Same Contacts, Different Rooms:Meeting Format Shapes LLM Group Influence Beyond Pairwise Contact Counts
Authors: Zhexi Gu, Shusheng Cao, Runping Zhu
Organizations: School of Information and Library Science, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA · School of Geographic and Biologic Information, Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications, China · Public Relations and Advertising, Department of Communication, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Beijing Normal-Hong Kong Baptist University, China
Simulations of LLM agent collectives usually summarise interaction as a pairwise contact network. We test that summary with a contact-matched intervention: the members, their initial stances and every pairwise contact count stay fixed while the meetings are reorganised, and each member gives a one-step support readout after reading the arguments of everyone present. Across six open-weight LLMs and 14 debate topics, merging triads into five-person meetings (resize) moves group support more than reshuffling who meets in triads (regroup), although both move the same 60 dyadic exposures. The root-mean-square change is 4.36 versus 2.59 percentage points (pp), larger for resize in all six models and in 81 of 84 model-topic cells. Resizing also has a consistent direction: it amplifies the initial majority of the merged members by 1.72 pp, in every model, whereas regrouping has no direction (<= 0.03 pp). A contact network cannot represent regrouping at all, yet pairwise rules applied meeting by meeting explain up to 76% of its effect, and with identical weights they raise resize R^2 by 0.51-0.58 for two models. We show that the gap between the two placements is an exact Jensen gap of the sigmoid readout, bounded by how much a member's predicted logits vary across meetings; this dispersion tracks the gap with log-log r=0.97 and tells a modeller when contact counts are a safe summary. Meeting format is a first-class variable for LLM social simulation.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Contact-matched schedules for six members (rows). Filled dots mark the members of one triad; “ ×k ” is its number of copies. (a) Base: two copies of every triad among members 1–5 (2T) plus five copies of each of four further triads P. (b) Regroup replaces P with four other triads P ′ (orange). (c) Resize replaces 2T with six five-person meetings S of members 1–5. (d) All three schedules share this pair-contact matrix (120 dyadic contacts); each intervention removes and adds 60. Meeting counts are 40, 40 and 26; members 1–5 attend 22 meetings in base and regroup and 16 in resize, and member 6 attends 10 in all three.
Magnitude: RMS change (pp)
Majority-directed shift D (pp)
Model
Resize
Regroup
Resize − regroup [95% CI]
Ratio
Cells
Resize [95% CI]
Regroup
Size w.
Network
Granite4.2-3B
5.61
4.38
1.23 [0.67, 1.83]
1.28
13/14
2.85 [2.25, 3.48]
0.00
2.26
0.62
LFM2.5-1.2B
3.09
2.30
0.79 [0.55, 1.02]
1.34
13/14
0.93 [0.58, 1.24]
0.00
1.11
− 0.16
Gemma4-E2B
6.70
3.87
2.83 [1.94, 3.65]
1.73
13/14
2.27 [1.68, 2.76]
0.00
0.68
0.25
MiniCPM5-2B
5.33
2.39
2.94 [2.15, 3.61]
2.23
14/14
2.74 [2.10, 3.36]
0.03
− 0.09
− 0.11
Phi4-mini
3.22
1.39
1.82 [1.28, 2.38]
2.31
14/14
0.90 [0.44, 1.40]
0.00
− 0.01
− 0.04
Table 1: Meeting-format effects on one-step support with pair contacts fixed (14 topics, 1,920 configurations each, person weighting). Cells: model–topic cells in which resize has the larger RMS. The last two columns give the majority-directed shift that the meeting-wise Size-weight rule and the static network rule predict for resize. All-six row: equal-weight model average with jointly resampled topics; Ratio there gives the range across models.
Figure 2: Meeting format changes one-step group support at fixed pair contacts. (a) RMS change per model–topic cell ( n=84 ; 1,920 configurations per cell); filled points: resize larger, open points: regroup larger. (b) Signed resize effect (pp), averaged over topics, by the number of initial supporters among members 1–5; the dashed line marks where the core majority switches from oppose to support. (c) Majority-directed shift D with 95% topic-cluster intervals, rows as in (b). Regroup estimates are at most 0.03 pp in every model (its signed effects by core composition all lie within ±0.11 pp), so only resize has a systematic direction.
