cs.CLApr 21, 2026

Disparities In Negation Understanding Across Languages In Vision-Language Models

Authors: Charikleia MoraitakiSarah PanSkyler PullingGwendolyn FluscheKumail AlhamoudMarzyeh Ghassemi

Organizations: Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Abstract

Vision-language models (VLMs) exhibit affirmation bias: a systematic tendency to select positive captions ("X is present") even when the correct description contains negation ("no X"). While prior work has documented this failure mode in English and proposed solutions, negation manifests differently across languages through varying morphology, word order, and cliticization patterns, raising the question of whether these solutions serve all linguistic communities equitably. We introduce the first human-verified multilingual negation benchmark, spanning seven typologically diverse languages: English, Mandarin Chinese, Arabic, Greek, Russian, Tagalog, and Spanish. Evaluating three VLMs - CLIP, SigLIP, and MultiCLIP - we find that standard CLIP performs at or below chance on non-Latin-script languages, while MultiCLIP achieves the highest and most uniform accuracy. We also evaluate SpaceVLM, a proposed negation correction, and find that it produces substantial improvements for several languages - particularly English, Greek, Spanish, and Tagalog - while showing varied effectiveness across typologically different languages. This variation reveals that linguistic properties like morphology, script, and negation structure interact with model improvements in fairness-relevant ways. As VLMs are deployed globally, multilingual benchmarks are essential for understanding not just whether solutions work, but for whom.

Explore similar work

Jun 22, 2026cs.CV

HANCLIP: A Family of Hyperbolic Angular Negation Vision Language Models

Vision-language models (VLMs) achieve strong cross-modal alignment but remain brittle to negation, often relying on shallow word associations rather than compositional reasoning. Fine-tuning on negation-specific data can also compromise their general purpose capabilities through catastrophic forgetting. We introduce HANCLIP (Hyperbolic, Angular, and Negation), a geometry-aware framework that improves negation sensitivity while preserving the structure of the pretrained joint embedding space. HANCLIP combines a hyperbolic contrastive objective, which models hierarchical relations and semantic asymmetries, with an angular triplet loss that separates negated descriptions from their affirmative counterparts. Using only 20,000 image-text quadruplets, HANCLIP consistently improves performance across CLIP, LongCLIP, and SmartCLIP backbones on the NegBench benchmark, while maintaining or improving zero-shot classification and image-text retrieval performance. These results show that lightweight, geometry-guided objectives can enhance negation understanding without large-scale retraining.
Hoang-Bao Le, Aiden Durrant, Thai Son Mai +3
Apr 21, 2026cs.CL

Lost in Translation: Do LVLM Judges Generalize Across Languages?

Automatic evaluators such as reward models play a central role in the alignment and evaluation of large vision-language models (LVLMs). Despite their growing importance, these evaluators are almost exclusively assessed on English-centric benchmarks, leaving open the question of how well these evaluators generalize across languages. To answer this question, we introduce MM-JudgeBench, the first large-scale benchmark for multilingual and multimodal judge model evaluation, which includes over 60K pairwise preference instances spanning 25 typologically diverse languages. MM-JudgeBench integrates two complementary subsets: a general vision-language preference evaluation subset extending VL-RewardBench, and a chart-centric visual-text reasoning subset derived from OpenCQA, enabling systematic analysis of reward models (i.e., LVLM judges) across diverse settings. We additionally release a multilingual training set derived from MM-RewardBench, disjoint from our evaluation data, to support domain adaptation. By evaluating 22 LVLMs (15 open-source, 7 proprietary), we uncover substantial cross-lingual performance variance in our proposed benchmark. Our analysis further shows that model size and architecture are poor predictors of multilingual robustness, and that even state-of-the-art LVLM judges exhibit inconsistent behavior across languages. Together, these findings expose fundamental limitations of current reward modeling and underscore the necessity of multilingual, multimodal benchmarks for developing reliable automated evaluators.
Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Mohammed Saidul Islam, Mir Tafseer Nayeem +5
Apr 20, 2026cs.CL

Multilingual Training and Evaluation Resources for Vision-Language Models

Vision Language Models (VLMs) achieved rapid progress in the recent years. However, despite their growth, VLMs development is heavily grounded on English, leading to two main limitations: (i) the lack of multilingual and multimodal datasets for training, and (ii) the scarcity of comprehensive evaluation benchmarks across languages. In this work, we address these gaps by introducing a new comprehensive suite of resources for VLMs training and evaluation spanning five European languages (English, French, German, Italian, and Spanish). We adopt a regeneration-translation paradigm that produces high-quality cross-lingual resources by combining curated synthetic generation and manual annotation. Specifically, we build Multi-PixMo, a training corpus obtained regenerating examples from Pixmo pre-existing datasets with permissively licensed models: PixMo-Cap, PixMo-AskModelAnything, and CoSyn-400k. On the evaluation side, we construct a set of multilingual benchmarks derived translating widely used English datasets (MMbench, ScienceQA, MME, POPE, AI2D). We assess the quality of these resources through qualitative and quantitative human analyses, measuring inter-annotator agreement. Additionally, we perform ablation studies to demonstrate the impact of multilingual data, with respect to English only, in VLMs training. Experiments, comprising 3 different models show that using multilingual, multimodal examples for training VLMs aids is consistently beneficial on non-English benchmarks, with positive transfer to English as well.
Daniela Baiamonte, Elena Fano, Matteo Gabburo +3