Social Bias in Language Models

Overview

This topic studies how language models reflect or produce social disparities tied to traits such as gender, race, disability, religion, class, and language variety, in both text generation and consequential tasks. Researchers use counterfactual prompts, stereotype and decision-making benchmarks, human and community judgments, and audits across languages, dialects, modalities, and multi-turn interactions. Mitigation approaches include data augmentation and fine-tuning, prompting and retrieval, decoding-time controls, and interventions on model weights or internal representations. A central challenge is that measured bias changes with the task and context, while interventions can reduce visible disparities without removing underlying associations or can shift harms and degrade useful capabilities.

Latest papers

217 papers20 papers in the last four weeks, level with the four weeks before. 0.2% of all new papers.

Jan 9, 2025

FairCoder: Probing LLM Bias in High-Stakes Decision Making via Coding Tasks

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used in high-stakes decisions such as hiring and college admissions, making their social bias a critical concern. While LLMs are trained to refuse explicitly biased requests, bias can be leaked implicitly during LLM planning and reasoning process. As code becomes the primary medium for LLM internal logic-writing, we introduce FairCoder, a benchmark that frames decision-making as coding tasks to systematically probe LLM bias across employment, education, and healthcare domains, covering multiple fairness definitions. Considering that existing metrics may fail when LLMs frequently refuse the request, we propose FairScore, a metric that jointly captures refusal behavior and group-level outcome diversity. Experiments with a 1k-sample dataset on powerful LLMs reveal consistent and previously underexplored bias patterns, such as prioritizing applicants from high-income families in college admissions. Our findings highlight the risks of deploying LLMs as decision-making agents and provide a comprehensive evaluation framework for future research.
Jan 4, 2025

Homogeneity Bias in Open-Weight LLMs Is Robust to Decoding Hyperparameters

Large language models (LLMs) reproduce homogeneity bias -- the tendency to portray marginalized groups as more internally similar than dominant groups -- but whether this bias is stable or an artifact of inference settings has only been studied in single proprietary models. We map homogeneity bias across a 5x5 temperature-by-top-p grid in seven open-weight instruction-tuned LLMs (7-20B parameters). Hispanic and Asian Americans are portrayed as more homogeneous than White Americans in at least 18 of 20 hyperparameter configurations across six of seven models, including at extreme sampling settings. African American and gender bias show model-specific variation in direction. A conservative cell-level re-analysis confirms Hispanic and Asian homogeneity as robust, while weaker African American and gender signals largely do not survive, establishing group-specific robustness. We also apply the same grid to a names-based paradigm in which group identity is signaled via racially distinctive surnames rather than explicit labels. The names paradigm corroborates Hispanic and Asian homogeneity bias, but Black-coded surnames elicit robustly less homogeneous outputs than White-coded names in every model tested -- a reversal absent from the label paradigm -- showing that how group identity is operationalized shapes which biases surface and in which direction.
Aug 20, 2024

BTBR: A Bayesian-Theory-Driven Probabilistic-Fuzzy Framework for Implicit Bias Removal in Large Language Models

Large language models (LLMs) may encode biased associations from heterogeneous training corpora that are not immediately visible under ordinary prompting, but can surface when the model is steered toward particular demographic personas. Such behavior often manifests not as explicit toxic output, but as systematic performance differences across semantically equivalent tasks, making the resulting bias difficult to detect and mitigate. To address this issue, we formalize the implicit bias problem as persona-induced performance disparity and argue that bias evidence should be treated as a graded signal rather than a binary label. Motivated by this observation, we model biased knowledge as a fuzzy subset equipped with an explicit membership function that reflects the strength of bias evidence for each candidate example. Building on this formulation, we propose Bayesian-Theory-based Bias Removal (BTBR), a hybrid probabilistic-fuzzy framework for identifying and removing latent bias traces from model parameters. BTBR first performs likelihood-ratio screening to measure how strongly candidate samples align with a target biased persona, then converts high-membership samples into structured knowledge triples, and finally applies targeted model editing with a lightweight fuzzy rule scheduler to reduce collateral performance degradation under high entanglement risk. Extensive experiments across multiple bias sources, tasks, model families and editing backends show that BTBR consistently reduces persona-induced performance gaps while preserving general reasoning ability. These results demonstrate that combining probabilistic evidence with fuzzy degree modeling provides an effective and practical approach for mitigating implicit bias in large language models.
Aug 8, 2024

BA-LoRA: Bias-Alleviating Low-Rank Adaptation to Mitigate Catastrophic Inheritance in Large Language Models

Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) has become a de facto standard for adapting large language models (LLMs). However, we identify a critical vulnerability within popular low-rank adaptation methods such as LoRA: they can exacerbate "Catastrophic Inheritance" - the unchecked propagation of biases, noise, and data imbalances from pre-training. This phenomenon can degrade model robustness and fairness, undermining the benefits of efficient adaptation. To address this, we introduce Bias-Alleviating Low-Rank Adaptation (BA-LoRA). Our approach is founded on a principled decomposition of Catastrophic Inheritance into three core challenges: Knowledge Drift, Representation Collapse, and Overfitting to Noise. BA-LoRA systematically mitigates these issues by incorporating a trio of targeted regularizers: consistency, diversity, and an SVD-based term, designed to preserve core knowledge, promote representational richness, and encourage robust, low-rank output representations, respectively. We conduct comprehensive evaluations on a suite of Natural Language Generation (NLG) and Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks using diverse, prominent open-source language models (e.g., LLaMA-2-7B and DeBERTa-v3-base). Our results show that BA-LoRA not only outperforms state-of-the-art LoRA variants in terms of performance and stability, but also demonstrates superior robustness and bias mitigation on targeted evaluations. These results provide evidence that BA-LoRA can counteract the adverse effects of Catastrophic Inheritance.
Jul 26, 2024

Fairness Definitions in Language Models Explained

Language Models (LMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance across various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Despite these advancements, LMs can inherit and amplify societal biases related to sensitive attributes such as gender and race, limiting their adoption in real-world applications. Therefore, fairness has been extensively explored in LMs, leading to the proposal of various fairness notions. However, the lack of clear agreement on which fairness definition to apply in specific contexts and the complexity of understanding the distinctions between these definitions can create confusion and impede further progress. To this end, this paper proposes a systematic survey that clarifies the definitions of fairness as they apply to LMs. Specifically, we begin with a brief introduction to LMs and fairness in LMs, followed by a comprehensive, up-to-date overview of existing fairness notions in LMs and the introduction of a novel taxonomy that categorizes these concepts based on their transformer architecture: encoder-only, decoder-only, and encoder-decoder LMs. We further illustrate each definition through experiments, showcasing their practical implications and outcomes. Finally, we discuss current research challenges and open questions, aiming to foster innovative ideas and advance the field. The repository is publicly available online at https://github.com/vanbanTruong/Fairness-in-Large-Language-Models/tree/main/definitions.
Jun 11, 2024

MBBQ: A Dataset for Cross-Lingual Comparison of Stereotypes in Generative LLMs

Generative large language models (LLMs) have been shown to exhibit harmful biases and stereotypes. While safety fine-tuning typically takes place in English, if at all, these models are being used by speakers of many different languages. There is existing evidence that the performance of these models is inconsistent across languages and that they discriminate based on demographic factors of the user. Motivated by this, we investigate whether the social stereotypes exhibited by LLMs differ as a function of the language used to prompt them, while controlling for cultural differences and task accuracy. To this end, we present MBBQ (Multilingual Bias Benchmark for Question-answering), a carefully curated version of the English BBQ dataset extended to Dutch, Spanish, and Turkish, which measures stereotypes commonly held across these languages. We further complement MBBQ with a parallel control dataset to measure task performance on the question-answering task independently of bias. Our results based on several open-source and proprietary LLMs confirm that some non-English languages suffer from bias more than English, even when controlling for cultural shifts. Moreover, we observe significant cross-lingual differences in bias behaviour for all except the most accurate models. With the release of MBBQ, we hope to encourage further research on bias in multilingual settings. The dataset and code are available at https://github.com/Veranep/MBBQ.
Nov 23, 2023

General Phrase Debiaser: Debiasing Masked Language Models at a Multi-Token Level

The social biases and unwelcome stereotypes revealed by pretrained language models are becoming obstacles to their application. Compared to numerous debiasing methods targeting word level, there has been relatively less attention on biases present at phrase level, limiting the performance of debiasing in discipline domains. In this paper, we propose an automatic multi-token debiasing pipeline called General Phrase Debiaser, which is capable of mitigating phrase-level biases in masked language models. Specifically, our method consists of a phrase filter stage that generates stereotypical phrases from Wikipedia pages as well as a model debias stage that can debias models at the multi-token level to tackle bias challenges on phrases. The latter searches for prompts that trigger model's bias, and then uses them for debiasing. State-of-the-art results on standard datasets and metrics show that our approach can significantly reduce gender biases on both career and multiple disciplines, across models with varying parameter sizes.