Figure 3: Contrast R2 of five pairwise predictors for (a) resize and (b) regroup effects (14 topics per model). R2=0 equals predicting no change; colours are clipped at −1 . Boxes mark each model’s best predictor. Sum, Mean, Size and Stance are meeting-wise (Eq. 2 ); Static network applies Size weights to the aggregated contact network (Eq. 3 ) and predicts exactly zero regroup effect.
Figure 4: Aggregation placement and its mechanism. (a) Paired R2 gain of meeting-wise Size weights over the same weights on the static contact network, for resize and regroup effects (95% topic-cluster intervals, 14 topics). (b) Auxiliary five-person design (three five-person meetings versus all ten triads; every pair meets three times in both): RMS Jensen gap of the Size rule against the mean variance of each member’s predicted logits across its meetings (one point per model–topic, n=84 ).
Appendix figures & tables7 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
Label
Hugging Face repository
Revision
Role
Gemma4-E2B
google/gemma-4-E2B-it
3e22461f65
main + micro
Granite4.2-3B
ibm-granite/granite-4.2-3b
4e9c275e23
main + micro
LFM2.5-1.2B
LiquidAI/LFM2.5-1.2B-Instruct
0f604ada3f
main + micro
MiniCPM5-2B
openbmb/MiniCPM5-2B
f97400052a
main + micro
Phi4-mini
microsoft/Phi-4-mini-instruct
cfbefacb99
main + micro
Qwen3.5-4B
Qwen/Qwen3.5-4B
851bf6e806
main + micro
Appendix
Table 2: Models and pinned download revisions (first ten hex digits). “Main + micro”: main group study and micro-experiment; the other five models enter the micro-experiment and the robustness analysis on the six further topics.
Scope
Weight
Res. − reg.
Cells
Models
Main: 6 models, 14 topics
person
1.77 [1.50, 2.03]
81/84
6/6
incidence
2.53 [2.26, 2.79]
84/84
6/6
6 models, 6 further topics
person
1.68 [1.41, 1.97]
35/36
6/6
incidence
2.45 [2.19, 2.69]
36/36
6/6
5 other models, 6 further topics
person
1.30 [1.22, 1.37]
30/30
5/5
incidence
1.79 [1.69, 1.89]
30/30
5/5
Appendix
Table 3: RMS difference between resize and regroup (pp, [95% CI]) across study scopes and weightings. The R1 readout scores full candidate answers by log-likelihood; with two topics, no cluster-bootstrap interval is reported.
Model
Sum
Mean
Size weights
Stance weights
Static network
Resize − base
Granite4.2-3B
− 1.69 [ − 2.68, − 0.88]
0.15 [0.01, 0.29]
0.48 [0.37, 0.57]
0.49 [0.39, 0.59]
− 0.03 [ − 0.20, 0.12]
LFM2.5-1.2B
− 3.12 [ − 4.97, − 1.58]
0.34 [0.21, 0.45]
0.20 [0.02, 0.37]
0.13 [ − 0.04, 0.27]
− 0.38 [ − 0.55, − 0.21]
Gemma4-E2B
0.07 [ − 0.10, 0.19]
− 0.01 [ − 0.05, 0.03]
0.11 [0.05, 0.19]
0.05 [ − 0.02, 0.12]
0.09 [0.03, 0.15]
MiniCPM5-2B
− 0.71 [ − 1.81, − 0.27]
0.00 [ − 0.02, 0.02]
0.02 [ − 0.10, 0.11]
0.12 [ − 0.01, 0.21]
0.04 [ − 0.09, 0.13]
Phi4-mini
− 2.29 [ − 4.91, − 0.83]
− 0.01 [ − 0.02, 0.01]
− 0.08 [ − 0.23, 0.07]
− 0.02 [ − 0.12, 0.09]
− 0.07 [ − 0.22, 0.07]
Appendix
Table 4: Contrast R2 [95% CI] for every predictor, model and intervention (values shown in Figure 3 ). “0 (constr.)”: identically zero because base and regroup share the contact network.
Table 9Table 10
Figure 5: Micro-experiment (64 items, 19 topics, 11 models). (a) Mean change in opposition-directed logit with k opponents and no allies. (b) Change when peers are scaled at fixed opponent:ally ratios (95% topic-cluster intervals); rows follow the order in (a).
