Multi-Objective Optimization

Overview

The field studies problems where improving one objective—such as accuracy, cost, safety, energy use, or fairness—can worsen another, and represents the alternatives as a Pareto frontier. Common approaches include evolutionary algorithms such as NSGA-II, Bayesian optimization for expensive evaluations, gradient-based methods for learning systems, and reinforcement-learning or generative methods for sequential and design tasks. Researchers also develop preference elicitation and constraint-handling methods so people can select useful trade-offs without always computing an entire frontier. A central tension is balancing broad, reliable coverage of feasible trade-offs against evaluation cost, while scalarization, objective scaling, and changing preferences can all affect which solutions are found.

Latest papers

287 papers23 papers in the last four weeks, down 42% on the four weeks before. 0.2% of all new papers.

Feb 8, 2026

Multi-Agent Route Planning as a QUBO Problem

Multi-Agent Route Planning considers selecting vehicles, each associated with a single predefined route, such that route-level coverage utility is maximized while redundant spatial overlaps are limited. This paper gives a formal problem definition, proves NP-hardness by reduction from the Weighted Set Packing problem, and derives a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization formulation whose coefficients directly encode route utility rewards and pairwise overlap penalties. A single penalty parameter λλ controls the coverage--overlap trade-off. We distinguish between a soft regime, which supports multi-objective exploration, and a hard regime, in which the penalty is strong enough to effectively enforce near-disjoint routes. We describe a practical pipeline for generating city instances, constructing candidate routes, building the QUBO matrix, and solving it with a binary quadratic programming baseline (Gurobi), simulated annealing, and D-Wave hybrid quantum annealing. Experiments on Barcelona instances with up to 10,00010{,}000 vehicles reveal a clear coverage--overlap knee and show that Pareto-optimal solutions are mainly obtained under the hard-penalty regime, while D-Wave hybrid solvers and Gurobi achieve very similar objective values on matching configurations with only minor runtime differences as problem size grows.
Feb 6, 2026

Uncovering Cross-Objective Interference in Multi-Objective Alignment

We study a persistent failure mode in multi-objective alignment for large language models (LLMs), in which scalarized training improves only some objectives while the others degrade. We formalize this phenomenon as cross-objective interference and, to our knowledge, conduct the first systematic study of scalarization algorithms for multi-objective LLM alignment. The study shows that interference is pervasive across algorithms yet strongly model-dependent. To understand how interference arises, we derive a local covariance law stating that an objective improves or degrades at first order according to the sign of the covariance between its reward and the scalarized score. We extend this law to the clipped surrogate objectives of modern reinforcement fine-tuning and show that it still holds under mild conditions. Building on this law, we propose COVariance-floor Enforced Reweighting (COVER), a one-sided controller that raises an objective's weight only when the covariance between its reward and the clipped advantage weight falls below a target. Through extensive experiments, we find that COVER can mitigate cross-objective interference while matching linear scalarization when objectives already co-improve. Finally, to explain why interference is model-dependent, we complement the local covariance law with a global convergence analysis. This analysis gives sufficient conditions for the non-convex scalarized objective to satisfy the Polyak--Łojasiewicz condition and relates interference to model geometry.
Feb 5, 2026

Variable Search Stepsize for Randomized Local Search in Multi-Objective Combinatorial Optimization

Over the past two decades, research in evolutionary multi-objective optimization has predominantly focused on continuous domains, with comparatively limited attention given to multi-objective combinatorial optimization problems (MOCOPs). Combinatorial problems differ significantly from continuous ones in terms of problem structure and landscape. Recent studies have shown that on MOCOPs multi-objective evolutionary algorithms (MOEAs) can even be outperformed by simple randomised local search. Starting with a randomly sampled solution in search space, randomised local search iteratively draws a random solution (from an archive) to perform local variation within its neighbourhood. However, in most existing methods, the local variation relies on a fixed neighbourhood, which limits exploration and makes the search easy to get trapped in local optima. In this paper, we present a simple yet effective local search method, called variable stepsize randomized local search (VS-RLS), which adjusts the stepsize during the search. VS-RLS transitions gradually from a broad, exploratory search in the early phases to a more focused, fine-grained search as the search progresses. We demonstrate the effectiveness and generalizability of VS-RLS through extensive evaluations against local search and MOEAs methods on diverse MOCOPs.
Feb 3, 2026

