The design of multicopter drones has remained almost the same since their inception. While conventional designs work well in many cases, they may not be optimal in specific tasks. This paper revisits rotary drone design by exploring which body morphologies are best suited for different objectives and constraints. An evolutionary algorithm is used to produce drone morphologies that performs better than standard configurations at thrust-to-weight ratio, maneuverability and size. To generate a range of drones with performance trade-offs between them, the non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm II is used. The evolved drone bodies outperform a standard multicopters in at least one of the three objectives. The Pareto front extrema show improvement of 489.2%, 23% and 4.8% in maneuverability, thrust-to-weight ratio and size, respectively, when compared to a standard quadcopter. The improvement in maneuverability is attributed to the tilt angles of the motors, while the increase in thrust-to-weight ratio is due to the higher number of propellers. Experiments show that the performance improvement transfers to a real world drone racing task, where the evolved drone outperforms the standard drone in terms of number of gates passed,flight speed and lap times.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: We use a multi-objective evolution algorithm to generate novel propeller-based drone designs. In this study, the most maneuverable drone produced by the evolution process is selected and its performance is compared to that of a standard quadcopter in a drone racing task (top). The top-left and top-right images illustrate the differences between the standard and the evolved drone, featuring different motor positions and propeller orientations for the latter. The bottom images show the flight paths of the standard quadcopter (middle) and the evolved drone (bottom) over the same duration. In the same time that the standard quadcopter only manages to complete part of a lap, the evolved drone successfully completes a full lap.
Parameter
Value
Main body weight
300 g
Arm mass per unit length
75 g/m
Propeller and motor mass
33.5 g
Propeller thrust coefficient
1.08 × 10 -6
Propeller torque coefficient
1.22 × 10 -8
Table 1: Physical parameters used for evolution
Figure 2: Percentage of number of arms for each generation.
Figure 3: Scatter plot of Pareto optimal and standard drones’ thrust-to-weight ratio ( α ) against maneuverability ( λ ) at generation 2000. Standard drones marked in dotted red circles are dominated.
Figure 4: Scatter plot of Pareto optimal and standard drones’ size against maneuverability at generation 2000. Standard drones marked in dotted red circles are dominated.
Figure 5: Scatter plot of Pareto optimal standard drones’ thrust-to-weight ratio ( α ) against size at generation 2000. Standard drones marked in dotted red circles are dominated.
Figure 6: Pareto extrema drones after 2000 generations.
Figure 7: Lemniscate trajectory (black) with seven gates (grey) of size 1.5x1.5m. The size of the track is parameterized by gate distance R.
Params
Std
Evo
Params
Std
Evo
kωx (10 -6 )
0.0
2.56
kx (10 -5 )
-3.53
-7.37
kωy (10 -6 )
0.0
4.88
ky (10 -5 )
-4.99
-8.55
kωz (10 -6 )
2.55
2.47
kz (10 -4 )
0.0
-2.02
kp1 (10 -5 )
-6.51
-7.38
kdp1 (10 -4 )
0.0
1.38
kp2 (10 -5 )
-6.18
-4.93
kdp2 (10 -5 )
0.0
9.13
kp3 (10 -5 )
6.21
5.26
kdp3 (10 -4 )
0.0
1.15
Table 2: Drone parameters for domain randomization
Parameter
Value
Number of parallel environments
100
Maximum training steps
1 ×108
Batch size
5000
Discount factor ( γ )
0.999
Policy network size
[64, 64, 64]
Value network size
[64, 64, 64]
Table 3: Hyperparameters used for PPO training.
Figure 8: Mean episodic reward over three runs for the standard and evolved drones navigating the R=1.5m and R=1.0m tracks.
Figure 9: Speed of the standard (blue) and evolved (red) drones for (a) R=1.5 m track and (b) R=1.0 m track.
Figure 10: Trajectories of the standard quadcopter and the evolved drone for the R=1.5m (top) and R=1.0m (bottom) tracks. The color of the lines represents the speed of the drones.
Figure 11: Number of gates passed in 10s by the standard drone (blue) and the evolved drone (red) in both tracks over 5 runs. Experimental results are compared with simulations. Higher numbers are better.
Figure 12: Fastest lap achieved by the standard drone (blue) and the evolved drone (red) in both tracks over 5 runs. Lower times are better.
