Mathematical Formulation and Comparative Performance Evaluation of Machine Learning Algorithms for Maize Land Suitability Prediction
Authors: Haimanot Bitew, Ayisheshim Almaw, Habtamu Zegeye, Demeke Alene
Organizations: Department of Information Technology, Injibara University, Ethiopia · Department of Computer Science, Injibara University, Ethiopia · Department of Mathematics, Injibara University,Ethiopia · Department of Information Science, Injibara University,Ethiopia
Addressing the food needs of a growing population is one of the major challenges of developing countries like Ethiopia. Various policies aimed at increasing food production have been enacted by governments and development partners. Although efforts in this regard have been made, there is still inadequate emphasis on increasing food production through the use of high technology practices. Precision agriculture using technology has been utilized to increase crop yield. Precision agriculture also relies on identifying land for a crop, which is a key factor that affects crop yield. Traditional methods of assessing land suitability for crop production are time-consuming, costly and unreliable. Against this background, the aim of this study was to assess the potential of machine learning (ML) in improving the speed and accuracy of assessing land suitability for maize, a staple crop in Ethiopia, as compared to traditional methods. The study is investigated in three areas (Burie, Shindi and Tilili) in the Amhara region. Data collection was done through the local agriculture offices and survey teams. The data were coded, scaled and balanced. Various feature extraction techniques, which included Univariate Feature Selection(UFS), Recursive Feature Elimination with Cross-Validation(RFECV) and Sequential Feature Selection(SFS), and various classifiers, which were K-nearest neighbor (KNN), gradient boosting (GB),random forest (RF) with mathematical formulations were employed. The best models were constructed through combining GBOOST and SFS and achieved an accuracy of 99.41% and 99.35% for both precision and recall. Our results showed that using machine learning is a reliable method of assessing land suitability for maize in Ethiopia. Keywords: Maize, Gradient boosting,Land suitability,Machine learning, Mathematical formulations
Figures & tables
Reference
Focus
Approach & Key Result
Main Limitation
Komolafe et al. [ 7 ]
Cassava land suitability
87.5% accuracy using SVM and DT
Small dataset; incomplete crop–need mapping
Senagi et al. [ 8 ]
Sorghum land suitability
RF among other classifiers; 96% under 10-fold CV
Missing N and P features
Sarmadian et al. [ 9 ]
Rainfed agriculture
RMSE =3.72 , R2=0.84 using SVM regression
Binary classification; no feature selection
Bhimanpallewar & Narasingrao [ 10 ]
Crop-specific suitability
98.9% accuracy using DT
Weak validation; unclear data provenance
Ogunde et al. [ 11 ]
Cassava soil suitability
76.5% accuracy using DT in a web-based DSS
Ignored climate and topography
Tashayo et al. [ 21 ]
Maize in semi-arid Iran
Moderate accuracy using GIS-AHP
No ML; limited validation
Table 1: Related Works Summary
Figure 1: Location map of the study areas: Burie, Shindi, and Tilili, in the Amhara Region, Ethiopia.
Criteria
HS1
MS2
MarS3
currN1
PerN2
Depth (cm)
>75
50–75
30–50
20–30
<20
Texture
L SiL, SCL
SL, CL, SiCL . Ls, SC
C, SiC
–
pH
6.0–7.5
5.5–6.0 7.5–7.8
5.2–5.5 7.8–8.0
5.0–5.2 8.0–8.5
<5.0>8.5
OM (%)
>3.0
2.5–3.0
2.0–2.5
1.0–2.0
<1.0
Slope (%)
0–8
8–16
16–30
30–60
>60
Temp (°C)
20–28
18–20 28–30
15–18 30–33
12–15 33–35
<12>35
Table 2: Soil and climate suitability criteria for maize
y^=mode{T1(x),T2(x),…,TM(x)}.
Algorithm 3 Random Forest Algorithm
Figure 2: Architecture of the proposed models.
No
Symbol
Feature
Type
Description
1
Soil texture
Soil texture class
Nominal
Relative proportions of sand, silt, and clay
2
Mean-min temp
Mean minimum temperature
Number
Mean minimum temperature ( ∘ C)
3
Mean-max temp
Mean maximum temperature
Number
Mean maximum temperature ( ∘ C)
4
Annual rainfall
Annual rainfall
Number
Annual rainfall (mm)
5
Soil depth
Soil depth
Number
Soil depth (cm)
6
Slope
Slope
Number
Topographic slope (%)
Table 3: Description of dataset
Feature
No. of missing
Missing (%)
Rainfall
46
1.314
Min_mean_temp
8
0.228
Max_mean_temp
2
0.057
Depth
2
0.057
Min_slope
1
0.029
Max_slope
4
0.114
Table 4: Percentages of missing values
Figure 3: Class distribution for maize
Model
Chosen by UFS
Chosen by RFECV
Chosen by SFS
RF
Annual rainfall depth, K, texture mean-min temp max slope, min slope, CEC T_N mean-max temp, O_M, Av_P
Seidenberg School of Computer Science & Information Systems, Pace University, New York, USA · RiseAfrica Foundation for STEM and Innovation, Sierra Leone, West Africa
Department of Computer Science & Engineering, American International University-Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh · EliteLab.AI, Queens,NY, U.S.A · Department of Computer Science & Engineering, Begum Rokeya University, Rangpur,Bangladesh