harmonization for large-scale multi-site imaging studies. Code is available at https://github.com/Idea89560041/IHF-Harmony.
Mar 17, 2026

SA-CycleGAN-2.5D: Self-Attention CycleGAN with Tri-Planar Context for Multi-Site MRI Harmonization

Multi-site neuroimaging analysis is fundamentally confounded by scanner-induced covariate shifts, where the marginal distribution of voxel intensities P(x)P(\mathbf{x}) varies non-linearly across acquisition protocols while the conditional anatomy P(y∣x)P(\mathbf{y}|\mathbf{x}) remains constant. This is particularly detrimental to radiomic reproducibility, where acquisition variance often exceeds biological pathology variance. Existing statistical harmonization methods (e.g., ComBat) operate in feature space, precluding spatial downstream tasks, while standard deep learning approaches are theoretically bounded by local effective receptive fields (ERF), failing to model the global intensity correlations characteristic of field-strength bias. We propose SA-CycleGAN-2.5D, a domain adaptation framework motivated by the HΔHHΔH-divergence bound of Ben-David et al., integrating three architectural innovations: (1) A 2.5D tri-planar manifold injection preserving through-plane gradients ∇z\nabla_z at O(HW)O(HW) complexity; (2) A U-ResNet generator with dense voxel-to-voxel self-attention, surpassing the O(L)O(\sqrt{L}) receptive field limit of CNNs to model global scanner field biases; and (3) A spectrally-normalized discriminator constraining the Lipschitz constant (KD≤1K_D \le 1) for stable adversarial optimization. Evaluated on 654 glioma patients across two institutional domains (BraTS and UPenn-GBM), our method reduces Maximum Mean Discrepancy (MMD) by 99.1% (1.729→0.0151.729 \to 0.015) and degrades domain classifier accuracy to near-chance (59.7%). Ablation confirms that global attention is statistically essential (Cohen's d=1.32d = 1.32, p<0.001p < 0.001) for the harder heterogeneous-to-homogeneous translation direction. By bridging 2D efficiency and 3D consistency, our framework yields voxel-level harmonized images that preserve tumor pathophysiology, enabling reproducible multi-center radiomic analysis.
Mar 18, 2026

Robust-ComBat: Mitigating Outlier Effects in Diffusion MRI Data Harmonization

Harmonization methods such as ComBat and its variants are widely used to mitigate diffusion MRI (dMRI) site-specific biases. However, ComBat assumes that subject distributions exhibit a Gaussian profile. In practice, patients with neurological disorders often present diffusion metrics that deviate markedly from those of healthy controls, introducing pathological outliers that distort site-effect estimation. This problem is particularly challenging in clinical practice as most patients undergoing brain imaging have an underlying and yet undiagnosed condition, making it difficult to exclude them from harmonization cohorts, as their scans were precisely prescribed to establish a diagnosis. In this paper, we show that harmonizing data to a normative reference population with ComBat while including pathological cases induces significant distortions. Across 7 neurological conditions, we evaluated 10 outlier rejection methods with 4 ComBat variants over a wide range of scenarios, revealing that many filtering strategies fail in the presence of pathology. In contrast, a simple MLP provides robust outlier compensation enabling reliable harmonization while preserving disease-related signal. Experiments on both control and real multi-site cohorts, comprising up to 80% of subjects with neurological disorders, demonstrate that Robust-ComBat consistently outperforms conventional statistical baselines with lower harmonization error across all ComBat variants.