Aerial robots operating in cluttered environments may encounter openings narrower than their nominal width. Existing passively morphing drones reduce their width upon traversal, but they typically involve human-made designs, which can struggle to find the right balance among folding ratio, flight efficiency, and control tracking performance. We introduce a closed-loop design method that jointly optimizes quadrotor geometry and the torque-deflection response of two passively folding arms driven by the success rate in simulation for contact-mediated gap traversal. An optimization algorithm samples candidate designs that are evaluated in a contact-based simulation of the traversal task, where the task success rate is used as a feedback signal to sample progressively better designs over time. The resulting prototype passively reduces its width from 31.3 to 14.1 cm and traverses a 15 cm wide opening at a 2 m/s reference speed. It also tolerates gap approach-angle errors of up to 30 degrees and folds through a 40 cm long confined passage. Compared to a rigid twin, the soft configuration adds only 2 mm of position RMSE and less than 1% electrical power during contact-free flight. These results show that task-driven closed-loop design optimization can produce passively morphing airframes that are compact under contact, tolerant to approach error, and effectively rigid during nominal flight.
Etor Arza, Luca Girardi, Gabriel Maquignaz +4
Department of Engineering Cybernetics, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), Trondheim, Norway. · Mobile Robotics Lab, Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland. · Agricultural Robotics, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
Multirotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) design is governed by a tightly coupled system of non-linear equations spanning structural mechanics, electrochemistry, aerodynamics, and kinematics. Solved sequentially, a miscalibrated sub-model coefficient triggers a mass-compounding cascade failure--the Mass Snowball effect. This paper presents AeroEval, a physics-based, Multidisciplinary Design Optimization (MDO) engine that simultaneously resolves all subsystem couplings and maps continuous sizing optima to physically purchasable, commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) components. The MDO engine is validated under a strict calibrate/test protocol that eliminates circularity: three structural/packaging coefficients are fitted on a held-out cohort of 20 do-it-yourself (DIY) and legacy platforms, then frozen and evaluated blind on 19 modern commercial drone platforms spanning 377 g to 76 kg. On the commercial test cohort the engine predicts Maximum Takeoff Weight (MTOW) within 7.2% Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE), with a mean complexity factor k≈1.05±0.08 and RMSEMTOW=1.59 kg; the DIY calibration cohort, characterized by high build variability, yields 26.1% MAPE. Battery mass is predicted within 7.9% on single-pack platforms, with a disclosed systematic underprediction on redundant multi-battery enterprise platforms. A 14-parameter sensitivity suite of >300 simulations quantifies partial derivatives of takeoff mass and flight time; forward velocity diverges beyond 25.5 m/s due to cubic parasite power growth. The path-dependent mass-shedding model for agricultural and delivery roles reduces structural frame mass by up to 40.6% and energy capacity by 33.7% relative to static baselines. Typical solver convergence requires 25-50 iterations, completing in under 50 ms on a standard desktop CPU.
Akshay Gupta Burela, P. B. Sujit
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, International Institute of Information Technology, Hyderabad, India · Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Bhopal, India
The size of a narrow gap traversable by a fixed-wing drone is limited by its wingspan. Inspired by birds, here, we enable the traversal of a gap of sub-wingspan width and height using a morphing-wing drone capable of temporarily sweeping in its wings mid-flight. This maneuver poses control challenges due to sudden lift loss during gap-passage at low flight speeds and the need for precisely timed wing-sweep actuation ahead of the gap. To address these challenges, we first develop an aerodynamic model for general wing-sweep morphing drone flight including low flight speeds and post-stall angles of attack. We integrate longitudinal drone dynamics into an optimal reference trajectory generation and Nonlinear Model Predictive Control framework with runtime adaptive costs and constraints. Validated on a 130 g wing-sweep-morphing drone, our method achieves an average altitude error of 5 cm during narrow-gap passage at forward speeds between 5 and 7 m/s, whilst enforcing fully swept wings near the gap across variable threshold distances. Trajectory analysis shows that the drone can compensate for lift loss during gap-passage by accelerating and pitching upwards ahead of the gap to an extent that differs between reference trajectory optimization objectives. We show that our strategy also allows for accurate gap passage on hardware whilst maintaining a constant forward flight speed reference and near-constant altitude.
Julius Wanner, Hoang-Vu Phan, Charbel Toumieh +1
Laboratory of Intelligent Systems, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Lausanne, Switzerland · Avian-Insect Robotics in Motion Laboratory, University of Nevada, Reno, USA