Beyond Acuity Accuracy: A Multidimensional Framework for Evaluating Patient-Facing Emergency Triage AI Tools
Organizations: Department of Biostatistics and Bioinformatics, Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, NC, USA · Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands · Department of Pediatrics, Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, NC, USA · Department of Medicine, Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, NC, USA ·
Abstract
Patient-facing AI triage tools may support care-seeking and emergency department prioritization, but require evaluation beyond acuity accuracy alone. We developed SAFE-Triage, a framework integrating human review, automated metrics, LLM-as-judge evaluation, and simulation testing across clinical performance, patient interaction, and clinician-facing summary quality. We applied SAFE-Triage to 40 MIMIC-IV-derived emergency vignettes and a 10,030-case acuity analysis comparing prompted LLM triage (PLT) with rule-augmented prompted LLM triage (rPLT). PLT achieved higher emergency severity index (ESI) accuracy (57.5% vs 42.8%, ), lower undertriage (13.1% vs 29.8%, ), and higher clinician ratings across all domains. rPLT produced shorter and more stable outputs with higher automated readability scores. SAFE-Triage identified trade-offs between acuity accuracy, undertriage risk, communication quality, readability, and summary quality, supporting pre-deployment refinement and ongoing monitoring by showing where triage tools are efficient, need improvement, or need clinician oversight.
Clinical Triage
Clinical triage uses patient symptoms, records, and measurements to prioritize urgency, referral, and care when time and resources are limited.
See all 51 papers