Effects of Locomotion and Viewpoint Control on Immersive Robot Telepresence for Navigation and Inspection
Organizations: Know-Center GmbH, Graz, Austria. · Graz University of Technology, Graz, Austria. · Siemens Digital Industries Software Egypt. · the American University in Cairo.
Abstract
In many robot telepresence interfaces, movement and viewing are managed through handheld inputs. This can divide attention between steering, looking, and inspection. We compared joystick versus omnidirectional treadmill locomotion and joystick-based versus head-guided camera control in a within-subject 2x2 study in which 17 participants used a virtual reality headset to guide a quadruped robot through a physical maze while locating marked wall symbols and capturing them as visual evidence. Mixed-effects analyses showed that head-guided camera control was associated with faster completion, lower wall-contact cost, lower workload, and more favorable presence, usability, technology acceptance, and flow than joystick-based camera control. The strongest overall objective performance was observed in the joystick locomotion plus head-guided camera condition, whereas the omnidirectional treadmill plus head-guided camera condition emerged as the strongest experiential compromise. Exploratory camera analyses showed that head-guided camera control reduced switching, increased reliance on the pan-tilt view, and supported a more stable viewing strategy across the maze. These strategy differences were consistent with the performance advantage, especially for wall-contact duration. Targets captured remained near ceiling and simulator sickness remained low across all conditions. Overall, the results indicate that viewpoint control was the stronger differentiator in this combined navigation and inspection task, while locomotion still shaped the objective and experiential tradeoff.
Figures & tables
| Component | Operator input | Command behavior | Condition role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joystick locomotion | Left thumbstick for forward motion and yaw. Right thumbstick for lateral motion. | Controller axes were mapped to bounded target velocity commands. Command limits were 0.5 m/s for forward, backward, and lateral motion, and 1.5 rad/s for yaw. | Used in JJ and JH. |
| Omnideck locomotion | Tracked torso translation and yaw while standing on the Omnifinity Omnideck 5. | Body motion was mapped to target velocity commands rather than one to one distance travel. Commands were smoothed, thresholded near zero input, and saturated at the same velocity limits as joystick locomotion. | Used in OJ and OH. |
| Robot Body Camera | Camera switch selected the fixed lower view. | The RBC was a view, not an active camera-control mode. It was aligned with the robot body and supported heading, wall clearance, and recovery of robot body orientation. | Available in all conditions. Robot motion remained body relative. |
| Joystick PTC control | Right thumbstick pan and tilt input when PTC control was active. | Joystick input used a dead zone and updated bounded pan and tilt targets within the 30–240 ∘ pan and 120–220 ∘ tilt soft servo limits. | Used in JJ and OJ. In JJ active robot control and active PTC control were serial because of the mode switch. |
| Head guided PTC control | Headset yaw and pitch relative to a reference frame. | Head motion was mapped to bounded pan and tilt targets within the same soft servo limits. Fast head turns could saturate or lag within the configured PTC range rather than producing unbounded camera motion. | Used in JH and OH. Locomotion and active PTC manipulation could occur together. |
| Camera switching and recentering | Right controller button for view switching and controller recenter commands. | The active view switched between RBC and PTC. Recenter commands returned the PTC to its forward reference. | Available in all conditions. |
| Channel | Median (ms) | IQR (ms) | Trial (ms) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robot command RTT | 9.02 | 8.82–9.55 | 35.95 |
| Robot receive-to-apply | 1.02 | 0.99–1.04 | 1.91 |
| Pan-tilt RTT | 15.22 | 15.00–15.42 | 21.63 |
| Pan-tilt receive-to-apply | 3.00 | 2.00–3.00 | 6.00 |
| Camera sender ACK RTT | 19.53 | 18.98–21.00 | 30.70 |
| Camera receive-to-apply | 7.90 | 7.52–8.09 | 13.95 |
| Measure | Items | Response range | Reported score |
|---|---|---|---|
| NASA-TLX workload | 6 | 1 to 10 | Raw item mean. Lower values indicate lower workload. |
