Pairwise Approximation Can Select the Wrong Multi-Robot Plan
Authors: William Teo
Organizations: MARMoT Lab, Department of Mechanical Engineering, National University of Singapore · NEAR Lab, AI.Robotics Strategic Technology Centre, Singapore Technologies Engineering
Multi-robot coordination methods often score a joint plan from singleton and pairwise terms, leaving out the terms that involve three or more robots. We measure the plan-selection regret of two pairwise approximations to delivered coverage using frozen multi-robot trajectories. For each four-robot plan on an indoor exploration benchmark, replaying all 16 robot subsets gives the exact delivered-coverage set function F. From the same subset values we compute two pairwise scores: the exact order-2 Möbius truncation F2, which depends only on the singleton and pair values, and an equal-weight least-squares two-additive fit G. Ranking by F2 instead of F changes the selected plan on six of seven maps at the 15 m candidate-generation range in each of two candidate families, with regret up to 0.337 of map coverage. Switching to G reduces the regret but still changes the selection on three of seven maps in each family. The additive score F1, which keeps only the singleton terms, selects the exact winner on six of seven maps in one family and four of seven in the other, against one of seven for F2. We also find that lower average reconstruction error does not guarantee lower selection regret.
Figures & tables
Nearest-frontier
Random-frontier
Map
F1
F2
G
Rand.
F1
F2
G
Rand.
env1
0
33.7
7.1
24.9
15.6
0
0
23.7
env2
0
0.3
0.3
7.3
1.3
18.1
0
12.4
env3
36.6
0
0
25.8
0
3.5
3.5
10.1
env4
0
13.3
0
23.3
0
6.4
6.4
14.0
env5
0
24.0
0
22.3
3.5
2.5
0
8.7
TABLE I: Selection regret at the 15 m generation range as % of map coverage, for the additive score F1 , the two pairwise scores, and a uniformly random pick from the eight candidates (expected regret).
Real-world robots often operate in settings where objective priorities depend on the underlying context of operation. When the underlying context is unknown apriori, multiple robots may have to coordinate to gather informative observations to infer the context, since acting based on an incorrect context can lead to misaligned and unsafe behavior. Once the underlying true context is inferred, the robots optimize their task-specific objectives in the preference order induced by the context. We formalize this problem as a Multi-Robot Context-Uncertain Stochastic Shortest Path (MR-CUSSP), which captures context-relevant information at landmark states through joint observations. Our two-stage solution approach is composed of: (1) CIMOP (Coordinated Inference for Multi-Objective Planning) to compute plans that guide robots toward informative landmarks to efficiently infer the true context, and (2) LCBS (Lexicographic Conflict-Based Search) for collision-free multi-robot path planning with lexicographic objective preferences, induced by the context. We evaluate the algorithms using three simulated domains and demonstrate its practical applicability using five mobile robots in the salp domain setup.
Collaborative Robotics and Intelligent Systems (CoRIS) Institute, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR 97331, USA · Khoury College of Computer Sciences, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115, USA
This report presents the \textbf{OpenSpace Lab}'s solution to the Competition on Intelligent Information Gathering for Single and Multi-Robot Systems Workshops, organized as part of the IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS) 2026. Our team reached 1st place in the Single-Robot Public Track and 3rd place in both the Single- and Multi-Robot Private Tracks. The single-robot framework utilizes pre-trained map completion predictions for global planning to prioritize unexplored areas. To reconcile map coverage with limited operation time, we introduce a remaining-time-based exploration strategy that integrates homing constraints into the decision-making process. For multi-robot exploration, we utilize a utility-driven target selection strategy that balances observation gains, movement costs, and budget constraints, leveraging shared map and intent data to eliminate redundant search and maximize coordination efficiency. Our solution reached a 61.04% coverage rate in the Single-Robot Public Track, while reaching 39.53% and 39.91% coverage in the Single- and Multi-Robot Private Tracks, respectively. An extended full-length paper based on this report is currently being prepared for submission, and the source code will be released upon acceptance of the full manuscript at https://github.com/OpenSpace-Lab/Indoor-Exploration-IROS2026.
Yuxuan Zhang, Dong Li, Zezhou Sun +5
China University of Mining and Technology-Beijing · Macau University of Science and Technology · Institute of Automation, Chinese Academy of Sciences +3
Multi-robot control in cluttered environments is a challenging problem that involves complex physical constraints, including robot-robot collisions, robot-obstacle collisions, and unreachable motions. Successful planning in such settings requires joint optimization over high-level task planning and low-level motion planning, as violations of physical constraints may arise from failures at either level. However, jointly optimizing task and motion planning is difficult due to the complex parameterization of low-level motion trajectories and the ambiguity of credit assignment across the two planning levels. In this paper, we propose a hybrid multi-robot control framework that jointly optimizes task and motion planning. To enable effective parameterization of low-level planning, we introduce waypoints, a simple yet expressive representation for motion trajectories. To address the credit assignment challenge, we adopt a curriculum-based training strategy with a modified RLVR algorithm that propagates motion feasibility feedback from the motion planner to the task planner. Experiments on BoxNet3D-OBS, a challenging multi-robot benchmark with dense obstacles and up to nine robots, show that our approach consistently improves task success over motion-agnostic and VLA-based baselines. Our code is available at https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/navigate-cluster
Jiabao Ji, Yongchao Chen, Yang Zhang +4
UC Santa Barbara · Massachusetts Institute of Technology · Harvard University +2