cs.MANov 3, 2026

Can Network Models of Science Do Without Pluralist Agents?

Authors: Jonas Hallgren, David Hyland, Mahault Albarracin

Organizations: Equilibria Network, Stockholm, Sweden · Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden · University of Oxford, Oxford, UK · Laboratoire d’Analyse Cognitive de l’Information, Université du Québec à Montréal, Québec, Canada · 

Abstract

Science is a process of useful models being proven wrong time and again, but despite its many flaws, it somehow works. Why is this? Paul Feyerabend argued that it works because people dare to hold and defend incompatible rival theories against the accepted one, since a theory's failures often lead to its abandonment in the presence of a more accurate or simpler alternative. He called this view theoretical pluralism. We introduce a theoretical and experimental model in which this can be examined. It compares communities of pluralist agents, which can hold rival theories side by side and maintain beliefs within and between those theories, with communities of monist agents, which can only incorporate what they hear or observe into a single model of their own. In a multi-agent variational inference setting, our experimental demonstrations illustrate how communities with rival theories can go through periods of uncertainty followed by a shift in the theories they hold true, how the information that is communicated between communities affects beliefs when those communities make different observations about the world, and how sharing support for theories and sharing beliefs within them contribute differently to collective belief dynamics.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables3 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. Nothing Deceives Like Success: Social Learning and the Illusion of Understanding in Science

    Apr 29, 2026Avery W. Louis, Marina DubovaScientific DiscoveryComputational Social Science

  2. Scientific Liquidity Agents: An Agent-Based Model of Knowledge Arbitrage in Scientific Communities

    Nov 2, 2026Koutian Wu, You Liu, Yue Liu +2Scientific CommunicationAgent-Based Modeling

  3. The Case for Model Science: Verify, Explore, Steer, Refine

    May 31, 2026Przemyslaw Biecek, Luca Longo, Jianlong Zhou +3LLM EvaluationLLM Interpretability