Passivity-Guaranteed Variable Impedance and Compliance Control via Online Parameter Optimization
Authors: Huseyin Tugcan Dinc, Ersin Daş, Nikolas Thelenberg, Christian Ott
Organizations: Automation and Control Institute (ACIN), TU Wien, Vienna, 1040, Austria · Department of Mechanical, Materials, and Aerospace Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, IL, 60616, USA · Institute of Robotics and Mechatronics, German Aerospace Center (DLR), Wessling, 82234, Germany
Variable impedance control enhances the interaction capability of robot manipulators by adapting impedance parameters online. However, time-varying impedance parameters may inject energy into the system and violate passivity, particularly when tasks demand rapid stiffness changes. Existing methods address this by increasing damping or limiting the stiffness profile, which often degrades the dynamic response. In this work, we propose a quadratic programming-based parameter optimization framework that guarantees passivity by modulating the desired inertia to compensate for energy injected by stiffness variations, while preserving a critically damped system. For the case of diagonal impedance matrices, we optimize the rates of change of inertia and stiffness subject to a passivity constraint formulated as a convex quadratic program. We extend the framework to compliance control, where the desired inertia is coupled to the robot's configuration-dependent inertia matrix. We use an eigendecomposition based on Cholesky factorization to optimize the spectral weights while maintaining passivity. Experiments on the Kinova Gen3 7-degree-of-freedom manipulator validate both methods with human interaction perturbations. Comparisons with an energy tank approach and a nonpassivity-based method demonstrate that the proposed framework achieves less conservative stiffness tracking without requiring an energy reservoir or damping overhead.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Overview of the proposed variable impedance and compliance control framework.
Figure 2: Block diagram representation of the proposed (a) variable impedance controller and (b) compliance controller.
Figure 3: Variable impedance control under a sinusoidal stiffness profile ( 42 ). Top row: Optimized (dashed) and desired (solid) stiffness for the x , y , and z axes; green-shaded regions indicate human interaction at the end-effector. Bottom row: Inertia scaling factors αx , αy , αz : the optimizer reduces α during stiffness increases to maintain passivity.
Figure 4: Compliance under a sinusoidal stiffness profile. Left to right panels: Desired and reconstructed (actual) stiffness for the x , y , and z axes via ( 28 ); green-shaded regions indicate human interaction at 5–7 [s] and 16–17 [s].
Figure 5: Comparison of the inertia scaling factor ε under different compliance control profiles. Left: Sine-wave profile. Right: Pulse-wave profile.
Figure 6: Compliance control under a pulse-wave stiffness profile ( 44 ) with sharp transitions ( γ=100 ). Left to right: Desired and reconstructed stiffness for the x , y , and z axes. The optimizer tracks the rapid stiffness changes while maintaining passivity through inertia scaling.
Figure 7: Left: Time derivative of the storage function S˙vic as in ( 15 ) during the variable impedance control experiment. Middle: Compliance control (sinusoidal profile). Time derivative of the storage function S˙comp as in ( 32 ). Right: Compliance control (pulse-wave profile). The nonpositive time derivative of the storage functions, confirming passivity throughout.
Figure 8: Energy tank comparison ( Ferraguti et al., 2013 ) with the pulse-wave stiffness profile. (a) Desired and passive stiffness in the −z axis: once the energy in the tank is insufficient, the controller can no longer track the desired profile and reduces stiffness to maintain passivity. (b) Energy level in the tank, showing depletion during sustained stiffness increases.
Figure 9: Comparison with a nonpassivity-based method ( Kronander and Billard, 2016 ) using the pulse-wave stiffness profile. The derivative of the Lyapunov function becomes positive when there are sudden switches in the stiffness profile, which violates the stability condition associated with the Lyapunov function.
Shared Control methods often use impedance control to track target poses in a robotic manipulator. The guidance behavior of such controllers is shaped by the used stiffness gains, which can be varying over time to achieve an adaptive guiding. When multiple target poses are tracked at the same time with varying importance, the corresponding output wrenches have to be arbitrated with weightings changing over time. In this work, we study the stabilization of both variable stiffness in impedance control as well as the arbitration of different controllers through a scaled addition of their output wrenches, reformulating both into a holistic framework. We identify passivity violations in the closed loop system and provide methods to passivate the system. The resulting approach can be used to stabilize standard impedance controllers, allowing for the development of novel and flexible shared control methods. We do not constrain the design of stiffness matrices or arbitration factors; both can be matrix-valued including off-diagonal elements and change arbitrarily over time. The proposed methods are furthermore validated in simulation as well as in real robot experiments on different systems, proving their effectiveness and showcasing different behaviors which can be utilized depending on the requirements of the shared control approach.
Maximilian Mühlbauer, Nepomuk Werner, Ribin Balachandran +4
School of Computation, Information and Technology, Sensor Based Robotic Systems and Intelligent Assistance Systems, Technical University Munich, Friedrich-Ludwig-Bauer-Str. 3, Garching, Germany. · German Aerospace Center (DLR), Robotics and Mechatronics Center (RMC), Münchener Str. 20, 82234 Weßling, Germany.
Contact-rich manipulation requires precise tracking and mechanical compliance, where variable impedance control can improve robustness in task success, whereas static compliance cannot adapt to varying contact constraints. Variable impedance skills can be learned from demonstrations, avoiding complex modeling, but compliance is a hidden variable in force-agnostic kinematic data. While existing methods infer compliance from trajectory variations, these variations may reflect geometric adaptation and not intentional compliance when subject to changing spatial layouts. Therefore, this letter introduces Variable Impedance Diffusion Policy (VIDP), an imitation learning-based variable impedance control framework leveraging a Task-Parameterized Directionality-Aware Mixture Model (TP-DAMM) to extract physically consistent trajectory distributions from diverse demonstrations. By mapping distributions to stiffness profiles, VIDP jointly predicts pose actions and task compliance without force sensors. Real-world experiments show that VIDP significantly outperforms fixed-impedance baselines in task success rate while reducing interaction forces with respect to high stiffness controllers and tracking errors with respect to low stiffness baselines.
Hisham Khalil, Neil Fernandes, Thomas M. Kwok +2
Department of Mechanical and Mechatronics Engineering, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada · Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada · School of Computer Science and the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada
The paper presents a robot-agnostic framework for implementing and deploying compliant-control algorithms across different manipulators. It extends the ROS control ecosystem with a plugin-based execution architecture that separates ROS controller boilerplate from control-law implementation. Standardized joint and Cartesian command interfaces provide a consistent message-level interface to higher-level applications, supporting motion references, stiffness and damping gains, nullspace targets, desired interaction wrenches, and independent feedforward inputs. Robot kinematics and dynamics are computed from URDF models using Pinocchio. The common plugin interface also supports control implementations generated through block-diagram-based pipelines. A real-robot curved-surface following experiment demonstrates the utility of online task-aligned compliance, while simulations demonstrate portability across manipulators with different kinematic and dynamic characteristics. The complete framework, including reference controllers, high-level task interfaces, and example configurations, is available as open-source software.
Mihael Simonič, Xiaocong Li
College of Information Science and Technology, Eastern Institute of Technology, Ningbo, Ningbo 315200, China · Zhejiang Key Laboratory of Industrial Intelligence and Digital Twin, Eastern Institute of Technology, Ningbo, Ningbo 315200, China