End-to-end autonomous driving systems increasingly rely on generating multiple trajectory candidates and selecting one for execution. In this setting, a central challenge is no longer only candidate generation, but how to evaluate candidates according to their long-horizon consequences under uncertainty. Existing methods still mainly use deterministic point scores, heuristic subscores, or single-outcome evaluations, which makes it difficult to capture delayed failures, tail risk, and ranking instability under plausible future perturbations. We present RiSE-Drive, a framework for risk-sensitive long-horizon candidate evaluation in end-to-end autonomous driving. RiSE-Drive first performs candidate-conditioned latent future rollout, then estimates long-horizon outcome distributions instead of single scalar scores, and finally ranks candidates using a tail-risk-aware and perturbation-robust decision criterion. This reformulates candidate scoring from deterministic oracle-style evaluation into distributional outcome assessment with explicit risk control. As a result, the evaluator is encouraged to prefer candidates that are not only strong under nominal conditions, but also reliable under long-horizon rollout and safety-critical deviations. Experiments on the NAVSIM-v1 and NAVSIM-v2 benchmarks, as well as the closed-loop HUGSIM benchmark, show that RiSE-Drive achieves state-of-the-art performance and significantly improves the robustness of candidate selection.
Figures & tables
Figure 1. Why deterministic mean scoring can fail. Two ego candidates may have similar mean scores, yet one can still hide a small set of catastrophic future-condition branches. RiSE-Drive therefore evaluates each candidate under multiple future-condition branches, forms a distribution over branch-level long-horizon outcomes, and ranks candidates with risk-sensitive statistics such as the mean, lower quantiles, and CVaR. RiSE-Drive evaluates each candidate under multiple future-condition branches, rolls each branch forward to obtain one long-horizon outcome sample, forms a distribution over branch outcomes, and ranks candidates using risk-sensitive statistics including the mean, lower quantiles, and CVaR.
Figure 2. Overview of the RiSE-Drive pipeline. Multi-view observations are encoded, and the proposal generator produces K ego-trajectory candidates. A future-condition generator predicts L branch-specific condition codes that parameterize plausible downstream evolutions. For each candidate–condition pair, RiSE-Drive initializes a latent consequence state, propagates it along the trajectory, and decodes one branch-level long-horizon outcome sample. The resulting branchwise consequence traces are pooled over time and across branches and mapped to ordered outcome quantiles by a distribution head. The final ranking score combines the mean estimate, lower-tail CVaR, and cross-condition instability, thereby favoring candidates that remain reliable under plausible future deviations rather than merely optimal under a single nominal forecast. Overview of RiSE-Drive. Multi-view observations are encoded into scene features. The proposal generator creates candidate ego trajectories, while the future-condition generator creates plausible downstream branches. Each candidate and branch pair is propagated to obtain a long-horizon outcome sample. The resulting distribution is summarized with ordered quantiles and ranked using the mean, lower-tail CVaR, and cross-condition instability.
Method
Input
Backbone
Venue
NC ↑
DAC ↑
EP ↑
TTC ↑
Conf. ↑
PDMS ↑
Human
-
-
-
100
100
87.5
100
99.9
94.8
DrivingGPT ( Chen et al., 2025 )
C
VQ-VAE/GPT
ICCV 2025
98.9
90.7
79.7
94.9
95.6
82.4
VADv2 ( Chen et al., 2024 )
C
ResNet-34
arXiv 2024
97.9
91.7
77.6
92.9
100
83.0
UniAD ( Hu et al., 2023 )
C
ResNet-34
CVPR 2023
97.8
91.9
78.8
92.9
100
83.4
LTF ( Chitta et al., 2023 )
C
ResNet-34
TPAMI 2022
97.4
92.8
79.0
92.4
100
83.8
TransFuser ( Chitta et al., 2023 )
C & L
ResNet-34
TPAMI 2022
97.7
92.8
79.2
92.8
100
84.0
Table 1. NAVSIM-v1 evaluation results on the Navtest split. C denotes camera-only input and L denotes LiDAR.
