A Sequential Framework for Urban Drone Delivery: Network Design, Vehicle Sizing, and Energy and Cost Assessment
Authors: Hong-Su Nam, Seokhwan Lee, Jungwoo Cho, Hak-Tae Lee
Organizations: Department of Aerospace Engineering and the Program in Aerospace Systems Convergence, Inha University, Incheon 21999, Republic of Korea · Department of Aerospace Engineering, Inha University, Incheon 21999, Republic of Korea · Aerospace R&D Center, Korean Air, Daejeon 34054, Republic of Korea · Aerospace Systems Research Institute, Inha University, Incheon 21999, Republic of Korea
A sequential engineering framework is presented for urban drone delivery, linking hub location, route planning, mission-specific vehicle sizing, and energy and operating cost assessment. Aggregate origin-destination demand is assumed known a priori. For each hub configuration, the maximum required link distance is minimized, and feasible routes that return to their departure hubs are generated. Route frequencies are determined using mixed-integer linear programming to satisfy delivery demand. The resulting range requirement guides motor-propeller selection and battery sizing to minimize vehicle takeoff mass. Flight distances and frequencies, cruise performance, and vehicle dimensions are combined to estimate monthly energy consumption, fleet size, hub area, staffing, and operating cost. The framework is applied to district-level Seoul delivery data. Increasing the number of hubs from one to four reduces the required range from 30.6 to 21.9 km and vehicle takeoff mass from 8.12 to 6.12 kg. Despite a 21.5% increase in total flight distance, monthly flight energy consumption decreases by 13.1%, from 15.2 to 13.2 MWh. Battery replacement is the largest vehicle-related operating expense, while operating cost per delivery increases from USD 1.18 to USD 2.20 because of higher rent and labor costs at the hubs. Among the designs evaluated, range-matched vehicles achieve the lowest operating cost in the two- and four-hub networks; a longer-range vehicle is least costly in the three-hub network. Sensitivity analyses further examine the effects of delivery demand and operating assumptions. The results demonstrate that reductions in vehicle mass and energy consumption do not necessarily lead to lower system operating cost.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1: Sequential design and evaluation framework for urban drone delivery.
Stage
Decision or evaluation criterion
Key conditions
Hub location
Minimize maximum link distance; break ties by mean hub-assignment distance over all demand nodes
Fixed hub count, candidate sites, and single-hub assignment
Route planning
Minimize total flights over generated candidate routes
Segment demand coverage, hub return, and range limit
Vehicle sizing
Minimize take-off mass subject to mission requirements
Required range, payload, hover reserve time, and component candidates
Operating cost assessment
Calculate monthly operating cost and operating cost per delivery
Selected vehicle and flight plan; fixed operating assumptions and unit prices
TABLE I: Stage-specific decisions and evaluation criteria.
Fig. 2: Hub-based single- and multi-stop closed-loop flights.
Fig. 3: Decomposition of planned OD demand through hubs.
Fig. 4: Illustrative construction of the route–segment incidence matrix R .
Fig. 5: Representative quadcopter geometry and dimensions.
Symbol
Definition and application
Value
ϕ
Angle between adjacent rotor arms [deg]
90
gdisc
Rotor clearance / propeller diameter
0.075
rmf
Main-frame diameter / wheelbase
0.35
ral
Rotor-arm length / wheelbase
0.45
rskid
Skid outer diameter / rotor-arm outer diameter
0.7
kwr
Mass-reduction factor for frame and mount plates
0.8
TABLE II: Design constants and fixed assumptions for vehicle sizing.
Fig. 6: Force and attitude definitions in forward flight.
Symbol
Description
Value
CL
Downward vertical force coefficient
0.193
CD
Vehicle drag coefficient
0.425
mref
Reference vehicle mass [kg]
13.5
Stop,ref
Top-view projected area [m 2 ]
0.5852
Sfront,ref
Front-view projected area [m 2 ]
0.585×0.4
Sfront,box
Payload frontal area [m 2 ]
0.32
TABLE III: Aerodynamic and geometric inputs for the forward-flight model.
Fig. 7: Vehicle design search for minimum take-off mass.
