Modelling the human-exoskeleton interaction interface - Benchmarking MuJoCo's deformable model
Authors: Lisette Masselink, Xiaolong Zhu Thomas George Thuruthel, Mohamed Irfan Refai
Organizations: Chair of Neuromuscular Robotics, Department of Biomechanical Engineering, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands · School of Medical Technology, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing, China · Department of Computer Science, University College London, London, U.K.
The human-exoskeleton interaction interface, consisting of the exoskeleton attachment and the underlying human soft tissue, can affect the transfer of assistance. MuJoCo's flexcomp has been previously used to model the soft tissue, but its accuracy has not been benchmarked against a finite element model. We benchmarked the flexcomp Saint Venant-Kirchhoff (StVK) and Stable Neo-Hookean (SNH) models against COMSOL's Yeoh model in three cases: case 1) spherical indentation, case 2) compression, and case 3) compression of a thigh. We compared force and strain energy as a function of indentation depth, hysteresis and computation time. MuJoCo's models capture force trends with a correlation of 0.97-0.99, but showed a stiffer response, which could be attributed to the volumetric locking of the linear finite elements. The MuJoCo models systematically underestimated hysteresis as MuJoCo's Rayleigh damping could not substitute a viscoelastic model. Moreover, MuJoCo's computational advantage was speed dependent: it was 2-2.5 times faster for spherical indentation, but COMSOL was faster for the other cases, which have more degrees of freedom and contacts. Although MuJoCo's flexcomp offers a combination of soft-tissue modelling and multibody dynamics, the limitations regarding the stiffening and hysteresis should be addressed to be used for the analysis of the human-exoskeleton interaction interface.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1 : Overview of the three cases and the methods to compare them. a) Indentation of a silicon block using a spherical indentor, b) compression of the block using a rigid plate, and c) compression of a thigh model with a rigid plate. Arrows indicate the direction of predescribed movement. Simulations are perfomed using MuJoCo’s St. Venant-Kirchhoff model and Stable Neo-Hookean model, and COMSOL’s Yeoh model.
Tool
Contact-Rich
MSK
Validated
Computational
MBD
Modelling
Soft Tissue
Speed
COMSOL [ 23 ]
✗
✗
✓
✗
MuJoCo [ 6 ]
✓
✓
✗
✓
TABLE I : Comparison of Simulation Tools for Modelling the Human–Exoskeleton Interaction Interface
Parameter
Symbol
Value (Unit)
MuJoCo’s settings
Flexcomp parameters
Young’s modulus
E
40kPa
Poisson’s ratio
ν
0.485
Rayleigh damping coefficient
β
0.002s
Solver model
TABLE II : Material Properties and Simulation Parameters used in MuJoCo (top) and COMSOL (bottom)
Fig. 2 : Snapshots of the MuJoCo (top) and COMSOL (bottom) simulations at initial contact and maximum indentation. Case 1 (left): a spherical indentor indents the soft tissue, which rests on a fixed plate. Case 2 (middle): a plate compresses the soft tissue from above. Case 3 (right): a plate indents a deformable thigh (outer cylinder), which is fixed to the femur (inner cylinder). Top: arrows indicate the magnitude of contact forces, and discs indicate the contact points. Bottom: colours indicate the von Mises stress.
Fig. 3 : Force-indentation (right) and strain energy (bottom) as a function of indentation depth for case 1 (left), case 2 (middle) and case 3 (right). The blue line indicates an indentation speed of 1 mm/s, the orange and green lines indentation speeds of 2 and 5 mm/s, respectively. The solid line is the COMSOL simulation, the dashed line the MuJoCo StVk model and the dotted line the MuJoCo SNH model.
Setup
η (%)
MuJoCo (StVK)
MuJoCo (SNH)
COMSOL
Case 1: 1 mm/s
1.81
0.30
7.67
Case 1: 2 mm/s
2.32
0.61
11.02
Case 1: 5 mm/s
3.73
1.49
15.90
Case 2: 1 mm/s
1.54
0.88
12.09
Case 2: 2 mm/s
2.48
1.93
17.65
TABLE III : Hysteresis ratio relative to the loading work for different setups, comparing MuJoCo and COMSOL simulations under nominal conditions.
Setup
twall (s) (RTF)
MuJoCo (StVK)
MuJoCo (SNH)
COMSOL
Case 1
426 (22.4 × )
536 (28.2 × )
1131 (55.5 × )
Case 2
473 (43.0 × )
483 (43.8 × )
172 (14.3 × )
Case 3
5336 (266.0 × )
5194 (258.9 × )
327 (16.4 × )
Fransen et al. [ 15 ]
156 (39.0 × )
–
–
TABLE IV : Wall-clock time and real-time factor (RTF) for simulations at an indentation speed of 1 mm/s.
Department of Computing Science, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen AB24 3UE, U.K. · Dyson School of Design Engineering, Imperial College London, London, U.K.