Price co-movement and price information diverge across Nordic electricity zones after the energy crisis
Organizations: Department of Computer Science, UiT The Arctic University of Norway, P.O. Box 6050 Langnes, 9037 Tromsø, Norway · Department of Mathematics, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1053 Blindern, 0316 Oslo, Norway · Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1078 Blindern, 0316 Oslo, Norway
Abstract
After the 2021-2022 energy crisis, day-ahead prices in Nordic bidding zones no longer move together. We ask whether this divergence also changes the information carried by prices. The answer matters for integrating variable renewable energy (VRE), because it can help identify where wind and solar forecasts are worth producing, publishing, and using. We measured the co-movement of each Norwegian and Swedish zone with Germany-Luxembourg (DE-LU) in 2018-2025. We then used a single model, selected on 2024 data, to forecast 2025 prices at 11:00 on the previous day and tested which inputs improved accuracy in each zone. The zones moved alike until 2019, but co-movement diverged in Sweden in 2020 and in Norway in 2021, and the split has persisted. In 2024, four southern zones co-moved strongly with DE-LU (intraday correlations of 0.54-0.71), while four northern zones co-moved weakly (0.25-0.30). Yet price information did not follow this split. Previous-day neighbouring prices reduced mean absolute error by at most 2.2% in any zone, equally in coupled and isolated zones. Removing the transmission system operators' wind and solar forecasts increased mean absolute error by at most 6% in Norway, 8-16% in Sweden, and 31% in DE-LU, and the ordering held in 2024. Within Norway, the value of these forecasts showed no detectable dependence on reservoir filling. The divergence in co-movement was therefore not matched by a divergence in price information, which differed mainly between national generation systems. Thus, a zone's coupling to the continent does not indicate the value of VRE forecasts there.
Figures & tables
| Group | Variables | Values used for D | Models |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prices | Day-ahead price of the zone | All 24 hours of D-1, D-2, D-3 and D-7; and for H and P | L, H, P |
| Load | TSO load forecast | Each hour of D, and of D-1 and D-7 for L and H | L, H, P |
| Wind and solar | TSO forecasts of onshore wind and solar generation, and their total | Each hour of D, and of D-1 and D-7 for L and H | L, H, P |
| Weather | 20 variables, including temperature, wind, radiation, precipitation and snow | Observation at 10:00 on D-1 and mean temperature from 00:00 to 10:00 on D-1 | P |
| Reservoir | Stored energy and its change over one and four weeks (Norway and Sweden) | Latest weekly value complete at 11:00 on D-1 | P |
| Commodities | TTF gas, EUA carbon (EUR/t), API2 coal (EUR/t), Brent oil, Henry Hub gas, EUR/NOK and derived features | Close of D-2 | P |
Electricity Price Forecasting
Electricity price forecasting predicts wholesale and retail prices to support trading, grid operations, and energy planning.
See all 24 papers