cs.CRNov 3, 2026

When Debate Amplifies Risk: Social-Bias Vulnerabilities in Multi-Agent Safety Deliberation

Authors: Qinghua Mao, Xi Lin, Yuxin Qi, Zihao Xu, Jinze Gu, Yuliang Chen

Organizations: Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China · China Telecom, Shanghai, China

Abstract

Retrieval-augmented Web applications increasingly employ multi-agent debate (MAD) to aggregate conflicting, noisy, and heterogeneous information, yet deliberation is fundamentally a social process susceptible to interpersonal dynamics. When retrieved Web sources contain latent hazards alongside safe factual content, social biases such as conformity pressure and authority deference can override evidence-grounded safety boundaries. In this work, we investigate whether the social structure of deliberation can paradoxically amplify latent Web safety risks. We introduce SafeConflict-Bias, a controlled counterfactual diagnostic protocol spanning six core Web risk categories, which holds queries and retrieved evidence strictly invariant while isolating conversational majority sway, authority cues, and confidence asymmetry. Empirical evaluation across diverse proprietary and open-source backbones reveals that while isolated models reliably reject unsafe guidance, standard MAD catastrophically capitulates to social pressure---surging unsafe adoption from 0.0% up to 100.0% and systematically silencing safe minority evidence. To resolve this systemic fragility without retraining or debate regeneration, we propose RiskTrace-Debias, an inference-time auditing framework uniting evidence-first precommitment, social-metadata masking, and consistency-gated arbitration. RiskTrace-Debias suppresses worst-case unsafe adoption to ≤2.0%\le 2.0\% across all architectures without inducing over-refusal, while generating verifiable provenance traces to audit interpersonal manipulation in Web deliberation.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables2 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. From Debate to Decision: Conformal Social Choice for Safe Multi-Agent Deliberation

    Apr 9, 2026Mengdie Flora Wang, Haochen Xie, Guanghui Wang +9LLM Agent SafetySelective Prediction

  2. MADBench: Benchmarking the Security of Multi-Agent Debate

    Sep 30, 2026Yuwan Liu, Jiaming Zhang, Yue Huang +1Adversarial Attacks on LLMsMulti-Agent Debate

  3. The Deliberative Illusion: Diagnosing Factual Attrition and Stance Homogenization in Multi-Agent LLM Deliberation

    Jun 2, 2026Herun Wan, Jiaying Wu, Minnan Luo +4Multi-Agent LLM SystemsLLM Agent Evaluation