Stage 1
Stage 2
Method
Backbone
NC
DAC
DDC
TLC
EP
TTC
LK
HC
EC
NC
DAC
DDC
TLC
EP
TTC
LK
HC
EC
EPDMS
LTF ( Chitta et al., 2023 )
ResNet-34
96.2
79.5
99.1
99.5
84.1
95.1
94.2
97.5
79.1
77.7
70.2
84.2
98.0
85.1
75.6
45.4
95.7
75.9
23.1
DiffusionDrive ∗ ( Liao et al., 2025 )
ResNet-34
96.0
79.7
97.4
99.5
81.3
93.1
90.8
96.8
73.8
82.1
72.2
88.5
98.7
85.1
78.8
49.2
89.3
71.2
24.2
GuideFlow ( Liu et al., 2025 )
ResNet-34
96.6
80.5
96.3
99.3
82.3
94.9
91.5
97.7
67.8
87.3
76.7
88.8
99.2
84.3
85.1
49.7
93.1
44.5
27.1
RAP-DINO ( Feng et al., 2026 )
ViT-H
97.1
94.4
98.8
99.8
83.9
96.9
94.7
96.4
66.2
83.2
83.9
87.4
98.0
86.9
80.4
52.3
95.2
52.4
39.6
DriveSuprim ( Yao et al., 2025 )
V2-99
98.9
95.1
99.2
99.6
76.1
99.1
94.7
97.6
54.2
87.9
88.8
89.6
98.8
80.3
86.0
53.5
97.1
56.1
42.1
Table 2. NAVSIM-v2 navhard-two-stage results. ∗ denotes results reproduced with the official code repository or official checkpoint.
Method
RC
HD-Score
E
M
H
X
Avg.
E
M
H
X
Avg.
VAD ( Jiang et al., 2023 )
51.3
31.1
25.3
26.5
31.4
36.3
9.5
8.0
11.5
13.4
LTF ( Chitta et al., 2023 )
67.8
35.1
26.2
40.5
38.9
58.9
18.0
9.8
25.9
23.7
UniAD ( Hu et al., 2023 )
78.4
60.5
33.6
17.8
45.9
64.9
45.8
20.6
6.6
32.7
DrivoR ( Kirby et al., 2026 )
80.9
50.5
33.8
47.1
49.8
73.3
34.6
18.8
32.5
35.7
Ours
76.5
53.3
34.1
46.3
50.1
74.6
37.2
22.7
39.2
39.5
Table 3. Photorealistic closed-loop evaluation on HUGSIM.
Figure 3. Qualitative results of RiSE-Drive on representative NavSafe safety-critical scenarios. From left to right, columns (a)–(d) correspond to UNPL ( unprotected left turn ), EXR ( exit ramp ), YLD ( yielding ), and RDBT ( roundabout ). Each column shows two temporal snapshots of one representative case. Magenta denotes the RiSE-Drive plan, green the human future trajectory, orange dashed the ego history, and blue the future trajectories of surrounding vehicles. Across all four cases, RiSE-Drive produces smooth, route-consistent, and interaction-aware behaviors while remaining close to safe human driving in conflict-prone regions. Four columns show unprotected-left-turn, exit-ramp, yielding, and roundabout scenarios, with two temporal snapshots in each column. Magenta curves are RiSE-Drive plans, green curves are human future trajectories, orange dashed curves are ego histories, and blue curves are future trajectories of surrounding vehicles.
NAVSIM-v1
NAVSIM-v2 NavHard
Configuration
PDMS ↑
NC ↑
EPDMS ↑
TTC ↑
B-I: DrivoR
93.1
98.9
48.3
88.0
B-II: DrivoR w/o SD
91.9
98.4
45.6
84.6
+ FCG
92.6
98.7
46.8
86.5
+ CTE
92.9
98.8
47.5
87.3
+ SLE + LCP
93.5
99.1
49.2
89.6
Table 4. Component-wise ablation of the proposed evaluator. Starting from the reduced baseline B-II, each row adds one RiSE-Drive component to the configuration immediately above.
Configuration
Optim Params (M)
Total Params (M)
PDMS ↑
EPDMS ↑
HD-Score Avg. ↑
DrivoR
18.8
41.8
93.1
48.3
35.7
B-II
17.2
39.9
91.9
45.6
33.8
RiSE-Drive
18.9
42.3
94.2
51.3
39.5
Table 5. Parameter-efficiency of RiSE-Drive relative to DrivoR and the reduced baseline.