ImpedanceMimic: Learned Impedance as Action Space for Force-Accurate Motion Imitation
Organizations: Harvard University · Kempner Institute for the Study of Natural and Artificial Intelligence
Abstract
Recovering the forces behind a motion is ill-posed: different controllers can reproduce the same movement while generating different contact forces. Physics-based motion imitation resolves this ambiguity through simulation, but relies on fixed-gain proportional-derivative (PD) control. We show that fixed gains impose a trade-off between motion and force tracking, as contact and swing place conflicting demands on joint stiffness and damping. We introduce ImpedanceMimic, a reinforcement-learning policy that modulates per-joint stiffness, damping, and position setpoints from motion and force measurements, but requires only motion at inference. Across 129 participants and six activities, ImpedanceMimic outperforms matched fixed-gain PD under every integration scheme, direct-torque, muscle-actuated and existing imitation controllers in kinematic and force fidelity, approaching a dedicated motion-to-force regressor. By expressing gains as multiples of inertia-scaled priors, a single policy controls subject-specific biomechanical models without explicit anthropometric input and transfers zero-shot to unseen humans and a humanoid robot. The learned impedance forms a low-dimensional representation of motor state, shared across bodies, that generalizes to withheld activities: stiffness scales with load, and damping anticipates unloading.
Figures & tables
| Activity | walk | run | stand | lateral | flexion | jump | Mean | |||||||||||||||
| Method | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | |||||||||||||||
| Seen subjects, held-out clips | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| GaitDynamics ∗ | – | – | 1.00 | – | – | 1.00 | – | – | .75 | – | – | .90 | – | – | .92 | – | – | .90 | – | – | .91 | .92 |
| Fixed-PD | 99.9 | 2.48 | .95 | 99.7 | 3.36 | .96 | 97.8 | 1.34 | .36 | 95.9 | 3.77 | .85 | 91.3 | 2.76 | .63 | 73.6 | 3.76 | .64 | 93.0 | 2.91 | .73 | .53 |
| Torque | 99.7 | 2.33 | .98 | 99.8 | 3.51 | .96 | 99.6 | 2.33 | .64 | 97.6 | 6.49 | .89 | 96.8 | 4.62 | .73 | 78.9 | 7.61 | .74 | 95.4 | 4.48 | .82 | .62 |
| Muscle | 98.6 | 2.72 | .97 | 99.7 | 3.84 | .98 | 93.2 | 2.14 | .52 | 92.4 | 8.91 | .89 | 68.2 | 12.3 | .62 | 56.4 | 13.2 | .62 | 84.8 | 7.18 | .77 | .62 |
| Seen subjects | Unseen subjects | Withheld activity | |||||||||||
| PD | Method | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | |||||||||
