From FAIR to AI-FAIR Metadata-First Infrastructure for AI-Enabled Science
Authors: Elizabeth G. Campolongo, Eric R. Sokol, Marty Downs, Gina Glenne, Gregory E. Maurer, Sydne Record, Dustin R. Rubenstein, Matthew J. Thompson, Christine Laney, Hilmar Lapp, Max Tarjan, Tanya Berger-Wolf
Organizations: Department of Computer Science and Engineering, The Ohio State University · National Ecological Observatory Network (NEON), Battelle · Long Term Ecological Research Network, National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis, UC Santa Barbara · US Fish and Wildlife Service · New Mexico State University · University of Maine & Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station · Ecology, Evolution and Environmental Biology, Columbia University, NSCORE · Neuromatch · NatureServe
Artificial intelligence (AI) technologies and their capabilities have advanced rapidly over the past few years, leading to widespread interest and adoption in the biological and ecological sciences. However, the data infrastructure and computational resources that provide the foundation for AI workflows in ecology and biodiversity science remain fragmented. Moreover, the flow of value remains largely unidirectional: data move from collectors, through repositories and aggregators into models, and finally to research products or management actions. The derived value, such as corrected taxonomies, annotations, quality flags, and insights, rarely returns to source communities. We propose an extension of the original FAIR principles to address the needs of AI-ready infrastructure: the AI-FAIR metadata criteria, which place AI-enabled science in the context of a bidirectional Question-Data-Model triangle. This framework is designed to facilitate large-scale content-based analysis across diverse collections and ensure that the scientists generating the data benefit from the AI-enabled advances built on their data. Alongside these criteria, we introduce an agentic evaluation workflow that both rates existing datasets on the AI-FAIR and traditional FAIR criteria and provides actionable feedback where critical metadata is missing or incomplete. This modular dataset evaluation tool, paired with a domain-appropriate checklist, translates these principles into a reusable assessment of machine-learning readiness, AI-readiness for specified tasks, traceability, and ethical and CARE-aligned stewardship. Through this approach we aim to create a community-informed system to close the model data loop, so that AI also enriches data to further enable scientific discovery.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: The AI-FAIR continuum. FAIR principles apply broadly to data without directed downstream use cases. AI-FAIR principles extend traditional FAIR with AI-enabled assessment and processing as a goal. AI-ready is use-case specific, but may be enabled, e.g., through Agentic workflows, when AI-FAIR standards are met.
Figure 2: The Question-Data-Model framework. Questions specify required data and models; models declare capabilities and data needs; data inform and are enriched by questions and models.
Figure 3: Checklist ratings are assigned to each item and scored by AI-FAIR metadata criteria: structural, scientific, provenance, and governance. These are then mapped into the four derived categories for algorithmic scoring. Traditional FAIR principle alignment is reported in parallel.
Blue Marble Space, Seattle, Washington, USA · Computational and Systems Biology, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA · Trivedi Institute for Space and Global Biomedicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA +18