Disentangling Forced and Internal Climate Variability in Single Realizations using Dynamic Mode Decomposition with Control
Organizations: Image Processing Laboratory (IPL), Universitat de València, Spain
Abstract
Separating externally forced trends from internal climate variability is a fundamental challenge in climate science, particularly when analyzing observational records that exist only as a single realization. We show that a single climate realization can be decomposed into forced and internal components by treating external forcing as a dynamical driver within a linear stochastic system, an idea grounded in pullback attractor theory. This addresses a central challenge for climate projection and for detecting and attributing the forced response. Existing single-realization methods rely on linear inverse models (LIMs), which ignore forcing, or linear regression, which omits dynamics. Here we introduce PullbackDMDc, a method grounded in non-autonomous dynamical systems theory and dynamic mode decomposition with control (DMDc), incorporating pullback attractor estimation to decompose a single climate realization into spatial modes and their associated forced and internal components, yielding a physically interpretable picture of the underlying dynamics. After testing on a synthetic system with a known forced response, we illustrate the utility of PullbackDMDc for Earth System Model (ESM) evaluation by applying it to near-surface air temperature and sea-level pressure from reanalysis and four ESM large ensembles. PullbackDMDc estimates the forced response with skill matching or exceeding established baselines and helps select forcing predictors against model-based ground truth. Its internal-variability components reveal that ESMs qualitatively capture interannual and decadal modes while exhibiting systematic differences relative to each other and to observations. Skillful forced-response estimation and a novel decomposition position PullbackDMDc as a practical tool for single-realization climate analysis and ESM evaluation.
Figures & tables
Appendix figures & tables30 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Experiment | Levels | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Total SNR | scaled by | |
| Slow timescale | yr | at fixed ratios (fixed SNR) |
| Measurement noise | alone (SNR decreases) | |
| Spatial overlap | , Eq. ( A.6 ) | |
| Joint | SNR levels levels | both, as above |
| Figure(s) | Description |
|---|---|
| Figs. 9 – 12 | Synthetic climate prototype experiments: system setup, verification of forced-response estimates against exact ground truth, and parameter sensitivity analyses. |
| Fig. 13 | Evaluation of forced-response estimates over the full historical period (1850–2014) using Taylor diagrams for SAT. |
| Fig. 14 | Comparison of estimated forced-response trends against the large ensemble mean over 1850–2014. |
| Fig. 15 – 17 | Forced-response trends over 1985–2014: trend maps for SAT and SLP (OSAT in the main text), and Taylor diagrams for SAT, OSAT and SLP. |
| Fig. 18 | Evaluation of forced-response estimates over the shorter period (1950–2014) using Taylor diagrams for SLP, SAT and OSAT. |
| Fig. 19 | Comparison of the decay times and oscillation frequencies of the leading dynamical modes between LIM and PullbackDMDc variants for SAT and OSAT across ESMs and reanalysis. |
Climate Science
Climate science studies Earth's climate system, its past and future changes, and the physical and human drivers of climate risks.
See all 66 papers