| Fixed-PD | 93.0 | 2.91 | .73 | .53 | 91.5 | 3.13 | .70 | .45 | 69.8 | 4.05 | .59 | .35 | |
| Fixed-PD, | 96.2 | 2.53 | .72 | .50 | 95.9 | 2.80 | .68 | .44 | 83.1 | 3.53 | .59 | .35 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 96.9 | 2.28 | .80 | .70 | 98.1 | 2.45 | .76 | .65 | 89.6 | 3.21 | .72 | .57 | |
| Explicit | ImpedanceMimic, | 96.9 | 2.30 | .79 | .68 | 97.8 | 2.47 | .75 | .63 | 90.3 | 3.22 | .69 | .49 |
| Fixed-PD | 93.5 | 2.44 | .75 | .65 | 92.2 | 2.70 | .72 | .59 | 78.9 | 3.32 | .69 | .51 | |
| Dataset | Subj. | Trials | Clips | Frames | Hours | Rate (Hz) | Setting | Activities | |
| Dos Santos et al. (2017) | 49/49 | 9 | 294 | 1,764 | 1,762,236 | 4.90 | 100 | OG | S |
| Fregly et al. (2012) | 6/6 | 1 | 113 | 115 | 19,061 | 0.05 | 120–200 | OG | W |
| Hamner & Delp (2013) | 10/10 | 2 | 36 | 36 | 5,226 | 0.01 | 100–120 | TM | R |
| Han et al. (2023) | 7/7 | 1 | 117 | 144 | 90,479 | 0.25 | 250 | OG | W S F L J |
| Moore et al. (2015) | 12/15 | 2 | 35 | 2,047 | 1,967,364 | 5.46 | 100 | TM | W S |
| Scherpereel et al. (2023) | 11/12 | 2 | 116 | 1,001 | 464,459 | 1.29 | 200 | OG | S F L J |
| Subj. | Sex | Age | Mass | Ht. | Activities | H-O |
| Dos Santos et al. (2017) | ||||||
| s0 | M | 25 | 74.3 | 1.72 | S (6,36) | 7 |
| s1 | M | 26 | 126.3 | 1.92 | S (6,36) | 7 |
| s2 | F | 22 | 52.9 | 1.67 | S (6,36) | 7 |
| s3 | M | 33 | 75.8 | 1.79 | S (6,36) | 7 |
| s4 | M | 24 | 61.0 | 1.84 | S (6,36) | 7 |
| Seen | Unseen | LOAO | ||||
| Activity | Train clips | Eval clips | Train clips | Eval clips | Train subj. | Eval clips |
| walk | 3,298 | 816 | 3,444 | 670 | 106 | 2,351 |
| run | 806 | 207 | 885 | 128 | 111 | 159 |
| stand | 1,591 | 387 | 1,618 | 360 | 80 | 214 |
| lateral | 369 | 93 | 382 | 80 | 129 | 462 |
| flexion | 464 | 125 | 510 | 79 | 129 | 589 |
| Rod | m, kg, kg m 2 , hinge height mm |
| Contact | sphere mm, contact at , solref |
| Rates | physics ms, policy Hz ( substeps) |
| Actuator | Nm |
| Gain priors | Nm/rad ( rad/s), Nm s/rad |
| Learned-PD | , (log-scale ), rad |
| Reference | s cycle: a contact-force bell peaking at N ( for the stiffness sweep), with the angle producing it on the floor, then a swing off the floor |
| Component | Contents | Dims |
| Proprioception | pelvis height, the three pelvis rotations and the 25 remaining coordinates, actuated and passive (29), and all generalized velocities (31) | 60 |
| Contact state | per foot: vertical contact force (BW, clamped at 0) and heel height | 4 |
| Kinematic lookahead | for , clamped at the clip end | 93 |
| GRF lookahead | , six components, | 18 |
| Foot lookahead | per foot at : heel height, toe height, heel vertical velocity and acceleration, estimated contact flag | 40 |
