cs.MANov 16, 2026

When Does Interaction Help? Toward a Reynolds Number for Collective Intelligence

Authors: Xuening Wu, Haode Yang, Yanlan Kang, Shenqin Yin

Organizations: Pfizer Inc. · Fudan University

Abstract

Multi-agent systems combine distributed information through interaction, which can improve performance but also spread errors or suppress useful differences. Predicting when interaction helps is central to understanding and designing collective intelligence. We investigate whether a few dimensionless parameters can predict gains over explicitly defined non-communicating baselines across group sizes, network structures, and tasks, toward a Reynolds-number-like description of collective intelligence. Using distributed classification tasks, stochastic tracking networks, and neural cellular automata, we combine analytical and empirical evidence to examine information sufficiency, dynamical applicability, and finite-sample prediction. We construct inference systems with bounded random variables and matching specified joint moments up to total degree three, yet opposite interaction gains under a fixed readout. These moments alone cannot generally determine the gain sign. Tracking networks likewise exhibit gain reversals despite matched candidate parameters when task power occupies different spectral modes. Under concentrated task spectra and aligned observation noise, however, we derive a low-dimensional similarity relation with an explicit zero-delay error bound and test it across network sizes and topologies under frozen protocols. The relation does not directly apply to the neural cellular systems, where a separate moment-based predictor underperforms direct gain measurement at matched calibration sample budgets. These results establish conditions and limits for low-dimensional gain prediction, providing a restricted similarity law while leaving a general Reynolds-number-like description of collective intelligence open.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables1 asset

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Nov 1, 2026

Renormalized Cellular Intelligence: When Does Model Reduction Preserve Collective Capability?

As multi-agent systems grow in size and complexity, understanding which features of their interactions support collective capability becomes increasingly difficult. Can a simpler description preserve both task performance and the measured contribution of interactions between agents? Preserving collective dynamics alone is insufficient: reduction can alter decision-relevant information or give a non-communicating baseline access to pooled observations, distorting the measured advantage of interaction. We introduce Renormalized Cellular Intelligence (RCI), a framework for specifying and auditing capability preservation across scales. RCI treats the task, interacting dynamics, matched baseline, decision interfaces, and resource budget as a joint object of reduction. It specifies dynamical closure, decision compatibility, and preservation of the intended baseline comparison, and bounds the resulting error in relative capability gain. An exact analytical construction demonstrates task-score preservation, while a counterexample shows how closed reduced dynamics can erase the measured interaction gain. Using cellular systems as models of locally interacting agents, we evaluate three reduction candidates on five frozen learned models without retraining. The final candidate reduces the evolving state from eight to five dimensions per cell (37.5%). Within-run uncertainty bounds support relative gain above a prespecified threshold for the fixed model collection, yet the candidate fails the closure and decision-preservation requirements for a complete RCI certificate. RCI provides explicit criteria for distinguishing positive interaction gains from
Sep 20, 2026

When Does Communication Help? Beyond Spectral Descriptions of Collective Intelligence

Communication can bring agents into agreement while making their decisions worse. We identify two limits of aggregate descriptions of communication gain in distributed inference. First, stable linear systems with fixed evidence, network and readout can have interaction and finite-time state operators with identical eigenvalue and singular-value spectra, yet produce gains of opposite sign. Changing only message orientation raises accuracy from 72.6% to 91.2% or lowers it to 65.9%. A standard task-projected local-response approximation retains the directional information missing from spectral summaries. Using labeled calibration data separate from the test set, it predicts multi-round gains in small trained nonlinear agents with a root-mean-square error of 0.45 percentage points on two synthetic tasks; tests with natural edge changes and handwritten digits extend the evaluation. Second, under community-shared bias, higher mean individual accuracy can coexist with harm to unaffected communities or lower global-vote accuracy. At fixed communication rounds, calibration constraints reduce observed community harm while retaining much of the mean benefit, but do not guarantee protection. Full direct calibration performs similarly. The results connect spectral insufficiency, task-aware prediction and the distribution of communication benefits, while leaving broad transfer and practical superiority open.
Oct 13, 2026

Collective Benefits and Efficiency in Coupled Echo State Networks

Simple aggregation of independent responses ("wisdom of crowds") generally improves collective performance through statistical facilitation, but interaction among members can sometimes hinder group outcomes. However, under certain circumstances, coordination studies show that interacting groups can outperform their individual members and nominal groups, and interaction can also be more efficient than independence. We present a reservoir computing model to investigate how interaction can enhance joint performance in terms of accuracy and efficiency. Echo state networks were trained independently to identify Japanese speakers from vowel recordings and tested jointly with and without coupled feedback. Model pairs reproduced the dyadic advantage reported by Bahrami et al. (2010) with interaction via pooled-feedback, but not when independent responses were aggregated together. Model dynamics revealed that interaction was beneficial whereas aggregated outputs were prone to diverging from runaway feedback over time. In terms of efficiency, larger groups of smaller interacting models outperformed smaller groups of larger models while equating for total amount of group computation. Our results offer a formal framework for explaining when and why interaction enhances collective intelligence.