Optimal Spatio-Temporal Decoupling for Bayesian Conformal Prediction
Authors: Yu-Hsueh Fang, Chia-Yen Lee
Organizations: Department of Information Management, National Taiwan University, No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Rd., Da’an Dist., Taipei, 106216, Taiwan.
Abstract
Online conformal prediction must balance fast adaptation to distribution shift against stable coverage: feedback-driven methods react quickly but become volatile, while strongly discounted Bayesian methods lag and inflate intervals at tight coverage. We introduce \textbf{State-Adaptive Bayesian Conformal Prediction (SA-BCP)}, which forms the predictive quantile as a gated convex combination of long-term temporal inertia and local spatial evidence from a kernel density estimate, controlled by a single interpretable evidence threshold K. We establish three results: (i) asymptotic marginal validity of the resulting intervals up to a gate-controlled bias that vanishes as spatial evidence accumulates (exact under recurrent states); (ii) a closed-form expression for the MSE-optimal threshold, KMSE∗=α(1−α)/MT, trading the coverage-indicator (Bernoulli) variance against the temporal structural bias MT; and (iii) a rolling-origin procedure for selecting K online -- consistent under stationarity, with O(TlogN) regret against the best fixed K and, for a segmented variant, a sublinear dynamic-regret bound under sublinearly many (BT=o(T)) threshold shifts. Across four financial-volatility and weather datasets, three target coverage levels, and eight baselines, SA-BCP attains at-or-above-nominal coverage in most settings while producing substantially sharper intervals -- up to roughly 3× lower Winkler score than discounted Bayesian CP at the tightest coverage -- and a coverage-matched audit confirms these efficiency gains are not an artifact of under-coverage. We disclose our principal limitation: a volatility-specialized CF-GARCH competitor remains more efficient on its home volatility-base series, though it does not transfer across domains.
This article considers an online version of conformal inference, called adaptive conformal inference [ACI] and introduced by Gibbs and Candès (2021): prediction sets are issued sequentially, after observing features and before the outcomes are revealed. These sets are evaluated both in terms of validity (the fraction of rounds where the outcome was lying in the prediction set) and efficiency (the average lengths of the prediction sets). The two criteria point to different directions (validity favors larger sets). We also target a wide range of scenarios, with exchangeable data and arbitrary data (lack of any stochastic guarantees) as two extremes. A series of existing strategies for ACI typically guarantee that empirical coverage converges to the desired level for arbitrary sequences, but they generally lack simultaneous efficiency guarantees. To provide a unified study, we first formulate ACI as a repeated two-player game with finite action sets and vector-valued payoffs encoding validity and efficiency. Building on this reformulation, we introduce a strategy based on Blackwell approachability and on its opportunistic extension by Bernstein et al. (2014) that ensures validity while adapting the efficiency of the prediction intervals to the underlying degree of stochasticity of the opponent player. The resulting guarantee is "best of many worlds": it recovers the relevant efficiency guarantees in exchangeable and adversarial settings, and provides guarantees in intermediate settings that arise in typical applications such as the forecasting of time series.
Conformal prediction is a framework that provides valid uncertainty quantification for general models with exchangeable data. However, in the online learning and time-series settings, exchangeability is not satisfied. Existing online conformal methods, such as adaptive conformal inference (ACI), can achieve long-run validity, yet they remain inefficient under covariate heterogeneity because they rely on global calibration. We propose \emph{Online Localized Conformal Prediction (OLCP)}, which combines online adaptation with covariate-dependent localization to better reflect heterogeneity. To reduce sensitivity to the localization bandwidth, we further develop \emph{OLCP-Hedge}, which performs bandwidth selection as an online expert aggregation problem using a constrained online convex optimization framework. Importantly, we provide coverage guarantees for both algorithms and demonstrate through simulations and real-data experiments that the proposed methods attain valid long-run coverage with narrower prediction sets than existing baselines.
Conformal prediction gives prediction intervals with finite-sample coverage when the data are exchangeable. Many time-indexed datasets are not exchangeable. They have seasons, recurring regimes, changing frequencies, or other forms of structured dependence. This paper studies a simple way to use that structure. We propose spectral adaptive conformal prediction, a method that forms weighted conformal quantiles using local spectral similarity and then updates the target miscoverage level online. The spectral weights choose calibration residuals that look relevant to the current test point. The adaptive update corrects the long-run miss rate when uncertainty changes over time. We give an approximate coverage result for the fixed spectral weighted quantile and a deterministic long-run calibration result for the adaptive update. Simulations with recurring regimes and slowly changing frequencies, together with three U.S. real-data examples, show that the hybrid method can improve on fixed spectral weighting, while also showing that spectral weighting must be monitored through effective sample size diagnostics.