| Category | Parameter | Value |
| Simulation | Sim timestep | 0.002 s |
| Control rate | 100 Hz (5 substeps) | |
| Contact time constant | 0.04 s | |
| Friction | 1.0 | |
| Foot model | 8 spheres per foot (extends Falisse et al.) | |
| Solver iterations | 6 (6 line-search) |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Budget | Activity | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| Seen subjects, held-out clips | |||||||||||||||
| 4 B | walk | 98.7 .9 | 2.41 .05 | 39.2 .3 | .030 .003 | .95 .00 | .10 .00 | .97 .00 | .87 .01 | .86 .01 | 21 1 | 50 1 | .40 .00 | .61 .01 | 6.48 .11 |
| run | 99.8 .2 | 3.47 .07 | 72.6 1.3 | .071 .015 | .94 .00 | .14 .01 | .98 .00 | .41 .04 | .80 .02 | 20 1 | 37 2 | .77 .01 | .72 .01 | 13.5 .2 | |
| stand | 92.3 1.3 | 1.97 .15 | 8.54 .97 | .013 .002 | .44 .02 | .07 .00 | .57 .02 | .70 .04 | .19 .03 | 16 1 | 46 2 | .77 .04 | .09 .01 | .70 .07 | |
| lateral | 91.8 1.6 | 7.58 .27 | 77.5 1.9 | .112 .006 | .73 .01 | .24 .01 | .89 .01 | .77 .02 | .62 .02 | 30 2 | 59 4 | .55 .01 | .49 .01 | 11.6 .3 | |
| AMASS train | AMASS test | |||||||
| Primitives | Motions | Succ. ↑ (%) | G-MPJPE ↓ | MPJPE ↓ | Succ. ↑ (%) | G-MPJPE ↓ | MPJPE ↓ | |
| PHC, reported ( Luo et al., 2023 ) | multiple | 11,313 | 98.9 | 37.5 | 26.9 | 96.4 | 47.4 | 30.9 |
| Our port | 1 | 4,021 | 96.2 .1 | 49.3 .3 | 39.0 .1 | 92.2 1.9 | 60.9 .6 | 42.7 .3 |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | GaitDynamics ∗ | – | – | – | – | – | .04 .00 | 1.00 .00 | .99 .00 | .99 .00 | 7 0 | 14 0 | – | – | – |
| Fixed-PD | 99.9 .1 | 2.48 .04 | 57.2 1.9 | .022 .002 | .97 .00 | .13 .00 | .95 .00 | .77 .01 | .72 .00 | 20 1 | 45 1 | .55 .01 | .50 .01 | 26.3 2.0 | |
| Torque | 99.7 .2 | 2.33 .03 | 55.7 2.5 | .022 .001 | .93 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .85 .00 | 19 0 | 41 1 | .42 .00 | .61 .01 | 9.06 .22 | |
| Muscle | 98.6 .4 | 2.72 .08 | 41.1 .6 | .032 .001 | .93 .00 | .10 .00 | .97 .00 | .86 .01 | .86 .01 | 20 1 | 51 2 | .41 .00 | .60 .01 | 6.12 .13 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.66 .03 | 28.8 .4 | .013 .001 | .98 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .86 .00 | 20 0 | 40 1 | .38 .00 | .65 .00 | 6.38 .08 | |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | GaitDynamics ∗ | – | – | – | – | – | .06 .00 | .99 .00 | .98 .00 | .97 .00 | 11 0 | 18 0 | – | – | – |
| Fixed-PD | 99.8 .2 | 2.75 .05 | 60.5 .4 | .027 .003 | .96 .00 | .16 .00 | .94 .00 | .71 .01 | .72 .01 | 24 1 | 41 1 | .55 .01 | .50 .01 | 28.0 .5 | |