Model
Shift at 6 opponents
Power exponent (1–6)
Neutral-statement effect
Fixed share 2:1
Granite4.2-3B
12.40
0.56 [0.47, 0.70]
− 2.21 [ − 2.80, − 1.64]
2.46 [1.56, 3.42]
Gemma4-E2B
8.72
0.87 [0.73, 1.09]
0.34 [0.07, 0.57]
0.75 [0.07, 1.47]
LFM2.5-1.2B
7.80
0.41 [0.36, 0.48]
− 2.40 [ − 3.04, − 1.87]
0.71 [0.49, 0.94]
SmolLM3-3B
3.02
0.54 [0.46, 0.63]
− 0.34 [ − 0.49, − 0.19]
0.08 [ − 0.21, 0.44]
MiniCPM5-2B
3.01
–
0.25 [ − 0.22, 0.75]
0.43 [ − 0.01, 0.86]
Gemma4-E4B
2.49
1.77
− 0.44 [ − 1.12, 0.21]
0.25 [ − 0.62, 1.04]
Appendix
Table 9: Micro-experiment summaries (logits, [95% CI]). Power exponent: fitted exponent of the no-ally count curve; “–” or no interval where it is undefined. Neutral-statement effect: change in a single opponent’s influence when three neutral statements are added.
Can LLM agents simulate how a real public would deliberate? For such simulations to be meaningful, agents must reflect the population's opinions, and their views must be shaped by what others say during discussion. We evaluate these requirements across six LLMs using national surveys, controlled deliberation experiments, and a real deliberative poll. Comparing census-grounded Korean personas against national surveys, we find that agents often produce overly concentrated opinions and fail to reliably reproduce demographic differences. During simulated deliberation, agents exchange arguments, respond to one another, and frequently change positions. Yet similar changes occur even when agents cannot see one another's contributions, while simply restating their starting positions sharply reduces movement. We further test whether these limitations persist in a real-world setting, using agents constructed from actual respondents in the 2017 Shin-Kori deliberative poll. Even with real respondent profiles, agents fail to reproduce the panel's initial opinion distribution or how its opinions change across survey waves. Our findings show that generating deliberative discussions, representing public opinion, and reproducing interaction-driven opinion change are distinct capabilities. These results suggest a different potential role for LLM deliberation: surfacing arguments and perspectives, rather than simulating a real public.
Chaemin Jang, Junsik Min, Jaewoo Choi +9
Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST) · Seoul National University
Studies attempting to simulate human behavior with Silicon Societies grow in numbers while LLM-only social networks have started appearing outside of controlled settings. However, the design space of these networks remains under-studied, which contributes to a gap in validating model realism. To enable future works to make more informed design decisions, we perform a systematic analysis of the consequences and interactions of key design choices in simulated social networks, including the choice of base model used to model individual agents, and how they are connected to each other. Using surveys as a proxy for agent opinions, our findings suggest that the geometry of the design space is non-trivial, with some parameters behaving in additive ways while others display more complex interactions. In particular, the choice of the base LLM is the most important variable impacting the simulation outcomes.
Aurélien Bück-Kaeffer, Sneheel Sarangi, Maximilian Puelma Touzel +3
McGill University · Mila - Quebec Artificial Intelligence Institute · Ubisoft La Forge +2
As large language models (LLMs) are deployed in interacting populations, their collective behaviour depends not only on the models but also on who interacts with whom. Studies of convention formation in LLM populations have mainly tested well-mixed interactions. We place policies extracted from four LLMs on fully connected, random regular, and heterogeneous networks, with 103 to 105 agents playing the naming game. Topology affects how quickly consensus emerges, sometimes whether it emerges at all, and, in rare cases, which convention wins. Sparsest networks slow consensus up to twelvefold. Yet, by preserving correlations between persistent neighbours, they restore consensus in some cases that fail to converge under well-mixed interactions. Networks also govern vulnerability to adversarial attack. We measure the critical mass of committed agents needed to overturn an established convention. Tipping thresholds follow the same ordering across models and conditions: hubs ≤ random ≤ low-degree nodes. On the most heterogeneous topology, median critical masses are 3%, 16%, and 35%, respectively; targeting hubs requires one-sixth as many committed agents as random placement. For most models, networked populations are easier to tip than well-mixed ones, so well-mixed estimates can overstate robustness. Assessing the safety of multi-agent AI requires mapping who interacts with whom.
IT University of Copenhagen, Denmark. · Pioneer Centre for AI, Copenhagen, Denmark. · Department of Mathematics, City St George’s, University of London, UK. +1