Aircraft / source
Motor
Propeller [in]
Battery inputs
Mass [kg]
Wheelbase [mm]
Endurance [min]
Matrice 100 specifications [ 35 ]
DJI 3510 KV350
13×4.5
600 g; 6S 4,500 mAh; 99.9 Wh
2.355
650
22
Model-based design
MN3510 KV360
13×4.5 MR
1.825
502
32
Inspire 1 V2 specifications [ 36 ]
DJI 3510H KV420
13×4.5
570 g; 6S 4,500 mAh; 99.9 Wh
2.845
581
18
Model-based design
MN3520 KV400
13×4.5 MR
2.254
502
20
M690A retailer listing [ 37 ]
T-Motor 5005 KV520
18×6
2,100 g; 4S 30,000 mAh; 444 Wh
3.250 a
699
≥71b
Model-based design
MN5006 KV450
18×5.5 MR
3.923
695
64
TABLE IV: Commercial drone specifications and corresponding model-based designs.
Fig. 8: Commercial battery mass–price relationship and linear fit.
Fig. 9: Spatial distribution of ground OD demand in Seoul.
Fig. 10: Optimal maximum link distance Z∗ versus hub count.
Input
Baseline
Analysis range
Payload [kg]
2
0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5 (design grid)
Hover reserve time [min]
10
Fixed
Cruise altitude [m]
300
Fixed
Demand scaling factor β
0.01
0.0025, 0.005, 0.01, 0.02, 0.05
Daily operating hours hday=hhub [h/day]
18
6, 9, 12, 15, 18
Battery cycle life [cycles]
500
300, 500, 800, 1,000
TABLE V: Baseline inputs and analysis ranges.
Fig. 11: Hub locations and service zones by hub-count scenario (colors: zones; red inverted triangles: hubs).
Parameter
H=1
H=2
H=3
H=4
Motor
MN5008 KV170 (all scenarios)
Propeller
18×5.5 MR (all scenarios)
Required range [km]
30.55
26.33
23.33
21.86
Achieved range [km]
30.55
26.33
23.33
21.86
Battery energy [Wh]
721
530
434
394
Battery mass [kg]
4.01
2.95
2.41
2.19
TABLE VI: Vehicle design results by hub count H .
Metric
H=1
H=2
H=3
H=4
Planned OD demand K [deliveries]
47,674
47,674
47,674
47,674
Total flights F [flights]
28,456
41,169
52,003
52,587
Fleet size ∑jNj [drones]
20
25
27
28
Total flight distance 10−3∑jdjtot [km]
828,931
992,453
1,062,781
1,007,080
Total energy consumption ∑jEj [kWh]
15,215
15,147
14,610
13,227
Monthly operating cost Ctotal [USD]
56,173
76,023
98,833
105,021
TABLE VII: Monthly operating results and initial vehicle acquisition cost by hub count H .
Fig. 12: Monthly operating cost breakdown by hub-count scenario.
Cost component
H=1
H=2
H=3
H=4
Battery charging
1,840
1,832
1,767
1,599
Battery replacement
17,573
17,654
17,371
15,875
Motor replacement
4,769
5,939
6,479
6,299
Hub operation
31,991
50,598
73,215
81,247
TABLE VIII: Monthly operating cost breakdown [USD] by hub count H .
Fig. 13: Monthly operating results by vehicle design and operating hub count (colors: vehicle design s ).
H
s
Operating cost Ctotal [USD]
Operating cost per delivery cOD [USD/delivery]
Flights F [flights]
Energy ∑jEj [kWh]
Fleet size ∑jNj [drones]
1
1
56,173
1.178
28,456
15,215
20
2
1
77,029
1.616
37,434
19,489
26
2
2
76,023
1.595
41,169
15,147
25
3
1
92,322
1.937
47,381
20,679
28
3
2
96,968
2.034
49,815
16,622
28
3
3
98,833
2.073
52,003
14,610
27
TABLE IX: Monthly operating results by vehicle design s and operating hub count H .
Fig. 14: Take-off mass and propulsion configuration by range and payload.
Fig. 15: Sensitivity of operating cost per delivery to the demand scaling factor, daily operating hours, and component lifetimes.
Fig. 16: Sensitivity of operating cost per delivery to hub-area and staffing coefficients.
Aerial robotics studies the design, perception, control, and coordination of flying robots for navigation, inspection, transport, and physical interaction.
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong, China · School of Architecture, Civil and Environmental Engineering (ENAC), École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Lausanne, Switzerland