cs.CVSep 21, 2025

The SAGES Critical View of Safety Challenge: A Global Benchmark for AI-Assisted Surgical Quality Assessment

Authors: Deepak Alapatt, Jennifer Eckhoff, Zhiliang Lyu, Yutong Ban, Jean-Paul Mazellier, Sarah Choksi, Kunyi Yang, Po-Hsing Chiang, 

Abstract

Advances in artificial intelligence (AI) for surgical quality assessment promise to democratize access to expertise, with applications in training, guidance, and accreditation. This study presents the SAGES Critical View of Safety (CVS) Challenge, the first AI competition organized by a surgical society, using the CVS in laparoscopic cholecystectomy, a universally recommended yet inconsistently performed safety step, as an exemplar of surgical quality assessment. A global collaboration across 54 institutions in 24 countries engaged hundreds of clinicians and engineers to curate 1,000 videos annotated by 20 surgical experts according to a consensus-validated protocol. The challenge addressed key barriers to real-world deployment in surgery, including achieving high performance, capturing uncertainty in subjective assessment, and ensuring robustness to clinical variability. To enable this scale of effort, we developed EndoGlacier, a framework for managing large, heterogeneous surgical video and multi-annotator workflows. Thirteen international teams participated, achieving up to a 17% relative gain in assessment performance, over 62% reduction in calibration error, and a 17% relative improvement in robustness over the state-of-the-art. Analysis of results highlighted methodological trends linked to model performance, providing guidance for future research toward robust, clinically deployable AI for surgical quality assessment.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Jun 16, 2026

AI for Quality Assurance in the Operating Room

Surgical outcomes depend not only on patient factors and postoperative care but are also strongly influenced by the quality of the operation itself. Yet, for much of mod-ern surgery, intraoperative quality has been assessed indirectly through outcomes and operative reports. The increase in minimally invasive procedures inherently guided by endoscopic video, together with advances in artificial intelligence, creates an unprecedented opportunity to systematically observe, measure, and improve surgi-cal care. This chapter introduces AI-enabled Surgical Quality Assurance as a frame-work for using surgical data to support continuous assessment and improvement in the operating room. We first review existing approaches to surgical safety, from sys-tem-level interventions to procedure-specific standards. We then describe how AI can transform intraoperative video into clinically meaningful information, including recog-nition of anatomy, instruments, workflow, surgical actions, quality criteria, adverse events, and critical moments. Finally, we outline the major challenges that must be addressed before these systems can deliver routine clinical value, including representa-tive data collection, robust validation, workflow integration, regulation, liability, pri-vacy, and equitable access. Rather than replacing surgical judgment, AI for quality assurance should be understood as a set of tools for augmenting the surgical team, scaling expert review, and helping surgery evolve toward a learning system in which intraoperative care is continuously observed, assessed, and improved.
Apr 24, 2026

Sum-of-Checks: Structured Reasoning for Surgical Safety with Large Vision-Language Models

Purpose: Accurate assessment of the Critical View of Safety (CVS) during laparoscopic cholecystectomy is essential to prevent bile duct injury, a complication associated with significant morbidity and mortality. While large vision-language models (LVLMs) offer flexible reasoning, their predictions remain difficult to audit and unreliable on safety-critical surgical tasks. Methods: We introduce Sum-of-Checks, a framework that decomposes each CVS criterion into expert-defined reasoning checks reflecting clinically relevant visual evidence. Given a laparoscopic frame, an LVLM evaluates each check, producing a binary judgment and justification. Criterion-level scores are computed via fixed, weighted aggregation of check outcomes. We evaluate on the Endoscapes2023 benchmark using three frontier LVLMs, comparing against direct prompting, chain-of-thought, and sub-question decomposition, each with and without few-shot examples. Results: Sum-of-Checks improves average frame-level mean average precision by 12--14% relative to the best baseline across all three models and criteria. Analysis of individual checks reveals that LVLMs are reliable on observational checks (e.g., visibility, tool obstruction) but show substantial variability on decision-critical anatomical evidence. Conclusion: Structuring surgical reasoning into expert-aligned verification checks improves both accuracy and transparency of LVLM-based CVS assessment, demonstrating that explicitly separating evidence elicitation from decision-making is critical for reliable and auditable surgical AI systems. Code is available at https://github.com/BrachioLab/SumOfChecks.
Mar 28, 2026

A Comparative Study in Surgical AI: Potential and Limitations of Data, Compute, and Scaling

Recent Artificial Intelligence (AI) models have matched or exceeded human experts in several benchmarks of biomedical task performance, but surgical benchmarks in particular are often missing from prominent medical benchmark suites. Since surgery requires integrating disparate tasks, generally-capable AI models could be particularly attractive as a collaborative tool if performance could be improved. On the one hand, the canonical approach of scaling architecture size and training data is attractive, especially since there are millions of hours of surgical video data generated per year. On the other hand, preparing surgical data for AI training requires significantly higher levels of professional expertise, and training on that data requires expensive computational resources. These trade-offs paint an uncertain picture of whether and to-what-extent modern AI could aid surgical practice. In this paper, we explore this question through a case study of surgical tool detection using state-of-the-art AI methods available in 2026. We demonstrate that even with multi-billion parameter models and extensive training, current Vision Language Models fall short in the seemingly simple task of tool detection in neurosurgery. Additionally, we show scaling experiments indicating that increasing model size and training time only leads to diminishing improvements in relevant performance metrics. Thus, our experiments suggest that current models could still face significant obstacles in surgical use cases. Moreover, some obstacles cannot be simply ``scaled away'' with additional compute and persist across diverse model architectures, raising the question of whether data and label availability are the only limiting factors. We discuss the main contributors to these constraints and advance potential solutions.