NeuroPareto: Calibrated Acquisition for Costly Many-Goal Search in Vast Parameter Spaces

The pursuit of optimal trade-offs in high-dimensional search spaces under stringent computational constraints poses a fundamental challenge for contemporary multi-objective optimization. We develop NeuroPareto, a cohesive architecture that integrates rank-centric filtering, uncertainty disentanglement, and history-conditioned acquisition strategies to navigate complex objective landscapes. A calibrated Bayesian classifier estimates epistemic uncertainty across non-domination tiers, enabling rapid generation of high-quality candidates with minimal evaluation cost. Deep Gaussian Process surrogates further separate predictive uncertainty into reducible and irreducible components, providing refined predictive means and risk-aware signals for downstream selection. A lightweight acquisition network, trained online from historical hypervolume improvements, guides expensive evaluations toward regions balancing convergence and diversity. With hierarchical screening and amortized surrogate updates, the method maintains accuracy while keeping computational overhead low. Experiments on DTLZ and ZDT suites and a subsurface energy extraction task show that NeuroPareto consistently outperforms classifier-enhanced and surrogate-assisted baselines in Pareto proximity and hypervolume.
Jan 30, 2026

Fairness-Aware Performance Evaluation for Multi-Party Multi-Objective Optimization

In multiparty multiobjective optimization problems, solution sets are usually evaluated using classical performance metrics, aggregated across DMs. However, such mean-based evaluations may be unfair by favoring certain parties, as they assume identical geometric approximation quality to each party's PF carries comparable evaluative significance. Moreover, prevailing notions of MPMOP optimal solutions are restricted to strictly common Pareto optimal solutions, representing a narrow form of cooperation in multiparty decision making scenarios. These limitations obscure whether a solution set reflects balanced relative gains or meaningful consensus among heterogeneous DMs. To address these issues, this paper develops a fairness-aware performance evaluation framework grounded in a generalized notion of consensus solutions. From a cooperative game-theoretic perspective, we formalize four axioms that a fairness-aware evaluation function for MPMOPs should satisfy. By introducing a concession rate vector to quantify acceptable compromises by individual DMs, we generalize the classical definition of MPMOP optimal solutions and embed classical performance metrics into a Nash-product-based evaluation framework, which is theoretically shown to satisfy all axioms. To support empirical validation, we further construct benchmark problems that extend existing MPMOP suites by incorporating consensus-deficient negotiation structures. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed evaluation framework is able to distinguish algorithmic performance in a manner consistent with consensus-aware fairness considerations. Specifically, algorithms converging toward strictly common solutions are assigned higher evaluation scores when such solutions exist, whereas in the absence of strictly common solutions, algorithms that effectively cover the commonly acceptable region are more favorably evaluated.
Dec 30, 2025

Decoupling Constraints from Two Directions for Evolutionary Constrained Multi-objective Optimization

Real-world constrained multi-objective optimization problems (CMOPs) commonly involve multiple constraints, and understanding and exploiting their coupling relationships is crucial for efficient optimization. Recent constraint-decoupling methods handle individual constraints separately, but they generally search only in the evolutionary direction to approximate single-constraint Pareto fronts (SCPFs). In this study, we show that part or all of the constrained Pareto front (CPF) may be unrelated to any SCPF and instead be shaped by the boundaries of infeasible regions. We refer to such a portion as the independent CPF (ICPF) and introduce the reverse CPF (RCPF) to characterize its associated informative infeasible boundaries. Based on these observations, we propose a bidirectional constraint-decoupling coevolutionary algorithm named DCF2D. DCF2D dynamically identifies the constraints obstructing the main population and activates constraint-specific auxiliary populations. These populations adaptively search in the evolutionary direction for the corresponding SCPFs or in the reverse evolutionary direction for the corresponding RCPFs. Its three-stage framework integrates unconstrained global exploration, event-driven bidirectional coevolution, and final convergence refinement. Experiments on 87 benchmark instances from seven test suites and 28 real-world engineering CMOPs demonstrate that DCF2D achieves the best overall performance among nine algorithms. Code available at: https://github.com/RuiqingS/DCF2D.
Dec 20, 2025

