Same Contacts, Different Rooms:Meeting Format Shapes LLM Group Influence Beyond Pairwise Contact Counts
Authors: Zhexi Gu, Shusheng Cao, Runping Zhu
Organizations: School of Information and Library Science, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA · School of Geographic and Biologic Information, Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications, China · Public Relations and Advertising, Department of Communication, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Beijing Normal-Hong Kong Baptist University, China
Simulations of LLM agent collectives usually summarise interaction as a pairwise contact network. We test that summary with a contact-matched intervention: the members, their initial stances and every pairwise contact count stay fixed while the meetings are reorganised, and each member gives a one-step support readout after reading the arguments of everyone present. Across six open-weight LLMs and 14 debate topics, merging triads into five-person meetings (resize) moves group support more than reshuffling who meets in triads (regroup), although both move the same 60 dyadic exposures. The root-mean-square change is 4.36 versus 2.59 percentage points (pp), larger for resize in all six models and in 81 of 84 model-topic cells. Resizing also has a consistent direction: it amplifies the initial majority of the merged members by 1.72 pp, in every model, whereas regrouping has no direction (<= 0.03 pp). A contact network cannot represent regrouping at all, yet pairwise rules applied meeting by meeting explain up to 76% of its effect, and with identical weights they raise resize R^2 by 0.51-0.58 for two models. We show that the gap between the two placements is an exact Jensen gap of the sigmoid readout, bounded by how much a member's predicted logits vary across meetings; this dispersion tracks the gap with log-log r=0.97 and tells a modeller when contact counts are a safe summary. Meeting format is a first-class variable for LLM social simulation.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Contact-matched schedules for six members (rows). Filled dots mark the members of one triad; “ ×k ” is its number of copies. (a) Base: two copies of every triad among members 1–5 (2T) plus five copies of each of four further triads P. (b) Regroup replaces P with four other triads P ′ (orange). (c) Resize replaces 2T with six five-person meetings S of members 1–5. (d) All three schedules share this pair-contact matrix (120 dyadic contacts); each intervention removes and adds 60. Meeting counts are 40, 40 and 26; members 1–5 attend 22 meetings in base and regroup and 16 in resize, and member 6 attends 10 in all three.
Magnitude: RMS change (pp)
Majority-directed shift D (pp)
Model
Resize
Regroup
Resize − regroup [95% CI]
Ratio
Cells
Resize [95% CI]
Regroup
Size w.
Network
Granite4.2-3B
5.61
4.38
1.23 [0.67, 1.83]
1.28
13/14
2.85 [2.25, 3.48]
0.00
2.26
0.62
LFM2.5-1.2B
3.09
2.30
0.79 [0.55, 1.02]
1.34
13/14
0.93 [0.58, 1.24]
0.00
1.11
− 0.16
Gemma4-E2B
6.70
3.87
2.83 [1.94, 3.65]
1.73
13/14
2.27 [1.68, 2.76]
0.00
0.68
0.25
MiniCPM5-2B
5.33
2.39
2.94 [2.15, 3.61]
2.23
14/14
2.74 [2.10, 3.36]
0.03
− 0.09
− 0.11
Phi4-mini
3.22
1.39
1.82 [1.28, 2.38]
2.31
14/14
0.90 [0.44, 1.40]
0.00
− 0.01
− 0.04
Table 1: Meeting-format effects on one-step support with pair contacts fixed (14 topics, 1,920 configurations each, person weighting). Cells: model–topic cells in which resize has the larger RMS. The last two columns give the majority-directed shift that the meeting-wise Size-weight rule and the static network rule predict for resize. All-six row: equal-weight model average with jointly resampled topics; Ratio there gives the range across models.
Figure 2: Meeting format changes one-step group support at fixed pair contacts. (a) RMS change per model–topic cell ( n=84 ; 1,920 configurations per cell); filled points: resize larger, open points: regroup larger. (b) Signed resize effect (pp), averaged over topics, by the number of initial supporters among members 1–5; the dashed line marks where the core majority switches from oppose to support. (c) Majority-directed shift D with 95% topic-cluster intervals, rows as in (b). Regroup estimates are at most 0.03 pp in every model (its signed effects by core composition all lie within ±0.11 pp), so only resize has a systematic direction.
Figure 3: Contrast R2 of five pairwise predictors for (a) resize and (b) regroup effects (14 topics per model). R2=0 equals predicting no change; colours are clipped at −1 . Boxes mark each model’s best predictor. Sum, Mean, Size and Stance are meeting-wise (Eq. 2 ); Static network applies Size weights to the aggregated contact network (Eq. 3 ) and predicts exactly zero regroup effect.
Figure 4: Aggregation placement and its mechanism. (a) Paired R2 gain of meeting-wise Size weights over the same weights on the static contact network, for resize and regroup effects (95% topic-cluster intervals, 14 topics). (b) Auxiliary five-person design (three five-person meetings versus all ten triads; every pair meets three times in both): RMS Jensen gap of the Size rule against the mean variance of each member’s predicted logits across its meetings (one point per model–topic, n=84 ).
