SCOPE: Scene-graph Construction Optimized by Plan Error-correction for Robot Long-term Planning Datasets
Authors: Chaoyue Li, Zeyu Gao, Yanfeng Lu, Fan Luo
Organizations: State Key Laboratory of Multimodal Artificial Intelligence Systems, Institute of Automation, Chinese Academy of Sciences (CASIA), Beijing 100190, China. · School of Artificial Intelligence, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences (UCAS), Beijing 100049, China.
Task and Motion Planning (TAMP) stands as a fundamental challenge in robotics, essential for enabling autonomous agents to execute complex, long-horizon tasks in diverse environments. While Large Language Models (LLMs) introduce a new paradigm for TAMP by leveraging extensive common sense, their inherent reasoning limitations hinder direct application, and fine-tuning strategies to enhance these capabilities are currently bottlenecked by the scarcity of high-quality datasets. Existing automated generation methods often suffer from homogeneity, limiting model generalization, and unsolvability, where hallucinated scene graphs create physical mismatches with task goals. To address these issues, we propose Scene-graph Construction Optimized by Plan Error-correction (SCOPE), an automated framework designed to generate diverse and executable TAMP datasets. SCOPE incorporates multi-level diversity metrics to maximize the information entropy of scenarios. Crucially, it introduces a Plan Feedback Error-correction pipeline that utilizes planner execution failures as feedback signals to retroactively rectify logical inconsistencies in scene graphs, ensuring physical feasibility. Experimental results demonstrate that SCOPE exhibits greater robustness to erroneous scene graphs and generates higher-quality data. When utilized for LLM fine-tuning, SCOPE-generated data yield a downstream TAMP model that achieves an absolute 12.33% gain in success rate over its counterpart fine-tuned with data generated by DELTA, a state-of-the-art PDDL-based planner.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1: An end-to-end task planning framework demonstrates the complete pipeline from environmental perception to plan generation. First, hierarchical scene graphs are extracted from the AI2-THOR environment. Subsequently, these graphs and natural language instructions are fed into the Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct model. This model is fine-tuned on the SCOPE dataset via LoRA for efficient task planning. Finally, the model outputs an ordered plan sequence Π={π0,π1,…,πn} , which is executed by the AI2-THOR simulator.
Fig. 2: Overview of the SCOPE framework. The pipeline consists of three main stages: (1) diverse scene generation based on statistical feedback and dynamic sampling; (2) Chain-of-Thought driven task instruction generation; and (3) scene graph construction optimized by planning feedback and autoregressive error-correction.
Methods
Overall
Simple Tasks
Complex Tasks
Vague Tasks
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
LLM-As-Planner [ 6 ]
1.84
27.00%
29.67%
2.27
46.00%
46.00%
1.78
18.00%
21.00%
1.47
17.00%
22.00%
LLM+P [ 7 ]
1.76
41.67%
48.00%
2.68
67.00%
67.00%
1.41
30.00%
39.00%
1.18
28.00%
38.00%
LLMGenPlan (w/o rp.)
0.40
6.33%
36.67%
0.61
12.00%
45.00%
0.36
4.00%
34.00%
0.22
3.00%
31.00%
LLMGenPlan [ 17 ]
1.24
23.00%
61.33%
1.83
42.00%
70.00%
1.14
14.00%
67.00%
0.76
13.00%
47.00%
DELTA [ 18 ]
2.25
46.33%
67.00%
2.86
69.00%
74.00%
1.94
31.00%
68.00%
1.94
39.00%
59.00%
TABLE I: Planning Robustness Evaluation on LLM-Synthetic Noisy Dataset. Comparison of baseline models and SCOPE under erroneous scene graphs generated by LLMs.
Methods
Div.
Corr.
Overall
Simple Tasks
Complex Tasks
Vague Tasks
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
AQS ↑
SR ↑
EX ↑
LLM-As-Planner [ 6 ]
✗
✗
1.57
25.00%
26.00%
2.43
54.00%
54.00%
1.36
10.00%
11.00%
0.91
11.00%
13.00%
DELTA [ 18 ]
✗
✗
2.67
50.67%
77.67%
3.47
83.00%
90.00%
2.23
28.00%
74.00%
2.31
41.00%
69.00%
SCOPE
✓
✗
3.03
59.67%
87.00%
3.62
87.00%
93.00%
2.66
40.00%
86.00%
2.81
52.00%
82.00%
SCOPE
✗
✓
2.96
58.00%
81.00%
3.60
86.00%
93.00%
2.65
41.00%
71.00%
2.64
47.00%
79.00%
SCOPE
✓
✓
3.08
63.00%
85.33%
3.61
88.00%
93.00%
2.83
50.00%
83.00%
2.81
51.00%
80.00%
TABLE II: Generalization Performance of Fine-tuned Models on AI2-THOR Grounded Dataset. Ablation of the planning capabilities of models fine-tuned on datasets varying in scene diversity and error-correction.
