The Effectiveness of Sliding Mode Control for Robust Vision Stabilization under the Plant-Binding Condition
Organizations: Department of Mechanical Engineering, SUNY Korea, Incheon, Republic of Korea · Department of Mechanical Engineering, Stony Brook University, NY, USA · Department of Computer Science, SUNY Korea, Incheon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Boundary-layer Sliding Mode Control (SMC) has been applied to vision-based stabilization, but identifying its activation condition against simpler causal baselines (LPF, PID) has been elusive. The operational condition is plant binding: the disturbance velocity approaches or exceeds the actuator slew limit, so the bounded per-step actuation budget binds. We validate this in two independent vision domains: handheld translation stabilization (12 1080p clips; LPF, PID, SMC, L1) and angular re-framing against a virtual slew-rate-limited pan-tilt-zoom (PTZ) plant. Outside binding, leave-one-out cross-validation makes SMC and LPF on translation statistically indistinguishable, and PID beats SMC on the angular 99th-percentile pointing offset by 5.85 degrees (95% CI clear of zero); inside binding -- reached only by sweeping the simulated slew limit, as both captured datasets land outside it -- the translation gap stays a tie and SMC beats PID on the angular worst case (Cohen's d up to +0.83). The PTZ plant's 100 degrees/s default sits on the cross-over, which explains a small-margin PID result previously reported in the angular setting. A complementary ablation shows raising the SMC reaching gain k costs mean tracking outside a narrow window.
Figures & tables
| o|X[0.9,m,c]|X[0.9,m,c]|X[2.6,m,c]|Domain | Method | Configuration |
|---|---|---|
| Transl. | Raw | no processing |
| Transl. | LPF | th-order causal Butterworth, clip-specific |
| Transl. | PID | , , , anti-windup [ 16 ] |
| Transl. | SMC | ( 6 ): , , |
| Transl. | global LP solve [ 10 ] ; non-causal | |
| Angular | PID | , , (P-only in effect; Sec. 3.2 ) |
| o|X[1.9,m,c]|X[0.9,m,c]|X[2.2,m,c]|X[0.7,m,c]|Configuration | Mean diff (px) | CI (px) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: paper, fixed | |||
| B: LOO-CV, locked | |||
| C: LOO-CV, free (picks ) |
| o|X[0.7,m,c]|X[0.9,m,c]|X[1.9,m,c]|X[1.9,m,c]|slew ( s) | Mean diff (deg) | CI (deg) | Note |
| SMC wins ( ) | |||
| CIs cross zero | tied | ||
| PID, px equiv | |||
| PID, px equiv | |||
| clear of zero | PID dominates |
Sliding Mode Control
Sliding mode control uses switching feedback to drive systems toward designed surfaces and maintain robust behavior despite disturbances and uncertainty.
See all 17 papers