Hybrid Framework for Robotic Manipulation: Integrating Reinforcement Learning and Large Language Models
Authors: Md Saad, Sajjad Hussain, Mohd Suhaib
Organizations: Department of Mechanical Engineering, Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, India · School of Architecture, Technology and Engineering, University of Brighton, Brighton, UK
This paper introduces a new hybrid framework that combines Reinforcement Learning (RL) and Large Language Models (LLMs) to improve robotic manipulation tasks. By utilizing RL for accurate low-level control and LLMs for high level task planning and understanding of natural language, the proposed framework effectively connects low-level execution with high-level reasoning in robotic systems. This integration allows robots to understand and carry out complex, human-like instructions while adapting to changing environments in real time. The framework is tested in a PyBullet-based simulation environment using the Franka Emika Panda robotic arm, with various manipulation scenarios as benchmarks. The results show a 33.5% decrease in task completion time and enhancements of 18.1% and 36.4% in accuracy and adaptability, respectively, when compared to systems that use only RL. These results underscore the potential of LLM-enhanced robotic systems for practical applications, making them more efficient, adaptable, and capable of interacting with humans. Future research will aim to explore sim-to-real transfer, scalability, and multi-robot systems to further broaden the framework's applicability.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1 : System Architecture: Integration of LLM and RL for Robotic Manipulation
Fig. 2 : Simulation Environment: Franka Emika Panda Robot in PyBullet
Fig. 3 : Hybrid Framework Integrating RL and LLMs
Fig. 4 : Task Completion Time Comparison
Fig. 5 : Accuracy and Adaptability Comparison
Fig. 6 : Task Completion Time Across Experiments
Fig. 7 : Learning Progress Over Episodes
Metric
RL Only
LLM + RL
Improvement (%)
Task Completion Time (s)
18.5
12.3
33.5
Accuracy (%)
78.4
92.6
18.1
Adaptability (%)
65.2
88.9
36.4
TABLE I : Performance Comparison of RL-Only and LLM+RL Systems
Multi-robot systems provide the parallelism and redundancy necessary for long-horizon tasks, while Large Language Models (LLMs) offer the reasoning capabilities to decompose these objectives into actionable plans. However, effectively grounding this high-level reasoning in physical multi-robot execution remains an open challenge. Existing LLM-based approaches fall mainly into two categories: Single-robot methods achieve robust contact-rich manipulation but lack the coordination mechanisms required for tasks spanning multiple workspaces. Current multi-robot frameworks focus on high-level planning, often treating manipulation as an idealized primitive that fails to account for real-world execution uncertainties. To address this, we propose a hierarchical closed-loop agentic LLM-based framework to ensure robust multi-robot manipulation. Our system consists of three specialized agents: the Planning Agent decomposes instructions into allocated sub-tasks, the Manipulation Agent for each robot executes actions via adaptive tool use, and the Verification Agent closes the loop by monitoring physical outcomes and feeding back semantic corrections. Extensive real-world experiments demonstrate that our framework achieves superior success rates, ensures robust adaptability ranging from single to cross workspace manipulation, and offers a generalizable approach for diverse manipulation tasks.
Yi-Xiang He, Lan Wei, Haoming Cen +6
Sun Yat-sen University · Key Laboratory of Machine Intelligence and Advanced Computing, Ministry of Education, China
Reinforcement Learning (RL) and Imitation Learning (IL) are the standard frameworks for policy acquisition in manipulation. While IL offers efficient policy derivation, it suffers from compounding errors and distribution shift. Conversely, RL facilitates autonomous exploration but is frequently hindered by low sample efficiency and the high cost of trial and error. Since existing hybrid methods often struggle with complex tasks, we introduce Mixture of RL and IL Experts (MoRI). This system dynamically switches between IL and RL experts based on the variance of expert actions to handle coarse movements and fine-grained manipulations. MoRI employs an offline pre-training stage followed by online fine-tuning to accelerate convergence. To maintain exploration safety and minimize human intervention, the system applies IL-based regularization to the RL component. Evaluation across four complex real-world tasks shows that MoRI achieves an average success rate of 97.5% within 2 to 5 hours of fine-tuning. Compared to baseline RL algorithms, MoRI reduces human intervention by 85.8% and shortens convergence time by 21%, demonstrating its capability in robotic manipulation.
Yaohang Xu, Lianjie Ma, Gewei Zuo +3
School of Artificial Intelligence and Automation, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China. · DRAGON Lab, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan. · School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Task planning for robotic manipulation with large language models (LLMs) is an emerging area. Prior approaches rely on specialized models, fine tuning, or prompt tuning, and often operate in an open loop manner without robust environmental feedback, making them fragile in dynamic settings. MALLVI presents a Multi Agent Large Language and Vision framework that enables closed-loop feedback driven robotic manipulation. Given a natural language instruction and an image of the environment, MALLVI generates executable atomic actions for a robot manipulator. After action execution, a Vision Language Model (VLM) evaluates environmental feedback and decides whether to repeat the process or proceed to the next step. Rather than using a single model, MALLVI coordinates specialized agents, Decomposer, Localizer, Thinker, and Reflector, to manage perception, localization, reasoning, and high level planning. An optional Descriptor agent provides visual memory of the initial state. The Reflector supports targeted error detection and recovery by reactivating only relevant agents, avoiding full replanning. Experiments in simulation and real-world settings show that iterative closed loop multi agent coordination improves generalization and increases success rates in zero shot manipulation tasks. Code available at https://github.com/iman1234ahmadi/MALLVI .
Mehrshad Taji, Arad Mahdinezhad Kashani, Iman Ahmadi +3
Department of Electrical Engineering Sharif University of Technology