| Torque | 99.8 .3 | 2.69 .04 | 64.1 3.5 | .025 .002 | .93 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .88 .00 | .86 .00 | 22 1 | 37 1 | .41 .00 | .62 .01 | 9.54 .31 | |
| Muscle | 90.9 7.9 | 3.98 .24 | 50.4 1.6 | .044 .005 | .90 .01 | .13 .01 | .95 .01 | .83 .02 | .83 .01 | 22 1 | 48 1 | .41 .00 | .60 .01 | 6.30 .07 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.95 .03 | 32.7 .3 | .016 .001 | .98 .00 | .11 .00 | .97 .00 | .88 .01 | .85 .01 | 23 1 | 39 1 | .38 .01 | .65 .01 | 6.78 .11 | |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg/s) | |||
| walk | Fixed-PD | 76.7 4.0 | 4.70 .10 | 107 2 | .078 .018 | .87 .01 | .62 .02 | .41 .03 | .39 .03 | .21 .03 | 24 3 | 58 1 | 32.8 .9 |
| Torque | 34.5 3.9 | 14.2 .4 | 393 30 | .186 .016 | .46 .02 | .67 .03 | .44 .03 | .33 .04 | .23 .02 | 28 2 | 57 1 | 43.9 3.1 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 95.5 6.6 | 3.85 .16 | 83.7 6.3 | .035 .004 | .91 .01 | .46 .02 | .60 .03 | .68 .02 | .43 .05 | 22 1 | 58 3 | 18.2 2.3 | |
| run | Fixed-PD | 43.0 13.8 | 5.83 .20 | 120 2 | .109 .016 | .89 .00 | .60 .01 | .66 .02 | .10 .06 | .28 .03 | 28 2 | 50 1 | 39.8 1.8 |
| Torque | 20.4 2.8 | 17.5 1.0 | 427 41 | .178 .023 | .46 .02 | .68 .03 | .57 .02 | .13 .06 | .16 .03 | 36 3 | 51 1 | 42.5 2.6 | |
| PD | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||
| Fixed-PD | 56.9 3.6 | 4.68 .11 | .33 .01 | .25 .02 | 30.2 .8 | |
| Fixed-PD, | 63.3 5.5 | 4.58 .15 | .32 .01 | .21 .02 | 54.8 2.9 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 82.1 4.3 | 4.04 .14 | .42 .02 | .48 .05 | 19.8 .6 | |
| Explicit | ImpedanceMimic, | 83.5 3.6 | 3.98 .12 | .40 .02 | .41 .02 | 31.4 3.1 |
| Fixed-PD | 74.5 2.6 | 3.82 .09 | .45 .01 | .46 .03 | 13.4 .5 | |
| Fixed-PD, | 71.1 4.9 | 3.46 .05 | .40 .01 | .44 .04 | 22.1 .8 |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Withheld Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | GaitDynamics ∗ | – | – | – | – | – | .12 .00 | .96 .00 | .93 .01 | .91 .01 | 15 1 | 40 2 | – | – | – |
| Fixed-PD | 40.0 5.0 | 4.52 .14 | 115 5 | .322 .034 | .85 .01 | .61 .00 | .43 .01 | .13 .02 | .11 .01 | 76 22 | 137 18 | 1.40 .03 | .14 .01 | 158 6 | |
| Torque | 79.5 7.7 | 6.53 .44 | 172 14 | .251 .064 | .76 .02 | .32 .03 | .76 .04 | .51 .03 | .41 .02 | 27 3 | 81 6 | .68 .04 | .34 .04 | 27.6 2.7 | |
| Muscle | 32.8 7.8 | 12.2 .8 | 93.3 4.0 | .214 .055 | .54 .03 | .33 .02 | .74 .02 | .50 .04 | .34 .04 | 28 4 | 94 8 | .61 .02 | .28 .03 | 9.06 .38 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 87.1 4.2 | 3.43 .20 | 78.0 5.3 | .263 .050 | .91 .01 | .41 .04 | .66 .04 | .49 .04 | .42 .05 | 38 5 | 95 9 | .83 .07 | .30 .04 | 31.5 5.6 | |