Large-scale benchmarking of multi-objective soft-computing metaheuristics for redundancy allocation in repairable k-out-of-n systems

This paper presents a large-scale budget-aware benchmark of multi-objective soft-computing metaheuristics for a bi-objective redundancy allocation problem in repairable k-out-of-n systems. The problem combines cost minimization and steady-state availability maximization under weight constraints, with binary subsystem-level decisions determining both the number of redundant components and the redundancy strategy. Four strategies are considered: cold standby, warm standby, hot standby, and a mixed active-warm standby strategy. Subsystem availability is evaluated using continuous-time Markov chains, while the optimization task is treated as a constrained mixed-integer multi-objective problem. The study compares 65 metaheuristic algorithms from multiple algorithmic families under two initialization settings, with and without Scaled Binomial Initialization (SBI), across six case studies of increasing structural and dimensional complexity and four weight limits per case. Performance is assessed using hypervolume, budget-dependent convergence profiles, and non-parametric statistical comparisons. The results show that algorithm rankings are strongly budget-dependent, indicating that a single final-budget ranking can be misleading. SBI provides a substantial early advantage and can change the relative performance of competing methods, especially for larger instances. The best-performing algorithms vary across budget regimes: NNIA-SBI and CMOPSO-SBI are competitive under tight budgets, whereas NSGA-II+ARSBX-SBI performs robustly for medium and large budgets. From a system design perspective, Pareto-optimal solutions are dominated by hot standby and mixed redundancy strategies, while cold and warm standby rarely appear. The benchmark highlights the importance of initialization, computational budget, and problem complexity when selecting soft-computing optimizers for practical redundancy allocation.
Nov 9, 2025

Feature weighting for data analysis via evolutionary simulation

We analyze an algorithm for assigning weights prior to scalarization in discrete multi-objective problems arising from data analysis. The algorithm evolves weights (interpreted as the relevance of features) by a replicator-type dynamic on the standard simplex, with update indices computed from a normalized data matrix. We prove that the resulting sequence converges globally to a unique interior equilibrium, yielding non-degenerate limiting weights.
Sep 26, 2025

OFMU: Optimization-Driven Framework for Machine Unlearning

Large language models deployed in sensitive applications increasingly require the ability to unlearn specific knowledge, such as user requests, copyrighted materials, or outdated information, without retraining from scratch to ensure regulatory compliance, user privacy, and safety. This task, known as machine unlearning, aims to remove the influence of targeted data (forgetting) while maintaining performance on the remaining data (retention). A common approach is to formulate this as a multi-objective problem and reduce it to a single-objective problem via scalarization, where forgetting and retention losses are combined using a weighted sum. However, this often results in unstable training dynamics and degraded model utility due to conflicting gradient directions. To address these challenges, we propose OFMU, a penalty-based bi-level optimization framework that explicitly prioritizes forgetting while preserving retention through a hierarchical structure. Our method enforces forgetting via an inner maximization step that incorporates a similarity-aware penalty to decorrelate the gradients of the forget and retention objectives, and restores utility through an outer minimization step. To ensure scalability, we develop a two-loop algorithm with provable convergence guarantees under both convex and non-convex regimes. We further provide a rigorous theoretical analysis of convergence rates and show that our approach achieves better trade-offs between forgetting efficacy and model utility compared to prior methods. Extensive experiments across vision and language benchmarks demonstrate that OFMU consistently outperforms existing unlearning methods in both forgetting efficacy and retained utility.
Sep 3, 2025

FoMEMO: Towards Foundation Models for Expensive Multi-objective Optimization

Expensive multi-objective optimization is a prevalent and crucial concern in many real-world scenarios, where sample-efficiency is vital due to the limited evaluations to recover the true Pareto front for decision making. Existing works either involve repeatedly fitting Gaussian process surrogates from scratch for each newly encountered problem, or rely on computationally demanding hypervolume-oriented policy learning for amortized optimization, making it challenging to achieve scalable pre-training and efficient yet robust adaptation for diverse emerging real-world applications. To address these challenges, we propose FoMEMO (Foundation Models for Expensive Multi-objective Optimization), which adopts a decomposition-based training paradigm that converts multi-objective optimization into preference-wise aggregated posterior learning tasks, enabling scalable pre-training on hundreds of millions of diverse synthetic datasets without relying on extensive real-world domain experiments. At test time, given observed trajectories from unseen problems and user preferences, the foundation model performs in-context posterior prediction and optimizes the derived acquisition functions for efficient candidate generation, achieving strong generalization and optimization performance without any subsequent model training or updates.
Jun 27, 2025

