"I don't know what I don't know": Exploring the Benefits and Challenges of AI in Interdisciplinary Research
Organizations: Siebel School for Computing and Data Science, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Champaign, Illinois, USA
Abstract
Interdisciplinary research is widely lauded as beneficial for society but presents unique challenges to the researchers who bridge disciplinary boundaries. Despite the rapid increase in the availability and usage of AI systems for research tasks, there is little work studying how AI systems have impacted workflows that span unfamiliar disciplines. Through a survey () and follow-up interviews () with interdisciplinary researchers, we describe the unique challenges and opportunities for AI in interdisciplinary research workflows. Participants viewed AI both as a solution and exacerbation of the general challenge of "unknown unknowns": AI systems could facilitate a broad awareness of a new research area, yet also provide an illusion of understanding. Crucially, participants lacked the expertise and intuition to catch these illusions. Our findings motivate a focus on designing AI systems to support rather than automate collaboration across disciplines, scaffold learning opportunities, and include avenues for triangulation between resources.
Figures & tables
| Category | Experiences |
| Navigating Information | Unfamiliar terminology or jargon ( Agapie et al., 2022 ; Guo et al., 2024 ; Palmer, 1999 ; Spanner, 2001 ; Newby, 2011 ; Foster, 2004 ; Lee and Paine, 2015 ; Qin et al., 1997 ) Deciding what to ask or search for ( Zheng et al., 2024 ; Foster, 2004 ; Palmer and Fenlon, 2017 ; Palmer, 1999 ; Klein, 1991 ; Qin et al., 1997 ; Kim et al., 2025 ) |
| Assessing Information | Considering a work’s context in its field ( Cao et al., 2025 ; Guo et al., 2024 ; Qin et al., 1997 ) Deciding when you have sufficient information ( Foster, 2004 ; Zheng et al., 2024 ) Recognizing when information is valuable ( Kim et al., 2025 ; Foster, 2004 ) |
| Connecting Across Boundaries | Communication with collaborators ( Wan et al., 2026 ; Palmer, 1999 ; Cao et al., 2025 ; Agapie et al., 2022 ; Palmer, 2001 ; Lee and Paine, 2015 ; Qin et al., 1997 ) Different methodological expectations ( Cao et al., 2025 ; Wan et al., 2026 ; Palmer, 2001 ; Colusso et al., 2019 ; Agapie et al., 2022 ; Cibrian et al., 2022 ; Mitchell and Mamykina, 2021 ; Klein, 2008 ) Different expectations surrounding analysis and evidence ( Palmer, 1999 ; Wan et al., 2026 ; Agapie et al., 2022 ; Klein, 2008 ) Different writing styles ( Bhatt et al., 2025 ; Palmer, 1999 ) |
| Section | RQ | Findings |
| Section 5.2 | RQ1: Interdisciplinary challenges | Searching for information in new disciplines. Aligning expectations when working across disciplines. Managing communication between communities. |
| Section 5.3 | RQ2: Usage and benefits of AI | Search engine with flexible queries. Translator between disciplines. In-discipline reviewer for preliminary feedback. Software development assistant. |
| Section 5.4 | RQ3: Challenges of AI | AI can cause an illusion of understanding when in unfamiliar disciplines. AI lacks the taste in research that comes with experience in a discipline. AI can reduce respect for disciplinary boundaries. |
Appendix figures & tables4 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Participant | Occupation | Discipline (Years of Experience) |
| P1 | Research Assistant | Computer Science (Programming) (12) Literary Studies / Critical Theory (5) Writing Studies (2) Ethnomethodology / Conversation Analysis / Linguistic Anthropology (2) Human-Computer Interaction (4) |
| P2 | PhD student, 6th year | Human-Computer Interaction (7) Law (3) |
| P3 | PhD student, 4th year | Computer Science (14) Learning Sciences (3) |
| P4 | PhD student, 3rd year | Human-Computer Interaction (4) |
| P5 | Postdoc Researcher | Scientific Software (7) Material Science (Polymer) (5) Biophysics (2) |
| P6 | PhD student, 2nd year | Computer Science (7) Health (2) |
| Mentions | Discipline | Avg. Years |
| Computer Science | ||
| Human-Computer Interaction | ||
| Artificial Intelligence / Machine Learning | ||
| Education | ||
| Chemistry | ||
| Materials Science |
| Mentions | Discipline | Avg. Years |
| Art History | ||
| Game Studies | ||
| Architectural Engineering | ||
| Game Technologies | ||
| Quantitative Biology | ||
| Geology |
AI-Assisted Scientific Research
AI-assisted scientific research uses machine learning and AI agents to support discovery, analysis, experimentation, and scientific communication.
See all 266 papers