| Bound 2 | walk | run | stand | lateral | flexion | jump | |||||||
| Joint | ( ) | B1 % | B2 % | B1 % | B2 % | B1 % | B2 % | B1 % | B2 % | B1 % | B2 % | B1 % | B2 % |
| hip | 100.27 | 98 / 100 | 100 / 100 | 99 / 99 | 100 / 100 | 100 / 100 | – | 95 / 97 | 100 / 100 | 96 / 98 | 100 / 100 | 98 / 99 | 100 / 100 |
| knee | 16.43 | 98 / 100 | 100 / 100 | 97 / 72 | 100 / 100 | 100 / 100 | – | 97 / 89 | 100 / 100 | 97 / 100 | 100 / 100 | 98 / 99 | 100 / 100 |
| ankle | 0.77 | 96 / 93 | 100 / 0 | 92 / 53 | 100 / 0 | 100 / 100 | – | 79 / 76 | 99 / 0 | 100 / 100 | 100 / 0 | 94 / 94 | 96 / 0 |
| (Nm/rad/kg) | (Nm s/rad/kg) | |||||||||
| Activity | Joint | contact | swing | peak | contact | swing | contact | peak | contact | swing |
| walk | hip | 0.70 | 0.73 | 0.83 | 0.71 | 0.69 | 2.9 | 3.6 | 0.29 | 0.28 |
| knee | 0.57 | 0.73 | 0.75 | 1.02 | 0.91 | 2.3 | 3.3 | 0.41 | 0.37 | |
| ankle | 0.87 | 0.67 | 1.54 | 0.66 | 0.29 | 2.6 | 5.1 | 0.20 | 0.09 | |
| run | hip | 1.00 | 1.04 | 1.44 | 0.70 | 0.69 | 3.8 | 5.6 | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| Method | Actions | Policy parameters | Steps/s per process | Hours per run | Runs | GPU-h |
| Fixed-PD | 15 | 0.28 M | 139 k | 4.1 | 40 | 55 |
| Torque | 15 | 0.28 M | 141 k | 4.0 | 40 | 54 |
| Muscle | 83 | 0.33 M | 103 k | 5.5 | 40 | 73 |
| PHC | 15 | 1.09 M | 53 k | 10.6 | 40 | 141 |
| SimPoE | 51 | 2.46 M | 42 k | 13.3 | 40 | 177 |
| ImpedanceMimic | 45 | 0.28 M | 143 k | 4.0 | 40 | 53 |
| Force (% BW) | Moment about (Nm/kg) | Root share (%) | No contact | ||||||||||
| Activity | Z | ML | AP | Z | ML | AP | Z | ML | AP | frames (%) | |||
| Seen subjects, held-out clips | |||||||||||||
| walk | 10.3 1.0 | 16.7 1.1 | 12.0 1.1 | .40 .03 | .55 .03 | .64 .02 | 8 1 | 64 1 | 57 2 | – | |||
| run | 12.5 1.3 | 19.1 1.0 | 22.4 2.0 | .66 .04 | .97 .08 | .96 .05 | 11 1 | 76 1 | 69 2 | 99 0 | |||
| stand | 1.3 .2 | 7.8 .9 | 1.9 .2 | .16 .04 | .17 .01 | .59 .03 | 1 0 | 86 1 | 46 3 | – | |||
| lateral | 13.1 1.0 | 13.0 .4 | 12.6 .6 | .56 .02 | .87 .06 | .92 .03 | 12 1 | 51 1 | 51 1 | 98 1 | |||
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | Fixed-PD | 99.9 .1 | 2.48 .04 | 57.2 1.9 | .022 .002 | .97 .00 | .13 .00 | .95 .00 | .77 .01 | .72 .00 | 20 1 | 45 1 | .55 .01 | .50 .01 | 26.3 2.0 |
| Fixed-PD, uncapped | 99.0 .2 | 3.89 .03 | 112 0 | .071 .006 | .91 .00 | .32 .00 | .82 .00 | .45 .01 | .22 .02 | 28 1 | 56 2 | 1.16 .01 | .24 .00 | 145 2 | |
| Fixed-PD, | 99.9 .1 | 2.19 .02 | 88.2 15.1 | .020 .001 | .97 .00 | .15 .01 | .94 .00 | .67 .02 | .64 .01 | 23 0 | 44 1 | .84 .02 | .38 .00 | 97.5 3.2 | |
