FlowMoDL: Model-Based Deep Learning with Conjugate-Gradient Data Consistency for Highly Accelerated 4D Flow MRI Reconstruction
Authors: Tristan Gottwald, Michelle Bruch, Mubashir-Ul Hassan, Fatma Alickovic, Milan Kloiber, Daniel Tenbrinck, Torsten Panholzer, Melanie Schaller, +1 more
Organizations: Institute of Information Processing (tnt), Leibniz University Hannover, Germany · L3S, Leibniz University Hannover, Hannover, Germany · Department of Data Science, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany · CAIMED, Leibniz University Hannover, Hannover, Germany · Institute of Medical Biostatistics, Epidemiology and Informatics, University Medical Center of the Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Germany
We present FlowMoDL, an unrolled neural network for highly accelerated 4D flow MRI reconstruction that directly optimizes for both anatomical magnitude and phase-derived velocity accuracy. Building on the MoDL framework, FlowMoDL alternates a learned (3+1)D spatiotemporal denoiser with conjugate-gradient data-consistency updates based on the SENSE forward model. A novel dual-pathway conditioning scheme adapts the denoiser features and data-consistency weighting, enabling a single model to handle varying acceleration factors (10× to 50×). To ensure physiological accuracy, the network is trained using a deep-supervision composite loss that explicitly penalizes velocity magnitude and angular errors, stabilized by a curriculum schedule. We evaluate FlowMoDL on the multi-center CMRx4DFlow dataset against classical and deep-learning baselines (CG-SENSE, MoDL, FlowVN, and FlowMRI-Net). A key advantage of FlowMoDL is its superior gradient step efficiency. When evaluated under an equivalent, limited budget of gradient steps, competing flow-specific networks degrade significantly. In contrast, FlowMoDL robustly converges and strictly outperforms all competitors across all acceleration factors in magnitude SSIM, nRMSE, relative velocity error, and angular error, successfully recovering sharp structural details and temporally coherent velocity fields.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Detailed architecture of a single FlowMoDL cascade k (top) and the internal structure of its factorized (3+1)D spatiotemporal blocks (bottom). The network maps the previous estimate x^(k−1) to an intermediate denoised target z(k) using a learned prior Dθk equipped with a global residual connection. To improve the handling of varying acceleration rates, R is routed to both a FiLM generator within the denoiser and an MLP computing the data-consistency penalty weight λk(R) . The cascade concludes by solving the linear data-consistency equations via conjugate-gradient iterations.
Model
nRMSE ( ↓ )
SSIM ( ↑ )
RelErr ( ↓ )
AngErr ( ↓ )
CG-SENSE [ 11 ]
0.1592
0.6831
0.7087
45.6948
FlowVN [ 15 ]
0.2311 ± 0.0061
0.4687 ± 0.0200
2.1668 ± 0.0648
79.8481 ± 0.4238
FlowMRI-Net [ 6 ]
0.2126 ± 0.0540
0.6325 ± 0.0602
0.8660 ± 0.0741
69.2204 ± 3.7776
MoDL [ 1 ]
0.1147 ± 0.0035
0.8062 ± 0.0095
0.7412 ± 0.0126
56.9912 ± 0.6201
FlowMoDL (Ours)
0.0469 ± 0.0017
0.9409 ± 0.0026
0.2664 ± 0.0065
24.5639 ± 0.2458
Table 1: Mean performance of reconstruction models on the unseen test set averaged across all acceleration factors ( R∈{10,20,30,40,50} ). The best results are highlighted in bold , and the second-best results are underlined .
Figure 2: Metrics across different R ’s. For deep learning methods, solid lines denote the mean and shaded areas represent standard deviation ( n=5 seeds).
Figure 3: Representative qualitative results at R=50 comparing CG-SENSE, MoDL, and the proposed FlowMoDL with the fully sampled reference. FlowMoDL reconstructs the volume with the lowest magnitude and velocity errors.
4D flow MRI measures time-resolved, three-directional blood velocity but requires long acquisition times, and its diagnostic signal is carried by the phase difference between velocity encodings, not by image magnitude. Recent work has developed a per-encoding variational network to address image reconstruction in this field. In this work, we incorporate a joint supervised and self-supervised training regime and utilize both magnitude and velocity data during supervision. At the same time, we add multiple acquisition-robust and conditioning strategies based on the acceleration factors. On the CMRx4DFlow~2026 aortic dataset (1.5 and 3T), our model lowers RelErr by 38--50% and AngErr by 7.0--8.7∘ against a training-matched baseline across R=10--50, improving on every held-out subject at every acceleration. Our model also shows strong generalization ability to transfer on out-of-distribution data by employing the joint training scheme, with an increase of 7.2% in SSIM and decrease of 38% and 31% in AngErr and RelErr respectively.
Mengyuan Xue, Bochun Mei
Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA
While compressed-sensing regularizers enable interpretable reconstruction of 4D Flow CMR through transparent variational objectives, their hand-crafted nature is too restrictive under high acceleration. State-of-the-art learning-based approaches mitigate this, but typically encode regularization implicitly through unrolled network modules, which limits their interpretability. To address this limitation, we propose CLEAR, designed to combine the interpretability of compressed sensing with the flexibility of learned models. To the best of our knowledge, it is the first learned regularizer for a 4D reconstruction task. In the ultra-accelerated 10×--50× regime of the CMRx4DFlow2026 challenge, CLEAR outperforms compressed sensing locally low-rank (LLR) and the popular variational network FlowVN, while using less than 10k parameters and preserving an interpretable regularization structure.
This work introduces an unsupervised Divergence and Aliasing-Free neural network (DAF-FlowNet) for 4D Flow Magnetic Resonance Imaging (4D Flow MRI) that jointly enhances noisy velocity fields and corrects phase wrapping artifacts. DAF-FlowNet parameterizes velocities as the curl of a vector potential, enforcing mass conservation by construction and avoiding explicit divergence-penalty tuning. A cosine data-consistency loss enables simultaneous denoising and unwrapping from wrapped phase images. On synthetic aortic 4D Flow MRI generated from computational fluid dynamics, DAF-FlowNet achieved lower errors than existing techniques (up to 11% lower velocity normalized root mean square error, 11% lower directional error, and 44% lower divergence relative to the best-performing alternative across noise levels), with robustness to moderate segmentation perturbations. For unwrapping, at peak velocity/velocity-encoding ratios of 1.4 and 2.1, DAF-FlowNet achieved 0.18% and 5.2% residual wrapped voxels, representing reductions of 72% and 18% relative to the best alternative method, respectively. In scenarios with both noise and aliasing, the proposed single-stage formulation outperformed a state-of-the-art sequential pipeline (up to 15% lower velocity normalized root mean square error, 11% lower directional error, and 28% lower divergence). Across 10 hypertrophic cardiomyopathy patient datasets, DAF-FlowNet preserved fine-scale flow features, corrected aliased regions, and improved internal flow consistency, as indicated by reduced inter-plane flow bias in aortic and pulmonary mass-conservation analyses recommended by the 4D Flow MRI consensus guidelines. These results support DAF-FlowNet as a framework that unifies velocity enhancement and phase unwrapping to improve the reliability of cardiovascular 4D Flow MRI.
Javier Bisbal, Julio Sotelo, Hernán Mella +8
Biomedical Imaging Center, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile (PUC), Santiago, Chile · Department of Electrical Engineering, PUC, Santiago, Chile · Millennium Institute for Intelligent Healthcare Engineering, iHEALTH, Santiago, Chile +8