Interactive Multi-Objective Probabilistic Preference Learning with Soft and Hard Bounds

High-stakes decision-making involves navigating multiple competing objectives with expensive evaluations. For instance, in brachytherapy, clinicians must balance maximizing tumor coverage (e.g., an aspirational target or soft bound of >95% coverage) against strict organ dose limits (e.g., a non-negotiable hard bound of <601cGy to the bladder). Selecting Pareto-optimal solutions that match implicit preferences is challenging, as exhaustive Pareto frontier exploration is computationally and cognitively prohibitive, necessitating interactive frameworks to guide users. While decision-makers (DMs) often possess domain knowledge to narrow the search via such soft-hard bounds, current methods often lack systematic approaches to iteratively refine these multi-faceted preference structures. Furthermore, DMs often require confidence that they have not overlooked superior alternatives, a paramount necessity in high-stakes scenarios. We present Active-MoSH, an interactive local-global framework designed for this process. Its local component integrates probabilistic preference learning with an active sampling strategy to adaptively refine Pareto subsets while minimizing cognitive burden. To bolster decision confidence, Active-MoSH's global component, C-MoSH, leverages multi-objective sensitivity analysis to identify potentially overlooked, high-value points beyond immediate feedback. We demonstrate Active-MoSH's performance benefits through diverse synthetic and real-world applications. A high-stakes case study with real cervical cancer brachytherapy treatment plans and an image selection user study further validate our hypotheses regarding the framework's ability to improve convergence, enhance DM confidence, and provide expressive preference articulation.
Dec 11, 2024

Variational Model Merging for Pareto Front Estimation in Multitask Finetuning

Pareto fronts are useful to find good task-mixing strategies for multitask finetuning, but they are also costly to compute. To reduce costs, recent works have used existing model merging methods to help train cheap surrogate models to estimate the Pareto fronts. However, no work has yet considered designing new model-merging methods to directly, and provably, improve the quality of Pareto fronts. Here, we fill this gap by proposing a new Bayesian approach called Variational Model Merging. In this approach, existing model-merging methods are obtained as special cases of "posterior-merging" when Gaussian posteriors are used and new model-merging strategies can be derived by using non-Gaussian posteriors. Our main theoretical result is to show that more flexible posteriors necessarily yield better estimates of Pareto fronts. For instance, a Pareto front estimate obtained by merging full-Gaussian posteriors is expected to be better than that obtained by using isotropic Gaussian posteriors. We validate the theory through extensive empirical results on vision and language transformers where better Gaussian families consistently yields better or comparable Pareto fronts. Our work is a rare instance where Bayesian ideas are used to improve Pareto analysis.
Sep 17, 2024

Lexicographic Descent: A Gradient-Based Approach to Optimize Totally Ordered Rulebooks via Parametric Scalarization

Safety-critical systems, such as autonomous vehicles, must satisfy conflicting constraints and objectives, collectively called rules, typically ordered lexicographically. Preemptive lexicographic optimization solves a sequence of problems, one per priority level. However, higher levels are optimized without considering lower ones, making the approach susceptible to suboptimal solutions. On the other hand, scalarization optimizes all levels jointly and so avoids this myopia, but a finite weighted sum permits trade-offs across priority levels, and exact scalar representations lack the regularity standard solvers require. We propose Lexicographic Descent, which combines the benefits of both: a single weighted sum whose relative weights decay at priority-dependent rates, recovering the lexicographic order in the limit. We show that Lexicographic Descent converges to constrained stationary points of the highest-priority rule, matching preemptive guarantees. Since the lower-priority weights vanish, we derive a necessary condition for the lower-priority rules to keep guiding the iterates, with the aim of avoiding suboptimal stationary points of the higher-priority rules. We show that Lexicographic Descent can exploit problem structure to reach the lexicographic optima, and outperforms the preemptive approach on an autonomous driving case study.
Sep 12, 2024

