Equilibrium Propagation

Ask about this topic

Momentum

0 papers in the last four weeks, with none the four weeks before. 0.0% of all new papers.

Jul 13Week of Sep 28
View on map

Latest papers 13

All topics
CardsList
Oct 5, 2026cs.LG

Lock-in EP: An In-Situ Training Algorithm for Oscillatory Hardware

Analog hardware platforms offer the potential to reduce energy consumption over digital architectures, but in order to succeed, large-scale analog systems must also be able to operate with or recover from the variability of their components. Towards this goal, we derive and demonstrate the lock-in equilibrium propagation (LIEP) training method. LIEP provides local gradient information for each component in an oscillatory network without separate forward and backward sweeps, potentially allowing for in-situ learning capabilities on analog oscillatory hardware platforms. We demonstrate that LIEP can be used both for ab-initio training as well as recovering performance when pre-trained parameters are perturbed. We show that LIEP can be formulated as a three-factor update rule, and suggest that although the method is currently only validated on shallow networks, alternate architectures may allow it to extend to deep and large-scale networks addressing complex tasks.

Sowjanya Tammali, Wilkie Olin-Ammentorp

Computer Science, Missouri University of Science and Technology, 500 West 15th Street, Rolla, 65409, MO, USA. · Mathematics & Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory, 9700 S. Cass Avenue, Lemont, 60439, IL, USA.

Equilibrium PropagationOn-Device TrainingOscillatory Neural Networks
AskPDF
Jul 30, 2026cond-mat.soft

Conservation laws determine what physical learning remembers

Physical learning rules such as equilibrium propagation (EP), coupled learning (CL), and adjoint coupled learning (AL) train resistive networks through local measurements. In the small-nudge limit EP and CL exactly conserve the conductance mass K = (1/2) sum_e kappa_e^2, a property that stabilizes training. We show that conservation also governs the inductive bias of these rules. For a single output we prove that EP and CL are trajectory equivalent, so single-output experiments cannot distinguish what the two rules learn. We prove that AL does not conserve the mass but dissipates it at exactly twice its own loss. In linear circuits we prove that the conserved mass has no functional consequence: all three vector fields are homogeneous in the conductances, so the selected solution is independent of the initialization scale. Fixed nonlinear elements break this protection. In diode circuits the learned input-output function depends on the initialization scale by up to about forty percent, an effect absent in linear controls, and the conservative rules retain this memory permanently while the dissipative rule partially erases it. At matched training loss the dissipative rule typically generalizes worse than the conservative rules, although it reaches low training loss faster; the penalty correlates with the mass dissipated en route and fades in larger circuits, where little mass is lost. The conservation structure of a local learning rule thus sets its initialization memory, its training speed, and, where dissipation is appreciable, its generalization; it should be treated as a design parameter of physical learning machines.

Bijaya Dangol

1Independent researcher

Equilibrium PropagationNeural Network Training DynamicsLocal Learning
AskPDF
Jun 13, 2026math.OC

A Conservation Law for Equilibrium Propagation and Coupled Learning

In this paper we show that the physical learning methods known as coupled learning (CL) and equilibrium propagation (EP) conserve a mass-like quantity in the trainable parameters in the continuous-time, small-nudging limit. We prove that this conservation holds in a broad range of physically relevant settings. We then show that the conservation law constrains the training dynamics in a way that makes convergence reliable in important settings for linear circuits. We conclude by discussing some practical implications of this conservation law.

Joshua A. McGinnis, Adam G. Kline, Yoichiro Mori

Department of Mathematics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA · Department of Physics & Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA · Department of Biology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA

Equilibrium PropagationNeural Network Training Dynamics
AskPDF
Jun 13, 2026math.OC

Coercivity and Local Convergence of Physical Learning in Linear Circuits

Physical learning methods train physical networks to perform computational tasks using only local update rules, exploiting the physics of the system to handle the global transfer of information. We provide the first local convergence analysis of three such methods -- Equilibrium Propagation (EP), Coupled Learning (CL), and a new method we call Adjoint Coupled Learning (AL) -- for linear circuits, in the limit of small-nudging for both discrete and continuous time. EP and AL perform gradient descent on a natural loss function, while CL follows modified dynamics with an additional cubic correction. Assuming the existence of a solution, we identify a coercivity condition, expressed as a rank condition on a matrix built from the network's incidence structure, under which the training loss decays exponentially and the parameters converge to the solution manifold. We show that coercivity can fail by exhibiting a kite circuit in which a symmetry causes the coercivity constant to degenerate on the solution manifold, but prove using Sard's theorem that such degeneracies are non-generic: coercivity holds at every point of the solution manifold for almost every choice of desired output.

