Organizations: University of Zagreb Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computing, AIFORS LAB, 10000, Zagreb, Croatia and Heron Robots, 16121, Genoa, Italy · the School of Engineering of the University of Basilicata, 85100, Potenza, Italy · the Institute of Marine Engineering of the National Research Council, 16149, Genoa, Italy
A great gap in adaptivity, flexibility, and dexterity still exists between intelligent robots, whether they are made of rigid or (partially) compliant components, and their naturally evolved animal and vegetal counterparts. One reason could be of paradigm' nature. On the one hand, most robots (both rigid and soft) are still designed by following a Cartesian' approach, with top-down control and a clear mind-body separation. Designing artificial agents on the basis of the principles that we observe in biology is not an easy task. The principles of organization of animals and plants rely on morphological computation and emergence of fit behaviors from loosely coupled networks of embodied agents. Modeling and control require radically new approaches. In this paper we briefly recall and explain some seminal mathematical results linking information metrics and dynamics of the agents, already published years ago; we integrate them with some recent methods developed by us and by the community, we highlight some brief remarks about their relevance and we hint to our current and near future work towards finding concrete and efficient ways for the modeling and control of completely or partially compliant artificial agents and for a better understanding of physical intelligence in nature. We present a technical note summarizing phase-space volume calculations for inverted-pendulum and passive-dynamic walking models, following our proposed framework. Starting from the McGeer compass gait, we introduce knee-ankle compliance, foot-rocker effects, and a Ruina-style compass gait with distributed leg inertia. Standard heel-strike maps are derived and used in the estimation of viable phase-space volumes W(γ), based on a state-dependent Monte-Carlo and Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces methods. We show how the methods based on RKHS allow deeper and more subtle analysis.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1: Phase–space admissible region (passive leg).
Fig. 2: Passive Walkers in the phase-space. Left: γ is the angle of the slope for a pure passive walker. Center: Illustrative Picture. Right: Our Simplified Model
Figure 3
Fig. 5: Rigid and projected compliant task-state samples. The two distributions have the same support, but the projected compliant distribution is more concentrated around low-energy states.
Fig. 6: Task-energy distributions for rigid and projected compliant samples. Uniform sampling in the full compliant energy ellipsoid shifts probability mass toward lower values of Hx .
Fig. 7: Empirical RKHS distributional complexity over independent realizations. The projected compliant distribution exhibits lower feature-space spectral complexity than the rigid distribution.
Quantity
Rigid
Compliant
Projected Euclidean support volume
6.2891
6.2891
Exact projected support volume
6.2832
6.2832
Kernel pullback volume
5.3171
5.3171
Mean task energy
0.5004
0.3328
RKHS distributional complexity
11.935
9.865
TABLE IV: Numerical comparison between rigid and compliant models.
Fig. 1: The ‘Ecce’ robot.
Fig. 2: Hierarchy connecting morphology to information-processing complexity. Morphology determines the geometry of the viable state space Dv and can simultaneously modify the probability measure P induced by the dynamics over that space. The scalar volume W(Dv) provides a zeroth-order descriptor of support size, whereas the RKHS mean embedding μP and covariance operator CP retain information about the statistical organization of the viable dynamics. The resulting distributional complexity C(P)=logdetF(I+γCP) therefore depends on the metric–measure structure of the viable dynamics rather than on scalar phase–space volume alone.
Mechanical intelligence, loosely defined as the reduction in control burden afforded by a robot's physical form, has become a prominent concept in robotics, with instantiations in bioinspired robotics, soft robotics, robotic swarms, and many other areas. However, rigorous theoretical understanding and quantitative measures of mechanical intelligence have lagged behind the engineering systems that the community has developed. In this work, using modern legged robots as a benchmark and exemplar, we propose several information-theoretic metrics for quantifying mechanical intelligence. By viewing body dynamics as both a computational process and a communication channel, we show that several prior insights in legged-robot engineering can be described using information theory, and we quantify how bits are processed by mechanical modes and across robot coordinates. Specifically, we examine the trade-off between explicitly incorporating compliance through series-elastic actuation and using so-called proprioceptive, low-gear-ratio transmissions, and we explore how these mechanisms interact with control policies during locomotion. We develop these results on systems of increasing complexity: a simplified linear model of a robot-leg transmission, a nonlinear single-leg simulation, and simulated quadruped robots controlled by a learned policy while navigating challenging terrain. These results lay the groundwork for broader study of robot mechanisms and their role in embodied computation.
Zach J. Patterson
Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Case Western Reserve University
Robots working in unstructured or partially unobservable environments must combine accurate motion with physical compliance that can passively correct contact misalignment. Soft robots provide this compliance but have struggled to precisely control their tip compliance and position. This paper presents a robot architecture designed around that control problem: a 7-link arm whose six articulated joints provide twelve independently driven revolute axes, each actuated by an antagonistic pair of pneumatic muscles, so that every axis can simultaneously change its angle and linearly adjust its stiffness. The rigid articulated backbone makes the tip compliance and position of the arm predictable enough to be commanded quantitatively in real time. The robot employs a unified iterative inverse-kinematics and inverse-compliance controller to achieve simultaneous, quantitative control of both compliance and position. The task-space compliance and kinematics models and the control law are derived and verified on both the physical arm and a matched simulation. Simulation is then used to study how the same framework extends to other arm morphologies. Finally, the arm demonstrates tasks that have been difficult for both rigid and soft arms: rejecting disturbances while writing on a moving whiteboard, and passively correcting hidden misalignment during a key-insertion and drawer-opening task. That these tasks succeed under so straightforward a controller is evidence for the advantage of this algorithm-informed structural design.
Runze Zuo, Tianhua Zou, Naike Wu +2
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Humanoid controllers need the ability to yield to external forces while retaining the capacity to resume their original tasks. However, tracking objectives penalize the deviations needed for yielding, while relaxing tracking goals persistently can make task recovery harder. Existing approaches often rely on task-specific interaction command interfaces or constructed compliant motion data and reference trajectories, limiting the direct reuse of their compliance-training mechanisms across different task interfaces. We introduce CompliantBot, a compliance-training framework for motion tracking and velocity-command locomotion. It preserves the original task inputs and requires no preconstructed compliant data or target trajectories. A state-dependent interaction force field couples applied loads to the robot's motion, enabling local articulation and whole-body movement to change the forces experienced. A complementary force-magnitude reward encourages lower interaction loads, while task rewards are downweighted during loading and restored after release to coordinate yielding and task resumption. The trained policies use task inputs and proprioceptive history without explicit external-force measurements. Across both task interfaces, CompliantBot yields farther under constant pulls and experiences lower spring interaction loads than matched baselines, while resuming task tracking after force removal. CompliantBot achieves the highest task completion among the compared methods under stronger pulls. Power evaluations further show that CompliantBot has the lowest mean joint mechanical power among the compared methods. Real-robot demonstrations further illustrate compliant responses through arm motion, stepping, and body reorientation.
Haoyang Li, Keqi Zhu, Zhanxiang Cao +4
Department of Automation, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China · Shanghai Innovation Institute, Shanghai, China · Department of Computer Science, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, China +1