Appendix figures & tables7 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
Label
Hugging Face repository
Revision
Role
Gemma4-E2B
google/gemma-4-E2B-it
3e22461f65
main + micro
Granite4.2-3B
ibm-granite/granite-4.2-3b
4e9c275e23
main + micro
LFM2.5-1.2B
LiquidAI/LFM2.5-1.2B-Instruct
0f604ada3f
main + micro
MiniCPM5-2B
openbmb/MiniCPM5-2B
f97400052a
main + micro
Phi4-mini
microsoft/Phi-4-mini-instruct
cfbefacb99
main + micro
Qwen3.5-4B
Qwen/Qwen3.5-4B
851bf6e806
main + micro
Appendix
Table 2: Models and pinned download revisions (first ten hex digits). “Main + micro”: main group study and micro-experiment; the other five models enter the micro-experiment and the robustness analysis on the six further topics.
Scope
Weight
Res. − reg.
Cells
Models
Main: 6 models, 14 topics
person
1.77 [1.50, 2.03]
81/84
6/6
incidence
2.53 [2.26, 2.79]
84/84
6/6
6 models, 6 further topics
person
1.68 [1.41, 1.97]
35/36
6/6
incidence
2.45 [2.19, 2.69]
36/36
6/6
5 other models, 6 further topics
person
1.30 [1.22, 1.37]
30/30
5/5
incidence
1.79 [1.69, 1.89]
30/30
5/5
Appendix
Table 3: RMS difference between resize and regroup (pp, [95% CI]) across study scopes and weightings. The R1 readout scores full candidate answers by log-likelihood; with two topics, no cluster-bootstrap interval is reported.
Model
Sum
Mean
Size weights
Stance weights
Static network
Resize − base
Granite4.2-3B
− 1.69 [ − 2.68, − 0.88]
0.15 [0.01, 0.29]
0.48 [0.37, 0.57]
0.49 [0.39, 0.59]
− 0.03 [ − 0.20, 0.12]
LFM2.5-1.2B
− 3.12 [ − 4.97, − 1.58]
0.34 [0.21, 0.45]
0.20 [0.02, 0.37]
0.13 [ − 0.04, 0.27]
− 0.38 [ − 0.55, − 0.21]
Gemma4-E2B
0.07 [ − 0.10, 0.19]
− 0.01 [ − 0.05, 0.03]
0.11 [0.05, 0.19]
0.05 [ − 0.02, 0.12]
0.09 [0.03, 0.15]
MiniCPM5-2B
− 0.71 [ − 1.81, − 0.27]
0.00 [ − 0.02, 0.02]
0.02 [ − 0.10, 0.11]
0.12 [ − 0.01, 0.21]
0.04 [ − 0.09, 0.13]
Phi4-mini
− 2.29 [ − 4.91, − 0.83]
− 0.01 [ − 0.02, 0.01]
− 0.08 [ − 0.23, 0.07]
− 0.02 [ − 0.12, 0.09]
− 0.07 [ − 0.22, 0.07]
Appendix
Table 4: Contrast R2 [95% CI] for every predictor, model and intervention (values shown in Figure 3 ). “0 (constr.)”: identically zero because base and regroup share the contact network.
Table 9Table 10
Figure 5: Micro-experiment (64 items, 19 topics, 11 models). (a) Mean change in opposition-directed logit with k opponents and no allies. (b) Change when peers are scaled at fixed opponent:ally ratios (95% topic-cluster intervals); rows follow the order in (a).
Model
Shift at 6 opponents
Power exponent (1–6)
Neutral-statement effect
Fixed share 2:1
Granite4.2-3B
12.40
0.56 [0.47, 0.70]
− 2.21 [ − 2.80, − 1.64]
2.46 [1.56, 3.42]
Gemma4-E2B
8.72
0.87 [0.73, 1.09]
0.34 [0.07, 0.57]
0.75 [0.07, 1.47]
LFM2.5-1.2B
7.80
0.41 [0.36, 0.48]
− 2.40 [ − 3.04, − 1.87]
0.71 [0.49, 0.94]
SmolLM3-3B
3.02
0.54 [0.46, 0.63]
− 0.34 [ − 0.49, − 0.19]
0.08 [ − 0.21, 0.44]
MiniCPM5-2B
3.01
–
0.25 [ − 0.22, 0.75]
0.43 [ − 0.01, 0.86]
Gemma4-E4B
2.49
1.77
− 0.44 [ − 1.12, 0.21]
0.25 [ − 0.62, 1.04]
Appendix
Table 9: Micro-experiment summaries (logits, [95% CI]). Power exponent: fitted exponent of the no-ally count curve; “–” or no interval where it is undefined. Neutral-statement effect: change in a single opponent’s influence when three neutral statements are added.
IT University of Copenhagen, Denmark. · Pioneer Centre for AI, Copenhagen, Denmark. · Department of Mathematics, City St George’s, University of London, UK. +1