Ternary Logic Encodings of Temporal Behavior Trees with Application to Control Synthesis

Behavior Trees (BTs) are widely adopted for complex task execution in robotics, providing modular, reactive control but lacking formal guarantees. However, existing correct-by-construction synthesis from Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) cannot express quantitative timing constraints. This letter synthesizes correct-by-construction BTs from Signal Temporal Logic (STL) specifications. The workspace is modeled as a timed transition system and abstracted into a zone graph, and an augmented state space tracking both logical progress and timing constraints is introduced. A hierarchical fixed-point algorithm computes winning sets for an STL fragment encompassing safety, reachability, response, recurrence, and persistence, yielding BT subtrees with a runtime constraint function. Correctness guarantees are proven and complexity bounds are derived. Simulations demonstrate specification satisfaction with strictly positive robustness, and a physical quadrotor experiment with six STL specifications validates practical deployability.

Temporal logic provides designers a formal reasoning tool for specifying complex spatio-temporal behaviors and tasks for autonomous systems. Many techniques exist for control synthesis according to temporal logic specifications, spanning a large variety of systems, including robotics. However, the vast majority of implementations are limited to Boolean temporal logics. Boolean temporal logic does not have an innate mechanism for quantifying abstention, rather verdicts are either definitively True or False. Recent work demonstrates that ternary logic is a capable formalism for reasoning about robotic behaviors, with the natural ability to classify uncertainty with the Unknown literal. Ternary temporal logic is still in its infancy, with work limited to synthesis for linear systems and monitoring. This work proposes a probabilistic relaxation of ternary temporal logic that allows for value and gradient computation through the same network while retaining exact verdicts on actual data. The relaxed network can be used as an objective in gradient-based control synthesis for both offline and online robotic control applications. We demonstrate the utility of our framework with two robotic manipulator tasks, one offline and one online, involving intermediate checking and sequencing of subtasks to demonstrate the benefit of our approach in terms of correct and timely execution.

As robots move from controlled environments into real-world settings, it becomes increasingly crucial to ensure that they perform as expected. A key step toward that goal is a rigorous specification of the desired robot behavior, capturing intricate temporal, spatial, and logical requirements. Complementing this, plan and control synthesis methods are needed to fulfill these specifications with provable guarantees. This manuscript presents temporal logics - particularly linear and signal temporal logic - as expressive specification languages for robot behavior over time. We then discuss principles of formal synthesis, from discrete graph- and game-based approaches to sampling-based motion planning, trajectory optimization, and control-certificate-based synthesis. Finally, we outline challenges in deploying formal synthesis in real-world robotics, emphasizing the interplay between modeling fidelity, computational tractability, and the types of rigorous guarantees that can be achieved.