Lost in Decoding? Reproducing and Stress-Testing the Look-Ahead Prior in Generative Retrieval
Authors: Kidist Amde Mekonnen, Yongkang Li, Yubao Tang, Simon Lupart, Maarten de Rijke
Organizations: University of Amsterdam Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract
Generative retrieval (GR) ranks documents by autoregressively generating document identifiers. Because many GR methods rely on trie-constrained beam search, they are vulnerable to early pruning of relevant prefixes under finite-beam decoding. Planning Ahead in Generative Retrieval (PAG) mitigates this failure mode by using simultaneous decoding to compute a document-level look-ahead prior that guides subsequent sequential decoding. We reproduce PAG at inference time and stress-test its decoding behavior. Using the authors' released checkpoint and identifier/trie artifacts under the reported decoding setup, we reproduce the main effectiveness results on MS MARCO Dev and TREC-DL 2019/2020, and corroborate the reported beam-size-latency trade-off in our hardware setting. Beyond reproduction, we introduce plan drift diagnostics that quantify how intent-preserving query variations alter the planner's top-n candidate set and highest-weight planner tokens, and how these changes affect guided decoding. We find that PAG's planning signal is brittle under lexical surface-form variation: intent-preserving typos can trigger plan collapse, where the planned candidate pool shifts enough that the look-ahead bonus provides little useful guidance, effectively reverting decoding toward weaker unguided search. We further evaluate fixed-index cross-lingual robustness using non-English mMARCO queries against an English index, and assess query-side mitigation strategies that require no re-indexing; query translation provides the strongest recovery in our setting. Overall, our results confirm PAG's reported effectiveness and the benefit of planning-guided decoding under the released inference setup, while showing that these gains depend on the stability of the planning signal under realistic query variation and query-document mismatch.
Constrained decoding is essential in generative retrieval, where document identifiers generated directly from a query must exactly match a predefined library of valid IDs. At scale, decoding is often constrained using a trie with beam search but most implementations run on CPU. Limited parallelism then makes trie traversal and candidate validation a serving bottleneck as beam width grows. We present FlashTrie, which addresses this limitation by optimizing constrained beam search on GPUs. It introduces an integer-aware succinct trie layout that uses bit compression to reduce memory footprint while keeping the full index in GPU high-bandwidth memory reducing memory stalls, and a cooperative CUDA kernel that performs beam expansion, validation, and pruning entirely on-device without per-step host orchestration. It further replaces CPU-style irregular lookup and heap maintenance with GPU-aware parallel primitives, improving warp utilization and reducing divergence. Together, these designs significantly reduce decoding latency and increase throughput while preserving retrieval quality. On a library of 800M keywords with beam widths up to 1000, FlashTrie reduces trie-search latency to under 3 ms, achieving up to 24x speedup over a highly optimized multi-threaded CPU baseline. These improvements enable FlashTrie to scale beam sizes by up to 5x in latency-critical applications such as sponsored search. In a large-scale online A/B experiment on a popular commercial search engine, it delivers a statistically significant +0.71% revenue lift, enabling real-time constrained decoding at a scale previously feasible only offline. The FlashTrie code will be publicly released after the review process.
Dakshitha Anandakumar, Anurag Mukkara, Wenxiang Hu +5
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) improves factual grounding in large language models but suffers from substantial latency due to synchronous retrieval. While recent work explores asynchronous retrieval, existing approaches rely on heuristic coordination between retrieval and generation and assume stable information demands during decoding that often break in complex, multi-domain settings. In this paper, we propose an advanced asynchronous retrieval framework that enables predictive prefetching aligned with evolving information needs. The framework explicitly predicts when retrieval should be triggered and what information should be retrieved using three components, a retrieval predictor, a context monitor, and a query generator, by exploiting semantic precursors in generation dynamics that emerge several tokens before uncertainty becomes critical. Experiments on multiple benchmarks demonstrate up to 43.5% end-to-end latency reduction and 62.4% improvement in time-to-first-token, while maintaining answer quality comparable to synchronous RAG baselines.
As retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems scale, it becomes increasingly challenging to ensure faithful grounding in external evidence. Large language models may still prioritize parametric knowledge over retrieved information when conflicts arise. We propose a novel training-free decoding framework, \emph{Grounded Decoding}, designed to improve factual consistency in RAG without modifying model parameters. Unlike standard approaches that rely on a single conditional distribution, our method constructs two matched-prompt distributions at every generation step: (1) a full RAG distribution conditioned on the query, retrieved documents, and generated prefix, and (2) a retrieval-only distribution conditioned solely on retrieved evidence and the same prefix. The final next-token distribution is derived as the unique solution to a KL-barycenter objective over the probability simplex, yielding a normalized geometric fusion of the two distributions.This formulation naturally recovers standard RAG when the grounding weight is zero and smoothly shifts probability mass toward retrieved evidence as grounding strength increases. We further introduce a conflict-aware adaptive weighting scheme that dynamically adjusts grounding based on distributional disagreement and retriever confidence. Experiments on ALCE, Natural Questions, and FActScore demonstrate consistent improvements in factual accuracy and citation quality over standard RAG and competitive decoding-time baselines, while maintaining fluency. Our results indicate that probability-level fusion provides a strong and efficient alternative to logit-level intervention methods for faithful RAG decoding.