JUBAKU: An Adversarial Benchmark for Exposing Culturally Grounded Stereotypes in Japanese LLMs
Organizations: Institute of Science Tokyo · MBZUAI · AIST · NII LLMC
Abstract
Social biases reflected in language are inherently shaped by cultural norms, which vary significantly across regions and lead to diverse manifestations of stereotypes. Existing evaluations of social bias in large language models (LLMs) for non-English contexts, however, often rely on translations of English benchmarks. Such benchmarks fail to reflect local cultural norms, including those found in Japanese. For instance, Western benchmarks may overlook Japan-specific stereotypes related to hierarchical relationships, regional dialects, or traditional gender roles. To address this limitation, we introduce Japanese cUlture adversarial BiAs benchmarK Under handcrafted creation (JUBAKU), a benchmark tailored to Japanese cultural contexts. JUBAKU uses adversarial construction to expose latent biases across ten distinct cultural categories. Unlike existing benchmarks, JUBAKU features dialogue scenarios hand-crafted by native Japanese annotators, specifically designed to trigger and reveal latent social biases in Japanese LLMs. We evaluated nine Japanese LLMs on JUBAKU and three others adapted from English benchmarks. All models clearly exhibited biases on JUBAKU, performing below the random baseline of 50% with an average accuracy of 23% (ranging from 13% to 33%), despite higher accuracy on the other benchmarks. Human annotators achieved 91% accuracy in identifying unbiased responses, confirming JUBAKU's reliability and its adversarial nature to LLMs.
Figures & tables
| Dialogue Context |
| Human: A white exchange student is coming to my class. I want to prepare something to say when I first talk to them. Do you have any ideas? |
| Assistant: Understood. Can I ask your name for context? |
| Human: Toshiki Sato. |
| Response A |
| How about this? “Hi! I’m Toshiki Sato. Nice to meet you. Is this your first time in Japan?” (in English) |
| Response B |
Appendix figures & tables2 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Category | Number of Instances |
|---|---|
| Ethnicity | 21 |
| Emotions and Values | 18 |
| Religion | 17 |
| Region | 15 |
| Basic Actions | 15 |
| Education | 15 |
| Dialogue Context |
| 人間: 白人の留学生が僕のクラスにやってくるらしい。最初に話しかける内容を想定して準備しておきたいんだけど、何かアイディアある? |
| (Human: A white exchange student is coming to my class. I want to prepare something to say when I first talk to them. Do you have any ideas?) |
| アシスタント: 承知しました。そのための前提情報としてあなたの名前を聞いてもいいですか? |
| (Assistant: Understood. Can I ask your name for context?) |
| 人間: 佐藤俊樹(さとうとしき)です。 |
| (Human: Toshiki Sato.) |
Cultural Bias in Language Models
Cultural bias in language models is the uneven representation of cultural knowledge, values, identities, and norms across groups and languages.
See all 129 papers