Hydrodynamics of robotic micro-swimmers in confinement
Authors: Giovanni Corsi, Giovanni Noselli, Antonio DeSimone
Organizations: The Biorobotics Institute, Scuola Superiore Sant‘Anna, 56127 Pisa, Italy · MathLab SISSA-International School for Advanced Studies, 34136 Trieste, Italy
Inspired by seminal work by E.M. Purcell, we discuss the problem of predicting and optimizing the performance of autonomous robots swimming in confinement. Our approach is based on the explicit numerical resolution of the fluid flow induced by the swimmer, and it is validated experimentally on a cm-size prototype composed of a cargo head and a rotating propulsive tail. Using hydrodynamic scaling, we predict the performance of replicas of our prototype scaled down to mm- and sub-mm-size to test the feasibility of autonomous micro-robots navigating in narrow vessels. The main result of our theoretical, computational, and experimental analysis is that, while hydrodynamics seems to place no fundamental obstruction to the vision of autonomous micro-robots navigating in narrow lumens inside the human body, it does provide useful and strict guidelines for rational design at different length scales.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Representation of the geometry: (A) robot geometry, with helical tail, and definition of variables related to it, and to the confined environment in which swimming occurs. In panel (A) , A is the common tube and swimmer axis and e3 defines its positive direction. The swimmer translates with velocity Ue3 ; the tail and head rotate with angular velocities Ωe3 and (Ω+ω)e3 , respectively, where ωe3 is their prescribed relative angular velocity. Gravity acts along −e3 . (B) Example of mesh for the simulations of the fluid flow, and computed streamlines. (C) 3D-printed components of the swimmer: helical tail, B-series propeller and cargo hull. (D) Example of assembled swimmer used in experiments.
Figure 2: Robot swimming with a helical tail, motor rotation rate ω=18.0 rad/s: (A) Comparison of predicted swimming velocities using either Navier-Stokes (N-S) or Stokes (S) as the equations governing the motion of the fluid. In the Stokes simulations, the distance d/LH between head and tail varies over a range, in order to highlight the effects of hydrodynamic interactions. The S,d/LH=6.54 and Purcell curves are nearly coincident. (B) Pressure along the axis of the tube, for a Navier-Stokes simulation when confinement is r/RH=8.2 , with an indication of the locations of head (H) and tail (T). (C) Iso-velocity curves from Stokes flow simulations, for different values of confinement r/RH (either 1.9 or 8.2 ), and d/LH (either 0 or 2.6 ). The upper and lower rows correspond to r/RH=1.9 and 8.2 , respectively, while the left and right columns correspond to d/LH=0 and 2.6 , respectively.
Figure 3: Robot swimming with a Wageningen B-series marine propeller, motor rotation rate ω=18.0 rad/s: (A) Comparison of predicted swimming velocities using either Navier-Stokes (N-S) or Stokes (S) as the equations governing the motion of the fluid. In the Stokes simulations, the distance d/LH between head and propeller varies over a range, in order to highlight the effects of hydrodynamic interactions. The S,d/LH=6.54 and Purcell curves are closely spaced. (B) Pressure along the axis of the tube, for a Navier-Stokes simulation when confinement is r/RH=8.2 , with an indication of the locations of head (H) and B-series propeller (B). (C) Iso-velocity curves from Stokes flow simulations, for different values of confinement r/RH (either 1.9 or 8.2 ), and d/LH (either 0 or 2.6 ). The upper and lower rows correspond to r/RH=1.9 and 8.2 , respectively, while the left and right columns correspond to d/LH=0 and 2.6 , respectively.
Figure 4: Resistance coefficients, given as a function of the ratio r/RH of confinement, for several values of the separation distance d/LH between head and thrusting part: (A) K11 (drag) and K12 (coupling). (B) K22 (rotational drag) and K23 (viscous torque due to rotation of tail/propeller alone). (C) K13 (drag due to rotation of tail/propeller alone).
Figure 5: Experiments: (A) Comparison of experiments and predictions with different numerical techniques, and for the swimmer moving in the FORE direction. (B) Same comparison for the AFT direction. (C) kymograph of the experiments, for a confinement value of r/RH=1.9 (D) kymograph for r/RH=8.2 .
Data for prototype swimmer and its components
Hull radius, RH [m]
1.3⋅10−2
Hull length, LH [m]
7.65⋅10−2
Factor for drag equivalence sphere/hull, α , high confinement ( r/RH≃2 )