Joshua A. McGinnis, Xinbo Li, Yoichiro Mori

Department of Mathematics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.

Equilibrium PropagationOptimization Convergence AnalysisLocal Learning
AskPDF
Jun 11, 2026physics.optics

Optical Implementation of Equilibrium Propagation Using Spatial Photonic Ising Machines

Equilibrium Propagation offers a compelling alternative to traditional machine learning for training energy-based networks. Here we demonstrate a hybrid optical-digital implementation of EP using a Spatial Photonic Ising Machine (SPIM). The SPIM exploits the gauge transformation method to optically encode both continuous neuron states and rank-1 binary trainable patterns as phase modulations via a spatial light modulator, with inference realized using a finite difference scheme. The experimental system is evaluated on the Wine classification dataset. The potential of this approach, including the use of continuous couplings and structured coupling matrices, is evaluated numerically on the more complex MNIST dataset. Our work provides a concrete pathway toward energy-efficient physical implementations of Equilibrium Propagation.

Dimitri Vanden Abeele, Daniele Veraldi, Davide Pierangeli +2

Laboratoire d’Information Quantique C.P. 224, Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium · Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Rome, Italy

Equilibrium PropagationEnergy-Efficient MLPhotonic Computing
AskPDF
Jun 8, 2026cs.LG

Perturbative Contrastive Physical Learning

Responses to perturbations are key to understanding physical systems. The ability to contrast such responses by comparing how a system reacts under slightly different conditions provides a mechanism for learning. Here, we introduce Perturbative Contrastive Physical Learning (PCPL), a general framework in which learning emerges from measurable contrasts between physical states produced by controlled changes to inputs, boundary conditions, parameters, or interpreter functions. PCPL unifies and extends prior approaches: Equilibrium Propagation is rooted in contrasts between free and nudged equilibria in energy-based systems, while Frequency Propagation corresponds to contrasts extracted from sinusoidally driven, frequency-demodulated responses. We show that contrast-driven updates can reflect either local sensitivities or global inverse-problem structure, yet do not require centralized gradient computation. Instead, effective learning geometry emerges implicitly from the system's own physical response, allowing learning behavior to arise without an external processor or explicit backpropagation. We demonstrate PCPL in two platforms: (i) spring networks that update bond stiffness using measured displacements and forces, and (ii) continuous-variable photonic circuits trained via x quadrature measurements and finite-difference estimates of the Jacobian. Both platforms successfully learn classification tasks. We further show that a continuous-variable photonic circuit can be trained to implement analog multiplication, illustrating a step toward more autonomous physical learning systems.

Kyungeun Kim, Amanuel Anteneh, Israel Klich +2

Department of Mathematics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC Canada · Department of Physics, University of Virginia, 382 McCormick Rd, Charlottesville, VA 22903, USA · Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems, 01187 Dresden, Germany +2

Equilibrium PropagationContrastive Learning
AskPDF
Jun 8, 2026cs.LG

Optimizing Energy-based Neural Network Training with Coherent Ising Machine

While Ising machines serve as advanced physical solvers for the Ising model,enabling applications in combinatorial optimization and neural network training,their scalability for large-scale neural networks remains constrained by hardware connectivity limitations and suboptimal training methodologies. In this work,we leverage a Coherent Ising Machine (CIM) to train an energy-based neural network using Equilibrium Propagation, achieving performance comparable to existing software-based implementations. We further enhance the algorithm by integrating the Adam optimizer to solve for the ground state of a Hopfield energy network, significantly improving convergence speed and solution accuracy. Additionally, we demonstrate the scalability of our approach across deeper network architectures and convolutional operations. Our results highlight the potential of CIM dynamics as a scalable platform for training complex neural networks, offering a pathway toward energy-efficient implementations via analog circuits, optoelectronics, or integrated photonics. This work establishes a novel physical framework for next-generation AI hardware development.

Chen-Rui Fan, Bo Lu, Zhi-Hong Zhang +3

School of Artificial Intelligence, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, 100875, China. · Laboratory for Advanced Computing and Intelligence Engineering, Information Engineering University, Zhengzhou, 450001, China. · China Mobile (Suzhou) Software Technology Company Limited, Suzhou, 215163, China.