| Gain schedule | 99.5 .1 | 1.83 .02 | 31.6 .3 | .020 .001 | .97 .00 | .11 .00 | .97 .00 | .88 .00 | .82 .01 | 20 0 | 41 1 | .40 .00 | .62 .01 | 8.58 .27 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.66 .03 | 28.8 .4 | .013 .001 | .98 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .86 .00 | 20 0 | 40 1 | .38 .00 | .65 .00 | 6.38 .08 | |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| run | Fixed-PD | 99.7 .2 | 3.36 .02 | 109 4 | .064 .005 | .96 .00 | .21 .00 | .96 .00 | .32 .01 | .52 .01 | 22 1 | 43 1 | 1.25 .01 | .47 .01 | 110 2 |
| Fixed-PD, uncapped | 99.4 .3 | 4.80 .04 | 161 1 | .103 .007 | .90 .00 | .30 .00 | .93 .00 | .19 .01 | .29 .01 | 24 1 | 48 4 | 1.57 .00 | .37 .00 | 192 1 | |
| Fixed-PD, | 100 0 | 2.45 .03 | 107 2 | .060 .004 | .97 .00 | .15 .00 | .98 .00 | .46 .03 | .81 .01 | 21 0 | 45 0 | 1.29 .02 | .48 .00 | 125 4 | |
| Gain schedule | 100 0 | 2.54 .03 | 65.5 .4 | .065 .006 | .98 .00 | .14 .00 | .98 .00 | .54 .03 | .81 .01 | 22 1 | 43 0 | .83 .00 | .69 .01 | 26.8 .4 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 2.24 .02 | 59.7 1.3 | .043 .003 | .98 .00 | .12 .00 | .99 .00 | .58 .03 | .86 .00 | 21 0 | 42 0 | .80 .00 | .72 .01 | 19.7 1.9 | |
| Unseen subjects, zero-shot | Withheld activity | ||||||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | (m/s) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | (m/s) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||||
| walk | Fixed-PD | 99.8 .2 | 2.75 .05 | .027 .003 | .94 .00 | .71 .01 | .72 .01 | .55 .01 | 28.0 .5 | 40.0 5.0 | 4.52 .14 | .322 .034 | .43 .01 | .13 .02 | .11 .01 | 1.40 .03 | 158 6 |
| Fixed-PD, | 100 0 | 2.42 .03 | .022 .002 | .93 .00 | .65 .01 | .65 .01 | .85 .01 | 99.1 2.0 | 67.5 4.1 | 3.93 .11 | .452 .046 | .42 .02 | .16 .01 | .11 .01 | 1.56 .01 | 160 5 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.95 .03 | .016 .001 | .97 .00 | .88 .01 | .85 .01 | .38 .01 | 6.78 .11 | 87.1 4.2 | 3.43 .20 | .263 .050 | .66 .04 | .49 .04 | .42 .05 | .83 .07 | 31.5 5.6 | |
| ImpedanceMimic, | 100 0 | 2.00 .04 | .017 .003 | .96 .00 | .87 .00 | .83 .01 | .40 .00 | 8.42 .16 | 89.1 3.0 | 3.31 .15 | .299 .039 | .64 .03 | .45 .03 | .37 .02 | .97 .08 | 46.0 9.5 | |
| Fixed-PD (S) | 100 0 | 1.88 .03 | .022 .002 | .96 .00 | .88 .01 | .84 .01 | .42 .01 | 8.98 .16 | 71.4 4.6 | 3.29 .09 | .190 .022 | .66 .01 | .48 .04 | .37 .03 | .71 .02 | 18.6 1.1 | |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.66 .03 | 28.8 .4 | .013 .001 | .98 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .86 .00 | 20 0 | 40 1 | .38 .00 | .65 .00 | 6.38 .08 |
