cs.SEFeb 23, 2026

When AI Teammates Meet Code Review: Collaboration Signals Shaping the Integration of Agent-Authored Pull Requests

Authors: Costain Nachuma, Minhaz Zibran

Organizations: Idaho State University, USA

Abstract

Autonomous coding agents increasingly contribute to software development by submitting pull requests on GitHub; yet, little is known about how these contributions integrate into human-driven review workflows. We present a large empirical study of agent-authored pull requests using the public AIDev dataset, examining integration outcomes, resolution speed, and review-time collaboration signals. Using logistic regression with repository-clustered standard errors, we find that reviewer engagement has the strongest correlation with successful integration, whereas larger change sizes and coordination-disrupting actions, such as force pushes, are associated with a lower likelihood of merging. In contrast, iteration intensity alone provides limited explanatory power once collaboration signals are considered. A qualitative analysis further shows that successful integration occurs when agents engage in actionable review loops that converge toward reviewer expectations. Overall, our results highlight that the effective integration of agent-authored pull requests depends not only on code quality but also on alignment with established review and coordination practices.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. How AI Coding Agents Communicate: A Study of Pull Request Description Characteristics and Human Review Responses

    Feb 19, 2026Kan Watanabe, Rikuto Tsuchida, Takahiro Monno +5AI Coding AgentsHuman-AI Collaboration

  2. 3100 Opinions on Code Review in an AI World: Building Causal Theory from Practitioner Discourse

    Jul 8, 2026Shyam Agarwal, Courtney Miller, Christian Kästner +1Software EngineeringCoding Agents

  3. Beyond Simpson's Paradox: A Cascade of Confounders in AI Agent Pull-Request Co-Authorship

    Jun 21, 2026Haoran Yu, Xiaochong Jiang, Lifei Liu +3Software EngineeringAI Coding Agents