Design Optimization of Nuclear Fusion Reactor through Deep Reinforcement Learning

In this research, we investigate deep reinforcement learning (DRL) as a practical tool for constrained, multi-objective optimization for tokamak fusion reactor designs. The task is to optimize the design configurations that minimize building cost while achieving high energy gain and long energy confinement time, subject to the four operational limits required for stable operation. Due to the coupled physics-engineering evaluation, the resulting objectives and constraints are black-box, making it challenging to find optimal solutions with conventional search strategies. To address this, we implement Reward-Constrained Policy Optimization (RCPO) for tokamak fusion reactor design. This method integrates multiple constraints into the reward functions, guiding the policy towards feasible solutions and simplifying the design optimization process. Our numerical results show that the proposed DRL-based approach finds more feasible designs that satisfy operational constraints more efficiently than other data-driven optimization methods, demonstrating the potential of DRL for efficient future reactor design.
Jun 23, 2024

Jacobian Descent for Multi-Objective Optimization

Many optimization problems require balancing multiple conflicting objectives. To generalize gradient descent, which is limited to single-objective optimization, we introduce Jacobian descent (JD) and its stochastic variants. This algorithm iteratively updates parameters using the Jacobian matrix of a vector-valued objective function, in which each row is the gradient of an individual objective. While several methods to combine gradients already exist in the literature, they generally struggle when the objectives conflict. In contrast, we propose projecting gradients to fully resolve conflict. We prove convergence to the Pareto front in the smooth convex case with this approach, a stronger guarantee than the usual convergence to a weakly Pareto stationary point. Our method also enables instance-wise risk minimization (IWRM), a novel learning paradigm in which the loss of each training example is considered a separate objective. Early experimentation on image classification shows promising results for IWRM. Lastly, we provide an efficient implementation of JD using the Gramian of the Jacobian matrix to drastically reduce memory requirements.
Jan 7, 2024

Multi-Objective Hyperparameter Search via Damped Gauss--Newton Optimization

We study hyperparameter optimization (HPO) from a numerical-optimization perspective and propose a multi-objective damped Newton--Gauss--Newton search method. Rather than perturbing each hyperparameter separately or treating model evaluations as independent trials, the method uses performance changes between successive full hyperparameter vectors to construct an iterative secant approximation of the local sensitivity matrix. Each iteration therefore requires only one new full-vector model evaluation while jointly updating all optimized hyperparameters. A Tikhonov-regularized Gauss--Newton system stabilizes the update when the number of hyperparameters exceeds the number of performance objectives. The search is initialized from readily available empirical/default settings of the underlying learner, without requiring a separate initialization search. We evaluate four-dimensional XGBoost HPO on three public classification datasets against exhaustive grid search, random search, and tree-structured Parzen estimator (TPE) optimization. On Breast Cancer Wisconsin, the proposed method matches the best validation accuracy of a 320-configuration grid search with slightly better log loss and ROC--AUC. Across three datasets and three seeds, predictive performance remains competitive with random search and TPE while using substantially fewer search iterations. A supplementary proprietary eight-dimensional threshold-optimization case study further demonstrates joint multi-parameter optimization under competing performance targets and reveals non-monotonic, oscillatory trajectories that motivate damping and best-iterate selection. Overall, the results establish iterative secant sensitivity as an evaluation-efficient local alternative to exhaustive HPO.
May 15, 2023

Python Tool for Visualizing Variability of Pareto Fronts over Multiple Runs

Hyperparameter optimization is crucial to achieving high performance in deep learning. On top of the performance, other criteria such as inference time or memory requirement often need to be optimized due to some practical reasons. This motivates research on multi-objective optimization (MOO). However, Pareto fronts of MOO methods are often shown without considering the variability caused by random seeds and this makes the performance stability evaluation difficult. Although there is a concept named empirical attainment surface to enable the visualization with uncertainty over multiple runs, there is no major Python package for empirical attainment surface. We, therefore, develop a Python package for this purpose and describe the usage. The package is available at https://github.com/nabenabe0928/empirical-attainment-func. OptunaHub now provides our implementation at https://hub.optuna.org/visualization/plot_empirical_attainment_surface/.