Fig. 3: Simulation snapshots of the execution process of a long-horizon task.
Fig. 4: Failure analysis of the SCOPE-fine-tuned model. The errors are classified into high-level cognitive deficits and low-level grounding issues to illustrate the bottlenecks in the planning pipeline.
Long-horizon task planning for heterogeneous multi-robot systems is essential for deploying collaborative teams in real-world environments; yet, it remains challenging due to the large volume of perceptual information, much of which is irrelevant to task objectives and burdens planning. Traditional symbolic planners rely on manually constructed problem specifications, limiting scalability and adaptability, while recent large language model (LLM)-based approaches often suffer from hallucinations and weak grounding-i.e., poor alignment between generated plans and actual environmental objects and constraints-in object-rich settings. We present Scale-Plan, a scalable LLM-assisted framework that generates compact, task-relevant problem representations from natural language instructions. Given a PDDL domain specification, Scale-Plan constructs an action graph capturing domain structure and uses shallow LLM reasoning to guide a structured graph search that identifies a minimal subset of relevant actions and objects. By filtering irrelevant information prior to planning, Scale-Plan enables efficient decomposition, allocation, and long-horizon plan generation. We evaluate our approach on complex multi-agent tasks and introduce MAT2-THOR, a cleaned benchmark built on AI2-THOR for reliable evaluation of multi-robot planning systems. Scale-Plan outperforms pure LLM and hybrid LLM-PDDL baselines across all metrics, improving scalability and reliability. Project website: https://github.com/honda-research-institute/Scale_Plan
Piyush Gupta, Sangjae Bae, Jiachen Li +1
Honda Research Institute, San Jose, CA 95134, USA. · Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, USA.
Ambiguity poses a major challenge to large language models (LLMs) used as robotic planners. In this letter, we present Scene Graph-Chain-of-Thought (SG-CoT), a two-stage framework where LLMs iteratively query a scene graph representation of the environment to detect and clarify ambiguities. First, a structured scene graph representation of the environment is constructed from input observations, capturing objects, their attributes, and relationships with other objects. Second, the LLM is equipped with retrieval functions to query portions of the scene graph that are relevant to the provided instruction. This grounds the reasoning process of the LLM in the observation, increasing the reliability of robotic planners under ambiguous situations. SG-CoT also allows the LLM to identify the source of ambiguity and pose a relevant disambiguation question to the user or another robot. Extensive experimentation demonstrates that SG-CoT consistently outperforms prior methods, with a minimum of 10% improvement in question accuracy and a minimum success rate increase of 4% in single-agent and 15% in multi-agent environments, validating its effectiveness for more generalizable robot planning.
Akshat Rana, Peeyush Agarwal, K. P. S. Rana +1
Netaji Subhas University of Technology, Dwarka, 110078, Delhi, India.
Human teleoperators spend substantial time demonstrating behaviors that robots can already perform autonomously, limiting the scalability of data collection for robot foundation models. Task and motion planning (TAMP) can automate many of these behaviors, but a fixed planning domain may not support every stage of a long-horizon manipulation task. We present TANDEM (Tamp with As-Needed Demonstrations for Efficient Model fine-tuning), a system that combines TAMP with selective human teleoperation to collect demonstrations for tasks beyond the planner's capabilities. Our key idea is to represent human assistance as an on-demand planning capability. Given a language instruction and visual observation, TANDEM uses pretrained vision-language models to extend the planning domain with missing predicates and human-executed magic operators. This allows the planner to interleave autonomous and human-executed stages without task-specific intervention points. After each human stage, TANDEM re-perceives the scene and checks whether the intended effects hold before resuming autonomous planning. To support fine-tuning vision-language-action (VLA) models, TANDEM also uses example pretraining trajectories to align planner-generated motions with the target model's pretraining distribution. We evaluate TANDEM on five long-horizon manipulation tasks beyond the TAMP domain's capabilities. On a representative long-horizon task, TANDEM collects 2.9x as many demonstrations as full-task teleoperation at the same human intervention time. Fine-tuning a pretrained π_{0.5}-DROID model on 20 TANDEM demonstrations per task increases average task success from 0% to 60% across the five tasks.