| Simulator sickness symptom score | 11 symptom ratings | 0 to 3 | Mean across symptom ratings. Lower values indicate fewer symptoms. |
| Presence questionnaire | 6 | 1 to 10 | Item mean. Higher values indicate higher presence. |
| System usability scale | 10 | 1 to 5 | Standard SUS conversion to a 0 to 100 score. Higher values indicate higher usability. |
| Technology acceptance | 5 | 1 to 10 | Item mean. Higher values indicate higher acceptance. |
| Flow | 5 | 1 to 10 | Item mean. Higher values indicate higher flow. |
| Outcome | Model | Interface effects | Task and order effects | , |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Completion time | Gamma GLMM, log | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Block order, , Trial in block, , | .304, .696 |
| Target completion | Grouped binomial GLMM, logit | No fixed effect reached significance Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .477, .830 |
| Wall contact count | Negative binomial GLMM, log | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Block order, , | .161, .348 |
| Wall contact duration | Tweedie GLMM, log | Camera control, , | Block order, , | .171, .473 |
| NASA TLX | Gaussian LMM | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Block order, , Trial in block, , | .091, .767 |
| Presence | Gaussian LMM | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Block order, , Trial in block, , | .178, .772 |
| Measure | JJ | JH | OJ | OH |
| Objective outcomes | ||||
| Completion time (s) | 258.25 | 178.49 | 282.36 | 214.45 |
| Targets captured (%) | 99.32 | 98.80 | 99.78 | 99.61 |
| Wall-contact count | 6.05 | 2.79 | 5.13 | 4.96 |
| Wall-contact duration (s) | 19.49 | 11.59 | 23.91 | 14.22 |
| Questionnaire outcomes | ||||
Appendix figures & tables47 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Outcome | Model | Interface effects | Task, order, and practice effects | / |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Completion time | Gamma GLMM, log | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , Block 1 and Block 2 were slower than Block 3 and Block 4. Trial 1 was slower than Trial 2 and Trial 3. | .304 / .696 |
| Wall-contact count | Negative-binomial GLMM, log | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , Estimated counts decreased from Block 1 to Block 4, but no Bonferroni-corrected block contrast remained significant. | .161 / .348 |
| Wall-contact duration | Tweedie GLMM, log | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , Block 1 had longer contact duration than Blocks 2, 3, and 4. | .171 / .473 |
| Outcome | Model | Interface effects | Task, order, and strategy details | / |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Camera switching frequency | Negative-binomial GLMM, log | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .310 / .894 |
| Capture camera share | Beta-binomial GLMM, logit | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .208 / 1.000 |
| Use of both cameras | Binomial GLMM, logit | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .314 / .814 |
| Pan-tilt-camera viewing time | Gaussian LMM | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Block order, , Sensitivity refits changed the significance of camera control. | .069 / .610 |
| Bottom-camera viewing time | Tweedie GLMM, log | Camera control, , Locomotion did not reach significance. | Maze, target count, block order, and trial in block did not reach significance. Sensitivity refits did not change the omnibus conclusions. | .164 / .702 |
| Section-level camera switching | Negative-binomial GLMM, log | Condition, , | Maze section, , Block order, , Trial in block, , Maze and target count did not reach significance. | .20 / .82 |
| Outcome | Interface effects | Task and order effects | / |
|---|---|---|---|
| NASA-TLX | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .091 / .767 |
| Presence (PQ) | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .178 / .772 |
| Simulator sickness (SSQ) | Locomotion, , Camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .022 / .826 |
| Flow | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .071 / .788 |
| System usability (SUS) | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .148 / .763 |
| Technology acceptance (TAM) | Locomotion, , Camera control, , Locomotion by camera control, , | Maze, , Target count, , Block order, , Trial in block, , | .124 / .706 |
Robot Teleoperation
Robot teleoperation studies how people remotely control robots through interfaces, sensing, feedback, and autonomy, despite distance, delay, and embodiment gaps.
See all 229 papers