| ImpedanceMimic, Torque’s kernel | 100 0 | 1.87 .02 | 29.8 .5 | .013 .001 | .96 .00 | .08 .00 | .98 .00 | .90 .00 | .87 .00 | 20 0 | 39 1 | .38 .00 | .65 .00 | 6.14 .05 | |
| Torque | 99.7 .2 | 2.33 .03 | 55.7 2.5 | .022 .001 | .93 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .85 .00 | 19 0 | 41 1 | .42 .00 | .61 .01 | 9.06 .22 | |
| Torque, fixed scale | 98.6 .4 | 2.69 .03 | 57.4 1.2 | .031 .002 | .93 .00 | .10 .00 | .98 .00 | .88 .00 | .85 .01 | 20 0 | 40 0 | .39 .00 | .63 .00 | 7.44 .11 | |
| Torque, ImpedanceMimic’s kernel | 94.6 1.5 | 44.8 .5 | 146 25 | .015 .004 | .20 .08 | .17 .02 | .93 .02 | .75 .04 | .77 .04 | 25 4 | 59 8 | .94 .05 | .26 .03 | 10.9 .5 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | Fixed-PD | Torque | Muscle | |||||||||||||
| Condition | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | Ep. ↑ | ||||||||||||
| Unperturbed | 96.9 .5 | 2.28 .04 | .80 .00 | 15.9 .4 | 93.0 .2 | 2.91 .03 | .73 .00 | 45.3 .6 | 95.4 .4 | 4.48 .09 | .82 .01 | 16.5 .4 | 84.8 .5 | 7.18 .26 | .77 .00 | 6.89 .15 |
| pelvis pushes BW | 0.2 | 0.02 | .01 | 0.2 | 0.1 | 0.00 | .01 | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.03 | .01 | 0.1 | 0.4 | 0.01 | .01 | 0.01 |
| pelvis pushes BW | 0.2 | 0.03 | .03 | 0.3 | 0.4 | 0.03 | .01 | 0.2 | 0.0 | 0.07 | .03 | 0.3 | 1.3 | 0.09 | .03 | 0.05 |
| pelvis pushes BW | 0.3 | 0.09 | .06 | 1.0 | 0.7 | 0.09 | .04 | 1.4 | 0.6 | 0.26 | .06 | 1.4 | 5.7 | 0.68 | .06 | 0.20 |
| contact stiffness | 0.2 | 0.00 | .01 | 0.2 | 0.5 | 0.01 | .01 | 0.5 | 0.1 | 0.03 | .00 | 0.5 | 0.4 | 0.02 | .00 | 0.10 |
| Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ||||||
| PD | Method | ms | ms | ms | ms | ms | ms |
| Fixed-PD | 93.0 .2 | 65.6 1.3 | 2.91 .03 | 4.67 .07 | .73 .00 | .51 .01 | |
| Fixed-PD, | 96.2 .2 | 60.1 1.0 | 2.53 .02 | 5.82 .08 | .72 .00 | .42 .01 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 96.9 .5 | 93.5 .3 | 2.28 .04 | 3.52 .02 | .80 .00 | .73 .00 | |
| Explicit | ImpedanceMimic, | 96.9 .2 | 86.6 1.8 | 2.30 .02 | 4.12 .13 | .79 .00 | .65 .01 |
| Fixed-PD | 93.5 .4 | 89.1 .8 | 2.44 .02 | 3.33 .05 | .75 .01 | .69 .00 | |
| Configuration | Ep. ↑ | ||||
| ImpedanceMimic ( , , ms) | 96.9 .5 | 2.28 .04 | .80 .00 | 15.9 .4 | .040 .001 |
| 2.4 | 0.24 | .03 | 1.5 | .006 | |
| 2.3 | 0.17 | .02 | 1.0 | .005 | |
| 1.4 | 0.08 | .01 | 0.1 | .001 | |
| 2.2 | 0.90 | .13 | 86 | .013 | |
| 1.4 | 0.72 | .09 | 74.7 | .009 |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | Fixed-PD | 99.7 .1 | 1.81 .03 | 63.8 .7 | .011 .001 | .98 .00 | .38 .01 | .67 .01 | .29 .01 | .21 .01 | 23 2 | 52 2 | .76 .01 | .34 .00 | 49.9 1.2 |
