We describe our approach to the V2X-Real track of the UrbanTwin Sim2Real LiDAR Challenge, in which a 3D object detector must be trained exclusively on synthetic data and evaluated on unseen real roadside LiDAR from an Ouster OS1-64 unit, while the synthetic point clouds are simultaneously scored for distributional realism. Our final entry scores 0.7457 combined, from a detection mAP of 0.4382 and a realism score of 0.9251. Three findings account for most of our result, and all three were diagnostic rather than architectural. First, a coordinate frame mismatch between our predictions and the evaluation ground truth was suppressing detection AP entirely; recovering it took our score from 0.3520 to 0.5147 in a single submission. Second, a single global non maximum suppression threshold was destroying genuine pedestrian detections, because pedestrians occur in groups and a 0.3 IoU threshold applied to a 0.7 m box suppresses distinct neighbouring people; correcting this per class raised overall mAP from 0.0751 to 0.4295. Third, approximately 31 percent of the real reference point cloud consists of null returns encoded as the literal point (0, 0, 0), a format feature entirely absent from our synthetic clouds, which pinned Earth Mover's Distance near its floor until we modelled it. Negative results are reported at equal length, and Section 9 gives a full account of data provenance and compliance. That section also accounts for every mechanism contributing to the submitted score.
Figures & tables
class
n matched
dz
length ratio
width ratio
pedestrian
1418
+0.093
0.894
0.949
vehicle
677
+0.088
0.997
1.053
Table 1
quantity
value
Combined score
0.7457
Detection (normalised)
0.6260
3D mAP @ IoU 0.5, R40
0.4382
BEV mAP @ IoU 0.5, R40
0.5236
Realism (normalised)
0.9251
Predictions submitted
17,575 on 1,547 ground truth boxes
Table 2
class
AP
ground truth instances
vehicle
0.5921
470
pedestrian
0.1893
953
truck
0.5333
124
Table 3
metric
value
normalised
Chamfer Distance
2.0307
0.9989
Maximum Mean Discrepancy
1.4558e-03
0.9971
Earth Mover’s Distance
1.3815
0.7237
Frechet Point cloud Distance
0.9705
0.9806
Table 4
lever
evidence
verdict
Truck sizing beyond the shipped value
bracketed in both directions
Interior optimum confirmed. Shrinking loses roughly 8 times more than lengthening gains
Score thresholding
swept in both directions
No class moves. Recall is model limited, not threshold limited, and the suffix property held exactly as predicted
Test time augmentation on truck
per class evaluation
Minus 23 percent. Applied per class, not globally
Anchor free heads
z distribution analysis
Genuinely unsuitable here. The scene has an 18 m vertical spread, which anchor free regression handles poorly
Learned refiners
built and measured
The sim2real gap, not compliance, was the binding constraint
Realism by further resampling
swept after the null return fix
A further round of harder distribution optimisation added only 0.0035 realism, against 0.0387 from the null return and alignment work. Lever largely exhausted
Lidar-based 3D object detection locates and classifies objects in point clouds, supporting perception for autonomous vehicles, robots, and other mobile systems.