Equilibrium PropagationNeural Network OptimizationHopfield NetworksEnergy-Based Models
AskPDF
Jun 8, 2026cs.LG

Hybridizing Equilibrium Propagation with Ising Machines for Efficient Energy-Based Learning

The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence has led to substantial advances in deep neural networks. Nonetheless, conventional GPU-based training remains highly energy-demanding, motivating the exploration of physical dynamics and compatible energy-based learning schemes, such as equilibrium propagation (EP). EP-based training, however, frequently suffers from convergence to local minima due to phase-space contraction. Here we introduce an Ising-dynamics-inspired equilibrium-propagation framework in which dissipative Hopfield relaxation is replaced by an extended phase-space dynamics with conjugate variables. The resulting training paradigm keeps the local two-phase learning rule of EP while changing the physical route by which neural states reach equilibrium. We show that this dynamics lowers effective energy barriers, accelerates convergence, improves noise robustness, and trains deep convolutional Hopfield networks on MNIST, FashionMNIST, and CIFAR-10 with performance comparable to backpropagation.

Chen-Rui Fan, Bo Lu, Xing-Yu Wu +2

School of Artificial Intelligence, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China · Laboratory for Advanced Computing and Intelligence Engineering, Information Engineering University, Zhengzhou 450001, China · School of Physical Science and Technology, Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications, Beijing 100876, China

Equilibrium PropagationHopfield NetworksEnergy-Based ModelsNeural Network Training Dynamics
AskPDF
Jun 2, 2026cs.LG

Training a Predictive Coding Network on ImageNet using Equilibrium Propagation

Equilibrium Propagation (EP) is a physics-based training framework that has primarily been employed in energy-based models, including continuous Hopfield networks, nonlinear resistive networks and coupled phase oscillators. However, EP's practical applications have so far remained limited to relatively small-scale problems. Predictive coding networks (PCNs), another class of energy-based models rooted in computational neuroscience, are typically trained with a specialized algorithm and have likewise not yet been demonstrated at large scale. In this work, we develop an EP-based training method for PCNs which combines the centered variant of EP with a novel equilibration scheme for PCNs. Using this approach, we train a 10-layer convolutional PCN (VGG10) on full-size ImageNet, achieving 13.23% test error rate on the top-5 classification task, close to the 12.2% backpropagation baseline. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of both PCNs and EP-based training at ImageNet scale. These results significantly extend the scalability of both approaches and suggest that the primary challenges in scaling EP in other physical systems may come more from the computational properties of these systems than from inherent limitations of the EP framework.

Tugdual Kerjan, Rasmus Høier, Benjamin Scellier

Rain AI

Equilibrium PropagationPredictive CodingEnergy-Based ModelsConvolutional Neural NetworksImage Classification
AskPDF
May 20, 2026cs.LG

Equilibrium Propagation and Hamiltonian Inference in the Diffusive Fitzhugh-Nagumo Model

In this work, we extend the Equilibrium Propagation framework to skew-gradient systems and show an equivalence between deep Energy-Based Models and Hamiltonian neural networks. We focus on networks of diffusively coupled Fitzhugh-Nagumo neurons as a prototypical example. We show that since stationary solutions of the Fitzhugh-Nagumo model are described by self-adjoint operators, the methods of equilibrium propagation for performing credit assignment can be applied. Furthermore, for Fitzhugh-Nagumo networks with the topology of a deep residual network, we show that the steady state solutions admit a (spatial) Hamiltonian, and thus the methods of Hamiltonian Echo Backpropagation can be applied. We end by deriving an explicit layer-wise Hamiltonian recurrence relation governing inference for stationary solutions of both deep Fitzhugh-Nagumo networks and deep Energy-Based Models.

Jack Kendall

Zyphra · San Francisco, CA

Equilibrium PropagationDynamical SystemsHamiltonian Neural NetworksEnergy-Based Models
AskPDF
May 10, 2026cs.NE

Neuromorphic Reinforcement Learning for Quadruped Locomotion Control on Uneven Terrain