| Torque | 99.9 .2 | 1.92 .03 | 58.6 1.6 | .009 .001 | .95 .00 | .29 .00 | .79 .01 | .57 .02 | .45 .02 | 21 1 | 48 1 | .52 .00 | .47 .01 | 18.8 .9 | |
| Muscle | 99.0 .2 | 2.00 .01 | 36.6 .3 | .022 .002 | .96 .00 | .23 .01 | .86 .01 | .71 .03 | .58 .01 | 22 1 | 56 3 | .44 .01 | .57 .01 | 8.30 .25 | |
| ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.25 .01 | 28.1 .3 | .008 .000 | .99 .00 | .27 .00 | .81 .01 | .66 .01 | .50 .01 | 21 0 | 45 1 | .49 .00 | .48 .00 | 11.1 .3 | |
| run | Fixed-PD | 99.7 .2 | 2.87 .04 | 107 1 | .025 .001 | .97 .00 | .38 .02 | .88 .01 | .15 .01 | .14 .01 | 23 0 | 49 1 | 1.36 .02 | .38 .01 | 117 4 |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.95 .03 | 32.7 .3 | .016 .001 | .98 .00 | .11 .00 | .97 .00 | .88 .01 | .85 .01 | 23 1 | 39 1 | .38 .01 | .65 .01 | 6.78 .11 |
| Oracle GRF obs | 100 0 | 1.97 .02 | 32.8 .4 | .017 .001 | .98 .00 | .11 .00 | .97 .00 | .89 .00 | .86 .01 | 22 1 | 39 1 | .38 .00 | .66 .01 | 6.68 .16 | |
| - Inertia scaling | 100 0 | 2.26 .06 | 74.4 4.7 | .019 .002 | .97 .00 | .15 .01 | .95 .00 | .81 .02 | .74 .02 | 23 0 | 38 1 | .62 .02 | .50 .01 | 39.7 4.0 | |
| - Estimator obs | 100 0 | 1.95 .01 | 32.8 .6 | .017 .002 | .98 .00 | .12 .00 | .96 .00 | .87 .00 | .84 .01 | 23 1 | 39 0 | .38 .00 | .65 .01 | 6.46 .11 | |
| - Learned residual | 100 0 | 1.98 .02 | 33.1 .5 | .016 .002 | .98 .00 | .11 .00 | .97 .00 | .87 .01 | .85 .01 | 23 0 | 38 0 | .38 .00 | .65 .01 | 6.62 .15 | |
| Stability | Kinematics | Ground Reaction Forces | Torques † | ||||||||||||
| Activity | Method | Ep. ↑ (%) | ( ∘ ) | ( ∘ /s) | (m/s) | kin | (BW) | (mm) | (mm) | (Nm/kg) | (Nm/kg/s) | ||||
| walk | ImpedanceMimic | 100 0 | 1.66 .03 | 28.8 .4 | .013 .001 | .98 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .86 .00 | 20 0 | 40 1 | .38 .00 | .65 .00 | 6.38 .08 |
| Oracle GRF obs | 100 0 | 1.67 .03 | 28.9 .2 | .014 .001 | .98 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .90 .01 | .87 .00 | 20 0 | 40 0 | .38 .00 | .65 .01 | 6.16 .05 | |
| - Root term | 100 0 | 1.72 .03 | 29.5 .3 | .018 .000 | .98 .00 | .09 .00 | .98 .00 | .89 .00 | .84 .00 | 20 0 | 42 1 | .40 .00 | .62 .00 | 6.44 .11 | |
| - Inertia scaling | 100 0 | 1.85 .04 | 62.1 3.7 | .016 .001 | .97 .00 | .12 .00 | .96 .00 | .82 .01 | .76 .02 | 21 0 | 40 1 | .60 .02 | .52 .01 | 37.6 3.8 | |
| - Amp norm | 100 0 | 1.87 .02 | 29.8 .5 | .013 .001 | .96 .00 | .08 .00 | .98 .00 | .90 .00 | .87 .00 | 20 0 | 39 1 | .38 .00 | .65 .00 | 6.14 .05 | |
Imitation Learning
Imitation learning trains agents to perform tasks by learning from expert demonstrations, feedback, or observed behavior.
See all 291 papers