cs.LGJun 25, 2025

Counterfactual Operator Relevance for PDE Discovery: Screening, Pruning, and Identifiability

Authors: Ronald Katende

Organizations: Department of Mathematics Kabale University Kikungiri Hill, Katuna Road, 317, Kabale, Uganda

Abstract

We study operator relevance in data-driven partial differential equation (PDE) discovery. Sparse residual methods can select terms that improve residual fit, but residual contribution is not the same as functional necessity. We formalize this distinction through counterfactual operator interventions, where a candidate term is deleted or perturbed and the factual and intervened trajectories, or observables, are compared. The resulting theory gives six reusable results. A residual--counterfactual gap theorem shows that deletion effects are governed by the inverse linearized PDE map, not by residual magnitude alone. A certified decision theorem gives error margins for relevance, irrelevance, and abstention under neural or numerical surrogate error. An aliasing theorem characterizes experiment-dependent non-identifiability through the null space of the operator-evaluation design. A constraint-manifold theorem shows that operators vanishing on invariant constraint classes cannot be identified from trajectories restricted to those classes. A pruning-consistency theorem proves that sparse screening followed by counterfactual deletion recovers the functionally relevant support under a recall and margin condition. An observable-level adjoint theorem extends relevance testing from full-state deviations to scientific quantities of interest. Validation experiments test these mechanisms on synthetic PDEs with known support and on public geophysical fields from atmospheric reanalysis and NOAA OISST. The real-data results are reported as operator-surrogate diagnostics, not as unconditional recovery of physical laws. The framework provides a rigorous diagnostic layer for distinguishing residual usefulness from counterfactual operator relevance within a specified library, experiment class, norm, and tolerance.

Explore similar work

CardsList
May 12, 2026cs.LG

EqOD: Symmetry-Informed Stability Selection for PDE Identification

Data-driven identification of partial differential equations (PDEs) relies on sparse regression over a candidate library of differential operators, where larger libraries inflate false positives under observation noise and smaller libraries risk missing true terms. We introduce Equivariant Operator Discovery (EqOD), a fully automatic method combining two library reduction mechanisms. When Galilean invariance is detected from trajectory data via a weak-form structural test, EqOD uses the symmetry-reduced library, eliminating terms that our Galilean exclusion result proves to be absent from the governing equation. Otherwise, it applies randomized LASSO stability selection guided by classical false-positive bounds. A residual-based fallback prevents degradation below the full-library baseline. On 8 PDEs at 4 noise levels, EqOD attains F1=1.000±0.000F_1 = 1.000 \pm 0.000 on Heat at 20%20\% noise, where WF-LASSO obtains 0.475±0.1810.475 \pm 0.181, official PySINDy 2.0 obtains 0.0000.000, and the WSINDy reimplementation obtains 0.7890.789. Under the strict criterion that the mean F1 difference exceeds the larger of the two standard deviations, EqOD wins 7 of 32 cells. WF-LASSO wins none, and the remaining 25 cells are ties. Across all 32 cells, EqOD outperforms PySINDy 2.0.0 in 23 of 32 cells, and all 5 PySINDy wins occur on reaction PDEs. External validation on WeakIdent and PINN-SR datasets gives F1=1.000F_1 = 1.000 on all 5 clean benchmarks. NLS, 2D, coupled-system, and cylinder-wake extensions are reported. The Galilean library reduction is proved under explicit autonomy and library assumptions. The stability-selection step is motivated by classical false-positive bounds, while formal guarantees for correlated PDE design matrices remain open.
Gnankan Landry Regis N'guessan, Bum Jun Kim
Partial Differential EquationsSystem IdentificationLasso
AskPDF
May 26, 2026stat.AP

Data-driven sparse identification of governing PDEs via knockoff filters and multi-criteria trade-offs

We propose KO-PDE-IDENT, a data-driven framework for identifying parsimonious partial differential equations (PDEs) with false discovery rate (FDR) control. PDE discovery from noisy observations is often hindered by extreme multicollinearity among candidate terms, which causes typical sparse-regression methods to select spurious terms. To address this problem, KO-PDE-IDENT initially mines a support set of potential candidate terms via model-X knockoff filters with finite-sample FDR control, then refines and ranks the surviving PDE alternatives. The framework integrates three components. First, knockoff feature statistics are constructed by coupling ℓ0\ell_{0}-constrained adaptive best-subset selection with SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP), yielding an effective and computationally efficient difference statistic. Second, a recursive feature elimination (RFE) procedure removes terms whose marginal contributions are dispensable and assesses statistical necessity through knockoff-perturbed hypothesis testing. Third, the final model selection is formulated as a multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) problem, where the optimal governing equation is the alternative that best balances a wide range of criteria such as predictive accuracy, model complexity and coefficient uncertainty. We evaluate KO-PDE-IDENT on five canonical PDEs under severe noise corruption. Empirical results show that our framework can exactly recover the true PDE structure, eliminating false discoveries while retaining all true underlying terms, with low coefficient estimation error.
Pongpisit Thanasutives, Naichang Ke, Yoshinobu Kawahara
Partial Differential EquationsFalse Discovery RateSystem IdentificationTwo-Sample TestingTrade-OffForgeries
AskPDF
Jun 16, 2026cs.LG

Operator Boosting Produces Pareto-Efficient PDE Surrogates

Neural operators are widely used as surrogate solution maps for partial differential equations (PDEs), but full-size models can be costly to store, deploy, and evaluate in many-query scientific workflows. This work introduces Operator Boosting, a stagewise residual-learning framework for constructing compact neural-operator surrogates directly, rather than training a large model and compressing it afterward. Starting from the empirical mean predictor in normalized output coordinates, the method trains a sequence of tiny same-family neural operators on residual fields and incorporates each correction through validation-selected shrinkage. We instantiate the framework with Fourier neural operators (FNOs), DeepONets, and convolutional neural operators (CNOs), and compare boosted tiny stacks against full-size monolithic baselines across one-, two-, and three-dimensional PDE benchmarks from PDEBench, APEBench, and The Well. Across 30 dataset-architecture pairs, 21 show positive mean accuracy gains and 17 have positive confidence intervals, while all boosted stacks reduce trainable parameter count by approximately 72-95%. Best-model comparisons show empirical Pareto improvements on 7 of 10 completed PDE benchmarks, including two-dimensional Navier-Stokes, shallow-water dynamics, Darcy flow, one-dimensional transport and reaction systems, and three-dimensional compressible Navier-Stokes. These results show that Operator Boosting often improves the empirical accuracy-parameter Pareto frontier of neural PDE surrogates, while also exposing PDE- and architecture-dependent regimes where residual boosting fails to offset compression.
Lennon J. Shikhman
Neural OperatorsSurrogate Modeling
AskPDF