Reinforcement learning (RL) has enabled robust quadruped locomotion over complex terrain, but most learned controllers are trained offline with backpropagation in massively parallel simulation and deployed as fixed policies, limiting adaptation to terrain variation, payload changes, actuator wear, and other real-world conditions under onboard power constraints. Local learning provides a potential path toward energy-aware on-robot adaptation by replacing global backpropagation graphs with updates driven by local neural states, making the learning rule more compatible with neuromorphic and in-memory computing substrates. This work proposes an equilibrium-propagation (EP)-based proximal policy optimization (PPO) framework for uneven-terrain quadruped locomotion. The controller combines a bio-inspired central pattern generator (CPG) policy with a residual postural adjustment policy, while replacing conventional backpropagation-trained policy and value networks with EP-enabled local learning. To train stochastic continuous-control policies with EP, we derive an EP-compatible PPO output-nudging signal and introduce a two-sided ratio clipping mechanism that stabilizes policy updates during relaxation. Experiments on a 12-DoF A1 quadruped show that the proposed controller achieves stable policy convergence in a two-stage uneven terrain locomotion task. Its locomotion performance is comparable to a backpropagation-trained PPO baseline in success rate, velocity tracking, actuator power, and body stability, while improving GPU memory efficiency by 4.3×\times compared with backpropagation through time (BPTT). These results suggest that local equilibrium-based learning can support high-dimensional embodied locomotion and provide an algorithmic foundation for low-power on-robot adaptation and fine-tuning.

Zhuangyu Han, Abhronil Sengupta

School of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Penn State University University Park, PA 16802

Equilibrium PropagationTerrain-Aware Robot LocomotionRobot LocomotionProximal Policy OptimizationPolicy LearningQuadruped Locomotion
AskPDF
May 1, 2026cs.LG

Dendritic Neural Networks with Equilibrium Propagation

Equilibrium propagation (EP) is a biologically plausible alternative to backpropagation (BP), but its effectiveness can degrade in deeper and more challenging learning settings. In parallel, dendritic neural networks have demonstrated improved performance and generalization when trained with BP, suggesting that structured, biologically inspired architectures may enhance learning. In this work, we investigate the integration of dendritic neural networks with equilibrium propagation using an advanced EP framework. We evaluate the proposed dendritic EP model on MNIST, Kuzushiji-MNIST (KMNIST), and Fashion-MNIST (FMNIST), considering both shallow and deeper architectures. Our results show that dendritic EP achieves performance comparable to standard EP on simple tasks, while providing consistent improvements on more challenging datasets and deeper models. In particular, dendritic EP significantly outperforms standard EP on KMNIST and FMNIST, and approaches the performance of dendritic networks trained with backpropagation through time.To further understand these improvements, we analyze the evolution of hidden states during the free phase. We observe that dendritic EP exhibits higher activation magnitudes and more distributed hidden-state activity compared to standard EP, indicating that dendritic structure alters the internal network dynamics. These findings suggest that incorporating dendritic structure can enhance the effectiveness of biologically plausible learning algorithms, especially in regimes where standard EP struggles. Our work highlights the importance of architectural design for improving biologically inspired training methods.

Yoshimasa Kubo

Department of Computer Science Lakehead University Thunder Bay, Canada

Equilibrium PropagationNeural Network Training Dynamics
AskPDF
Apr 26, 2026cs.LG

Symmetric Equilibrium Propagation for Thermodynamic Diffusion Training

The reverse process in score-based diffusion models is formally equivalent to overdamped Langevin dynamics in a time-dependent energy landscape. In our prior work we showed that a bilinearly-coupled analog substrate can physically realize this dynamics at a projected three-to-four orders of magnitude energy advantage over digital inference by replacing dense skip connections with low-rank inter-module couplings. Whether the \emph{training} loop can be closed on the same substrate -- without routing gradients through an external digital accelerator -- has remained open. We resolve this affirmatively: Equilibrium Propagation applied directly to the bilinear energy yields an unbiased estimator of the denoising score-matching gradient in the zero-nudge limit. For finite nudging we derive a sharp bias bound controlled solely by substrate stiffness, local curvature, and the norm of the loss-gradient signal, with a bilinear-specific corollary showing that one dominant bias term vanishes identically for coupling-parameter updates. Symmetric nudging further upgrades the leading bias from O(β)\mathcal{O}(β) to O(β2)\mathcal{O}(β^2) at negligible extra cost. Under realistic finite-relaxation budgets this upgrade is essential, as one-sided EqProp produces anti-correlated gradients while symmetric EqProp yields well-aligned updates. Bias-variance analysis determines the optimal operating point, and end-to-end physical-unit accounting projects a 103 10^3-104×10^4\times energy advantage per training step over a matched GPU baseline. Symmetric bilinear EqProp is the first local, readout-only training rule that preserves the low-rank coupling enabling scalable thermodynamic diffusion models.

Aditi De

Equilibrium PropagationThermodynamic ComputingScore-Based Generative ModelingDiffusion Models
AskPDF