cs.ARNov 14, 2026

RTLReviewBench: LLM Hardware Reviewers Rarely Miss Bugs but Routinely Reject Correct RTL

Authors: Yasir Mahmud

Organizations: University of Florida

Abstract

Hardware teams increasingly ask large language models (LLMs) to review register-transfer level (RTL) code, yet it is unclear whether a model can tell a correct module from a buggy one without simulating it. We introduce RTLReviewBench, a benchmark of 114 matched pairs of buggy and correct Verilog modules. Each pair shares one specification, most buggy modules are real failures of LLM code generators, and every label is confirmed by simulation. Evaluating 12 commercial and open-weight models, we find a consistent asymmetry: reviewers rarely accept buggy code but often reject correct code, producing more than five false rejections for every missed bug. Synthetic mutants hide part of the problem: on the same designs, models miss far fewer injected bugs than real ones. Asking a model to reason before it commits to a verdict sharply reduces false rejections for weaker reviewers, and a controlled ablation shows that where the reasoning appears in the output matters more than the instruction to reason, whereas sampling and majority voting do not help. A blinded audit further shows that some correct "buggy" verdicts rest on false technical claims. We release the benchmark, a harder split for future models, all model responses, and the evaluation code at https://github.com/yasirmahmud/RTLReviewBench

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables13 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. CorrectRTL: Boost RTL Generation Quality Through Automated Self-Correction with Instruction Decomposition

    Oct 18, 2026Jing Wang, Shang Liu, Hangan Zhou +4RTL Code GenerationLLM Self-Correction

  2. RuC: HDL-Agnostic Rule Completion Benchmark Generation

    Apr 30, 2026Arnau Ayguadé Domingo, Miquel Alberti-Binimelis, Cristian Gutierrez-Gomez +5LLM EvaluationLLM Prompting

  3. RTL-BenchLS: A Large-Scale Benchmark for RTL Reasoning and Generation with Large Language Models

    Jun 8, 2026Jing Wang, Shang Liu, Wenji Fang +3LLM EvaluationBenchmark Design